![]() |
|
|
2 Nutrition and Health Sciences Program, Emory University, Atlanta, GA; 3 Hubert Department of Global Health, Rollins School of Public Health, Emory University, Atlanta, GA; and 4 A2Z, the USAID Micronutrient and Child Blindness Program, Academy for Educational Development (AED), Washington, DC
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: rmart77{at}sph.emory.edu.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Although national estimates of the incidence of neural tube defects (NTD)4 are unavailable for Guatemala, the rate is estimated to be high in certain areas of the country. The Epidemiological Research Center in Sexual and Reproductive Health (CIESAR) in Guatemala reports neural tube defects rates of 106 per 10,000 live births in Quetzaltenango, a city located in the Guatemalan highlands (Dr. Edgar Kestler, CIESAR, personal communication).
Low maternal plasma folate is associated with a higher risk of NTD (3). Daily supplementation with folic acid (400 µg) during early pregnancy decreases the risk of neural tube defects (3–5). Also, fortification of food with folic acid has been shown to improve folate status in women, which is linked to reduced rates of neural tube defects in the United States, Chile, and Costa Rica (6–14).
Fortification, supplementation, and control of intestinal helminthic infections are among several strategies to combat iron deficiency. Several trials found that the consumption of iron-fortified staple foods or condiments improves iron status. Among the products studied were iron-fortified fish sauce (15), salt fortified with microencapsulated iron, iodine, and vitamin A (16), iron-fortified curry powder (17), iron-fortified soy sauce (18), iron-fortified milk and drinking water (19), and sugar fortified with vitamin A and iron (20). Information about the effectiveness of iron fortified flours is limited. An analysis of anemia in school-aged children suggested that fortification of wheat and corn flour in Venezuela in 1993 improved iron status and reduced anemia (18,21). Comparisons between countries with similar diets with or without iron-fortified flour suggest that flour fortification may be effective in decreasing anemia rates; for example, Chile, where flour is fortified with ferrous sulfate, has lower anemia rates than Argentina, where flour is not fortified (22).
Several Central American countries, including Guatemala, began to fortify wheat flour with iron in the early 1960s at a level of 28.7–36.6 mg/kg using reduced elemental iron (23). In the early 1990s, and in response to the persistently high prevalence of iron deficiency in the region, the level of fortification was increased to 50–60 mg/kg but in the form of atomized elemental iron. Unfortunately, this form of iron, which is iron ground to the same particle size as reduced iron, has extremely poor bioavailability. In 2002, all Central American countries agreed on uniform standards for fortification of wheat flour with iron, folic acid, thiamin, riboflavin, and niacin. Guatemala currently fortifies wheat flour with ferrous fumarate (45 mg/kg), a better fortificant than previously used, as well as with folic acid (1.8 mg/kg), thiamin (6.2 mg/kg), riboflavin (4.2 mg/kg), and niacin (55 mg/kg) (23). Routine monitoring indicates that wheat flour is being fortified at the specified fortification levels [C. Martinez, Instituto de Nutrición de Centro América y Panamá (INCAP), personal communication]. Though anemia rates decreased between 1998 and 2002 in Guatemala, it is unlikely that this was due to wheat flour fortification, because atomized elemental iron was used during this period (23).
Objective. We evaluated the potential impact of wheat flour fortification in Guatemala by estimating household consumption of wheat flour and ready-made breads among different socioeconomic groups, residences (urban vs. rural), and ethnic groups (indigenous vs. nonindigenous). We also explored whether fortification of additional food vehicles, such as pasta or rice, has the potential to further increase iron and folate intakes in more vulnerable populations. We addressed 2 primary programmatic questions: 1) who purchases and therefore consumes and benefits from fortified wheat flour foods in Guatemala? and 2) do other foods exist that are suitable fortification vehicles for targeting vulnerable populations?
| Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
We analyzed the following questions from the ENCOVI survey: "Did you purchase (food item) in the past 12 mo?" and "How much (food item) did you purchase in the last 15 d?" Data were weighted and analyzed accordingly so that appropriate population estimates could be made. Per capita food purchases were estimated by dividing the weight or quantity of food purchased per household per day by household adult equivalent units. To account for differences in gender and age composition in different households, we calculated household adult equivalent units using the INCAP daily energy requirement and household composition information in the survey (26). We designated the energy requirement of an 18 to 64-y-old male as the reference and weighted other age and gender groups based on their specific energy requirements. For example, 18 to 64-y-old men were assigned a weight of 1; 18 to 64-y-old women a weight of 0.677; and 10 to 11-y-old females a weight of 0.612. Household adult equivalent units were obtained by adding together all individual adult equivalent units in the household. Although these are technically "male" adult equivalent units, these values are conventionally known as "adult" equivalent units.
Household ethnicity was assigned based on the head of household's ethnicity, and socioeconomic status was as defined by the World Bank and based on levels of household purchasing power, with households classified as nonpoor, poor, or extremely poor (27,28). Households that could not afford to purchase the minimum "food basket" that supplied the minimum recommended energy per person per day were classified as extremely poor. Households that could purchase the minimum food basket plus a small amount of nonfood goods and services were classified as poor. And nonpoor-classified households could purchase the minimum food basket, plus nonfood goods and services.
Fortified wheat flour equivalents (FWFE) were estimated as the amount of fortified wheat flour contained in different breads. We assumed that sweet bread is composed of 65% wheat flour and that French rolls and sliced bread contain 77% wheat flour. Pasta, made from semolina, is not made from fortified flour. Median and mean per capita intakes of iron and folic acid were estimated by multiplying the fortification level by the amount of FWFE purchased per capita; intrinsic iron or folate, or the content naturally present in wheat flour, was not included.
Next, the percentage of iron and folate needs of women of reproductive age was estimated by expressing median nutrient intakes for women from fortification as a percentage of dietary recommendations. Women were selected as the group of interest because they, along with young children, are at greatest risk of anemia. Young children were not selected because their diets may differ markedly from those of the family.
A recent report from the WHO recommends the use of the estimated average requirement (EAR) for estimating nutrient contributions from fortification in populations (29). However, because of the pronounced right-skewed nature of iron requirements for menstruating women, the committee used the recommended nutrient intake (RNI), or the equivalent concept of the recommended dietary allowance (RDA), for this purpose. Although the RDA/RNI level is a better reference than the EAR for assessing the relative contribution of fortification to meeting the iron needs of women with high iron requirements, it underestimates the contribution of fortification in the case of other women. Neither of the levels is an ideal reference point and it becomes useful to examine the range of results obtained when both levels are used. The use of the RDA/RNI level will also underestimate the contribution of fortification in meeting the needs for iron, relative to those of folic acid and other nutrients for which the committee recommends the use of EAR levels. Thus, the contributions of fortification to satisfying iron needs were estimated relative to both EAR and RDA values and for consistency; this was done for folic acid as well. All reference values were taken or derived from Institute of Medicine reports (30,31).
Iron bioavailability is likely to be lower in Guatemalan diets than in diets of developed countries because of the common consumption of high-phytate foods. Because no specific bioavailability information is available for Guatemala, we estimated the proportion of the EAR and RDA for iron that was met by fortified wheat flour based on 2 levels of dietary bioavailability: 5% or 10%, denoted as poor and intermediate bioavailability, respectively, by FAO and WHO (29). Based on dietary patterns, it is likely that the bioavailability of iron may be poor in extremely poor and poor households and intermediate in nonpoor households. Diets in developed countries are assumed by FAO and WHO to have a bioavailability of 15%, a level that we considered unlikely for Guatemala. To estimate EAR levels at 5% and 10% bioavailability, the 50th percentile value of absorbed iron needs of adult, menstruating women (1.4 mg/d) was divided by 0.05 and 0.10, which yields EAR values of 28.2 and 14.1 mg/d, respectively. Similarly, the 97.5 percentile of absorbed iron needs (3.15 mg/d) was used to estimate RDA levels for adult menstruating women assuming 5% and 10% bioavailability, which yielded the values of 63.0 and 31.5 mg/d, respectively. We also estimated the contribution of wheat flour fortification to meeting the EAR and RDA for folate for women proposed by the Institute of Medicine: 320 µg/d and 400 µg/d of dietary folate equivalents (DFE), respectively (30). Based on the assumption that 1 µg folic acid = 1.7 µg DFE, the EAR and RDA values become 188 and 235 µg/d of folic acid (32). Finally, in estimating the percentage of EAR and RDA met for iron and folic acid, we expressed the nutrient contribution per adult equivalent unit multiplied by 0.677, the adult equivalent unit for women, as a percentage of the EAR and RDA for women.
Sample weights were taken into account and the statistical analyses were conducted using SAS 9.1 (SAS Institute). Due to the skewed distribution, we present both mean and median values for per capita purchases of foods made from fortified flour; for the same reason, we present median and interquartile range values (25th and 75th percentiles) when estimating the percentage of the EAR for iron and folic acid met through fortification.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
A high proportion of households purchased pasta (69%) and rice (79%) in the previous 15 d, and proportions did not differ appreciably among socioeconomic and ethnic groups and residence (Table 1). Median per capita purchases of pasta were
15 g/d, and were lowest in extremely poor households (Table 2). Median per capita purchases of rice were 24 g/d and were also lowest in extremely poor households. Overall, a high proportion of households across all socioeconomic groups and residences purchased rice and pasta in the previous 12 mo.
Eight percent of households purchased corn flour in the previous 15 d (Table 1). Per capita purchases of corn flour were low [6 g/(person · d)] and varied among different socioeconomic groups, residence types, and ethnicities (Table 2).
We examined iron and folic acid amounts contributed by fortification per adult equivalent unit, as well as the estimated contribution to the daily EAR and RDA for adult menstruating women, by demographic characteristics (Table 3). Fortification provided median values of 2.3 mg of iron and 90 µg of folic acid per day per adult equivalent unit. Assuming a low level of bioavailability (5%), the fortification program provided
12% of the EAR and 5% of the RDA for iron among women from nonpoor communities, and <3% of EAR and RDA values among women of poor and extremely poor communities. At intermediate levels of bioavailability (10%), the contribution of iron from fortification doubled but the contribution of fortification was still 5% or less of the EAR and RDA values for iron among rural and indigenous women. Overall, fortification contributed 6% of the EAR for iron assuming poor bioavailability and 11% assuming intermediate bioavailability; corresponding values for the percentage of RDA levels met were 2% for poor and 5% for intermediate bioavailability.
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The strengths of our analysis include the use of a nationally representative survey with a large sample size that includes information on sociodemographic characteristics and food purchases. This information allowed us to quantify the consumption of particular foods by various subgroups of the population. The strengths outweigh the limitations of our approach and the results provide indirect but useful measures of dietary impact that can contribute to policy formulation and program design. In fact, our approach offers a useful model for countries that have national expenditure data but not dietary data, which is not an uncommon situation.
In countries in transition, such as Chile, where compulsory wheat flour fortification programs have proven successful, clearly for folate (6,8) and indirectly for iron (23), the per capita consumption of wheat flour (mainly as bread) is several times greater than median per capita consumption of wheat flour in Guatemala. Chile currently fortifies wheat flour with ferrous sulfate (30 mg iron/kg), folic acid (2.2 mg/kg), thiamin, riboflavin, and niacin (13,33). The per capita consumption of fortified wheat flour (primarily as bread) in Chilean women was estimated to be 219 g/d, yielding an estimated daily intake of 427 µg/d of folic acid (8). For Guatemala, we estimate that women consumed 34 grams per day of fortified wheat flour, which contributed 61 µg of folic acid (nutrient contribution per adult equivalent unit from Table 3 multiplied by 0.677 to convert values to women equivalent units). Estimates of the daily contribution of iron from fortification to the diets of women are 6.6 mg for Chile and 1.6 mg for Guatemala. In addition, the absorption of iron is likely better in the Chilean than the Guatemalan diet due to lower consumption of iron absorption inhibitors. This case illustrates the importance of context in determining the effectiveness of fortification programs.
Venezuela introduced mandatory corn and wheat flour fortification programs, mostly with ferrous fumarate, in 1993 (18). Per capita intakes of corn and wheat flour in 1999 were estimated to be 84 and 104 grams per day, respectively (34). Although consumption of wheat flour in Venezuela was not as great as per capita consumption in Chile, compulsory fortification of corn and wheat flours seems to have restored the iron status of adolescents of low socioeconomic status to levels found in cohorts examined prior to a pronounced economic crisis that altered food consumption patterns. Iron deficiency (serum ferritin < 12 µg/L) affected 14.1% of adolescents of low socioeconomic status living in Caracas in 1989–90 before the economic crisis developed fully, reached a level of 36.6% in 1992 at the height of the crisis, and was 15.8% in 1994 after fortification and despite continuation of the crisis. The corresponding values in these cohorts for anemia were 3.6%, 19.0% and 9.3%, respectively. Although other factors might have contributed to this reduction in anemia and iron deficiency in 1994, fortification of wheat and corn flours likely played a key role.
A motivation for this analysis was the paucity of information about the effectiveness of flour fortification. Despite the limitations inherent in using household food purchase data, strong inferences can be made from the results that can be useful to guide policies and programs to combat iron deficiency and prevent NTDs. Fortified wheat flour appears to be an important source of folic acid for nonpoor, urban, and nonindigenous populations. We estimate that fortified wheat flour supplied 71% and 78% of the EAR for folate for nonpoor and urban women, respectively. Given these estimates, it is likely that the contribution of wheat flour fortification to the intake of other B vitamins such as thiamin, riboflavin, and niacin was also important. However, fortification had more limited potential impact on iron intakes, even in the case of urban, nonindigenous and nonpoor households. For example, we estimate that fortification met only 24% and 11% of EAR and RDA levels, respectively in women of nonpoor households at an intermediate level of bioavailability (10%). Given the large burden of anemia in Guatemala, one would have hoped for greater impact. Unfortunately, the level of iron cannot be increased further in wheat flour, and therefore other food vehicles or interventions will be necessary to build on the achievements of the wheat flour fortification program. If pasta and rice were fortified with iron, the situation would improve little because the median consumption of these foods in Guatemala is low (15 to 24 g/d, respectively), particularly considering the levels of iron that can be added to these foods. Pasta and rice may be effective candidates to deliver other nutrients, such as water soluble vitamins, but they are not good vehicles for appreciably increasing iron intakes. However, just because a major biological impact would not be expected, this does not mean that iron should not be added to pasta and rice; it should, and, given the nature of the problem of iron deficiency in Guatemala, it should be added with urgency.
Thus, despite iron fortification with a good bioavailable compound (ferrous fumarate), the consumption of wheat flour in Guatemala is not high enough to expect a major impact on the iron status of women. However, males and school age children may benefit more than women because their needs are half or less, whereas their wheat flour consumption may be similar. Analyses of dietary intake data are required to properly assess differential impact of fortification by sex and age.
Corn is the main staple in Guatemala; people living in poor, rural areas consume a more traditional diet consisting of corn products, both ground as masa (dough) in village mills and produced industrially. Currently, industrially produced corn flour is fortified with 30 mg/kg iron from ferrous fumarate (lime-treated, nixtamalized corn flour); however, a large segment of the Guatemalan population does not have access to industrially produced corn flour and consumes corn flour ground as masa in village mills (35). Our results indicate that very little corn flour is purchased as such by households; this is likely an underestimate of industrial flour consumption because some households may purchase ready-made tortillas made from industrial flour. The lack of information about the type of flour used in ready-made tortillas, which can be purchased from stores or households in the neighborhood, prevents further analysis of the potential contribution of fortified corn flour. However, we judge the potential contribution to be minor, given that corn flour contains large amounts of phytic acid, which interferes with iron absorption and results in poor iron bioavailability (36). Finally, fortification of corn ground as masa in small village mills is not feasible because of the large number of small mills throughout the country.
In conclusion, the flour fortification program of Guatemala is probably making an important contribution to improving folate intakes in all but poor, rural, indigenous households. On the other hand, the potential contribution to the prevention of iron deficiency in women is modest, even for the more privileged groups (nonpoor, urban, and nonindigenous households). This does not mean that the flour fortification program has no value; quite the contrary; the program should be supported and monitored closely to ensure compliance and quality of the fortified products. Also, other vehicles such as pastas and rice should be fortified when feasible, even if the increase to nutrient intakes is not large. Importantly, attention must be given to improving the effectiveness of other programs, such as iron/folic acid supplementation prior to and during pregnancy, and with particular attention to the less-privileged sectors of Guatemalan society.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
4 Abbreviations used: EAR, estimated average requirement; ENCOVI, Encuesta de Condiciones de Vida; FWFE, fortified wheat flour equivalents; RDA, recommended dietary allowance. ![]()
Manuscript received 19 September 2006. Initial review completed 12 October 2006. Revision accepted 3 January 2007.
| LITERATURE CITED |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1. Yip R. Iron deficiency and anemia. In: Semba R, Bloem M, editors. Nutrition and health in developing countries. Totowa, NJ: Humana Press; 2001. p. 327–42.
2. MSPAS. Encuesta nacional de salud materno infantil 2002. Instituto Nacional de Estadistica. 2002; p. 197, 199.
3. Daly L, Kirke P, Molloy A, Weir D, Scott J. Folate levels and neural tube Defects. JAMA. 1995;274:1698–702.
4. Berry RJ, Li Z, Erickson JD, Li S, Moore CA, Wang H, Mulinare J, Zhao P, Wong LYC, et al. Prevention of neural-tube defects with folic acid in China. N Engl J Med. 1999;341:1485–90.
5. Werler M, Shapiro S, Mitchell A. Periconceptional folic acid exposure and risk of occurent neural tube defects. JAMA. 1993;269:1257–61.
6. Castilla EE, Orioli IM, Lopez-Camelo JS, Dutra MG, Nazer-Herrera J. Preliminary data on changes in neural tube defect prevalence rates after folic acid fortification in South America. Am J Med Genet A. 2003;123A:123–8.[Medline]
7. Honein M, Paulozzi L, Mathews TJ, Erickson D, Wong LY. Impact of folic acid fortification of the US food supply on the occurrence of neural tube defects. JAMA. 2001;285:2981–6.
8. Hertrampf E, Cortes F, Erickson D, Cayazzo M, Freire W, Bailey L, Howson C, Kauwell G, Pfeiffer C. Consumption of folic acid-fortified bread improves folate status in women of reproductive age in Chile. J Nutr. 2003;133:3166–9.
9. Lawrence J, Petitti D, Watkins M, Umekubo M. Trends in serum folate after food fortification. Lancet. 1999;354:915–6.[Medline]
10. Tacsan Chen L. Fewer neural tube defects in Costa Rica following food fortification. Nutriview. 2003; 3–4.
11. Chen LT, Rivera MA. The Costa Rican experience: reduction of neural tube defects following food fortification programs. Nutr Rev. 2004;62:S40–3.[Medline]
12. Feinleib M, Beresford SAA, Bowman BA, Mills JL, Rader JI, Selhub J, Yetley A, Folate E. Fortification for the prevention of birth defects: case study. Am J Epidemiol. 2001;154:S60–9.
13. Hertrampf E, Cortes F. Folic acid fortification of wheat flour: Chile. Nutr Rev. 2004;62:S44–8.[Medline]
14. Mills, JL, Signore, C. Neural tube defect rates before and after food fortification with folic acid. Birth Defects Res A Clin Mol Teratol. 2004;70:844–5.[Medline]
15. Thuy PV, Berger J, Davidsson L, Khan NC, Lam NT, Cook JD, Hurrell RF, Khoi HH. Regular consumption of NaFeEDTA-fortified fish sauce improves iron status and reduces the prevalence of anemia in anemic Vietnamese women. Am J Clin Nutr. 2003;78:284–90.
16. Zimmermann MB, Wegmueller R, Zeder C, Chaouki N, Biebinger R, Hurrell RF, Windhab E. Triple fortification of salt with microcapsules of iodine, iron, and vitamin A. Am J Clin Nutr. 2004;80:1283–90.
17. Ballot D, MacPhail A, Bothwell T, Gillooly M, Mayet FG. Fortification of curry powder with NaFe(111)EDTA in an iron-deficient population: report of a controlled iron-fortification trial. Am J Clin Nutr. 1989;49:162–9.
18. Mannar V, Gallego E. Iron fortification: country level experiences and lessons learned. J Nutr. 2002;132:856S–8S.
19. Beinner MA, Lamounier JA. Recent experience with fortification of foods and beverages with iron for the control of iron-deficiency anemia in Brazilian children. Food Nutr Bull. 2003;24:268–74.[Medline]
20. Viteri FE, Alvarez E, Batres R, Torun B, Pineda O, Mejia LA, Sylvi J. Fortification of sugar with iron sodium ethylenediaminotetraacetate (FeNaEDTA) improves iron status in semirural Guatemalan populations. Am J Clin Nutr. 1995;61:1153–63.
21. Layrisse M, Chaves JF, Mendez-Castellano H, Bosch V, Tropper E, Bastardo B, Gonzalez E. Early response to the effect of iron fortification in the Venezuelan population. Am J Clin Nutr. 1996;64:903–7.
22. Allen LH. New approaches for designing and evaluating food fortification programs. J Nutr. 2006;136:1055–8.
23. Dary O. Lessons learned with iron fortification in Central America. Nutr Rev. 2002;60:S30–3.[Medline]
24. Encuesta Nacional Sobre Condiciones de Vida – ENCOVI. Available at: www.ine.gob.gt/encuestas_encovi.html.
25. Encuesta de Condiciones de Vida (ENCOVI) [Guatemalan living standards measurement survey]. Instituto Nacional de Estadística of Guatemala. Available at: http://www.ine.gob.gt/productos.html.
26. Menchu T, Osegueda O. La canasta basica de alimentos en Centro America. Guatemala City: Organizacion Panamericana de la Salud, Instituto de Nutrición de Centro América y Panamá. 2002; p. 57.
27. Poverty in Guatemala. World Bank, Washington (DC). 2003. Available at: http://wbln0018.worldbank.org/LAC/LACInfoClient.nsf/8d6661f6799ea8a48525673900537f95/eeba795e0f22768d85256ce700772165/$FILE/GUAPA%20-%20annex%203.pdf
28. The Magnitude and Causes of Poverty. World Bank, Washington (DC). Available at: http://wbln0018.worldbank.org/LAC/LACInfoClient.nsf/8d6661f6799ea8a48525673900537f95/eeba795e0f22768d85256ce700772165/$FILE/GUAPA%20-%20chap%202.pdf
29. Allen L, de Benoist B, Dary O, Hurrell R., eds. WHO guidelines on food fortification with micronutrients. Department of Nutrition for Health and Development. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2006.
30. Dietary reference intakes for thiamin, riboflavin, niacin, vitamin B6, folate, vitamin B12, pantothenic acid, biotin, and choline. Washington (DC): National Academies Press; 1998.
31. Dietary reference intakes for vitamin A, vitamin K, arsenic, boron, chromium, copper, iodine, iron, manganese, molybdenum, nickel, silicon, vanadium, and zinc. Washington (DC): National Academies Press; 2000.
32. Baily LB. Dietary reference intakes for folate: the debut of dietary folate equivalents. Nutr Rev. 1998;56:294–9.[Medline]
33. Hertrampf E. Iron fortification in the Americas. Nutr Rev. 2002;60:S22–5.[Medline]
34. García-Casal MN, Layrisse M. Iron fortification of flours in Venezuela. Nutr Rev. 2002;60:S26–9.[Medline]
35. Dary O. Staple food fortification with iron: a multifactorial decision. Nutr Rev. 2002;60:S34–41.[Medline]
36. Hernandez M, Sousa V, Moreno A, Villapando S, Lopez-Alarcon M. Iron bioavailability and utilization in rats are lower from lime-treated corn flour than from wheat flour when they are fortified with different sources of iron. J Nutr. 2003;133:154–9.
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
P. Nguyen, R. Grajeda, P. Melgar, J. Marcinkevage, R. Flores, and R. Martorell Weekly May Be as Efficacious as Daily Folic Acid Supplementation in Improving Folate Status and Lowering Serum Homocysteine Concentrations in Guatemalan Women J. Nutr., August 1, 2008; 138(8): 1491 - 1498. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||