![]() |
|
|


,**

* TNO Prevention and Health, Gaubius Laboratory, Leiden, The Netherlands;
Departments of General Internal Medicine and
** Cardiology, Leiden University Medical Center, Leiden, The Netherlands; and
Institut de Récherche sur la Biologie de lInsecte, University F. Rabelais, Tours, France
2To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: jmg.princen{at}pg.tno.nl.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
KEY WORDS: garlic lipids cholesterol synthesis lipoprotein metabolism APOE*3-Leiden transgenic mice
Garlic is widely used in preventive cardiovascular medicine. Recent studies report that garlic has beneficial effects on risk factors associated with cardiovascular disease, including modulation of plasma lipid levels (13). Confirming these reports, previous studies with rabbits and rats treated with garlic also report a modulation of plasma lipids, caused by a decrease in concentrations of plasma cholesterol and triglycerides and markers of cholesterol synthesis and absorption (412). In addition, human studies report a decrease in plasma cholesterol and triglyceride levels after garlic treatment (2,13,14). Studies with cultured rat hepatocytes suggest that the inhibition of cholesterol synthesis at least partly explains the possible hypolipidemic effect of garlic (15,16). Conversely, numerous animal and human studies report that garlic treatment does not affect plasma lipids (13,17, 18, 19). These conflicting data may, at least in part, be due to the use of different garlic-derived materials. The in vitro, in vivo, and human studies used a wide variety of garlic-derived materials, including water- and lipid-soluble garlic extracts, aged garlic extract, garlic oil, garlic powders, garlic-derived sulfur-containing compounds (i.e., S-allylcysteine, alliin, and allicin), and a metabolite (i.e., diallyldisulfide). In addition, the garlic-derived materials often were produced using nonstandardized procedures and were poorly chemically characterized. Experimental designs and models differed widely among the studies. Studies were conducted with rats, rabbits, or mice with or without cholesterol feeding; normolipidemic and hyperlipidemic human subjects; and coronary heart disease patients, as well as pregnant subjects. Hence, it is difficult to determine whether garlic truly modulates plasma lipids under conditions relevant to human patients.
The present study evaluated the possible hypolipidemic effects of the garlic-derived sulfur-containing compound allicin, the allicin metabolite diallyldisulfide (DADS),3 and powdered kwai and morado garlic (2 varieties that are well characterized chemically) in mice, under highly standardized conditions that approximate a human model. Allicin and DADS were selected based on the evidence that they might cause the beneficial effects of garlic on lipid metabolism (Fig. 1) (20,21). Commercially available kwai garlic powder was chosen as a standard because it was used in previous garlic studies (2,3,9,10,14). The European variety morado was selected because it was fertilized with higher levels of sulfur during cultivation. All garlic-derived materials were produced under highly standardized procedures and were well characterized chemically. The experiments were conducted with APOE*3-Leiden transgenic mice, a mouse model of mild hyperlipidemia that allows the titration of plasma lipids to selected levels relevant to conditions in humans by the addition of cholesterol and fat to the diet (22). Furthermore, the effects of dietary intervention with nutritional compounds such as fish oil, cafestol, or stanol esters and of treatment with hypolipidemic drugs such as statins and fibrates on plasma lipid and lipoprotein concentrations in APOE*3-Leiden mice are comparable to those in humans (2325). APOE*3-Leiden mice were fed a nonpurified diet for 4 wk (basal conditions in which endogenous cholesterol synthesis was not suppressed), followed by a Western diet for 8 wk (mild hyperlipidemic conditions in which endogenous cholesterol synthesis was suppressed); both diets were supplemented with the garlic-derived materials.
|
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Garlic-derived materials.
Five groups of APOE*3-Leiden mice were fed either a control diet; the garlic-derived sulfur-containing compound allicin (University F. Rabelais), mixed in the drinking water (0.29 g · L1); the allicin metabolite DADS (University F. Rabelais), mixed in the diet (0.27 g · kg1); or powdered kwai (Lichtwer) or morado (INRA) garlic, mixed in the diet (42 g · kg1). We assumed that a mouse weighs 20 g and consumes 3 mL of water and 3 g of food daily (for both the nonpurified and Western diets). In addition, we assumed that 1 mol of allicin is converted into 1 mol of DADS, and that kwai and morado garlic powder have similar alliin content and allicin liberation capacity (i.e., 1.7 and 0.7%, respectively, for kwai, per data provided by the manufacturer). Based on these assumptions, the amounts of garlic-derived materials provided were expected to supply a dosage of allicin or allicin equivalent to 44 mg · kg body wt1 · d1. The experimental doses were calculated during the experiment, taking into consideration food and water intake, body weight, and garlic powder composition. As determined for rats given free access to food, 44 mg · kg body wt1 · d1 of dietary allicin or allicin equivalent is well tolerated (personal communication, M. H. Siess, INRA). The garlic powders were analyzed by a standard HPLC procedure (26) to determine the alliin content, allicin liberation capacity, and
-glutamyl-S-allylcysteine and
-glutamyl-1-propenylcysteine content of each variety.
Plasma lipids, lipoproteins, and alanine aminotransferase. After food deprivation for 4 h (0700 to 1100 h), blood samples were collected from each mouse by tail bleeding. Plasma total cholesterol and triglyceride levels were measured enzymatically, using commercially available kits (No. C0534 and No. 337-B; Sigma Diagnostics). Size fractionation of the plasma lipoproteins was performed using a Smart system (Pharmacia) as previously described (24). Plasma alanine aminotransferase (ALAT) concentration was measured enzymatically (ALAT test; Roche Diagnostics).
Markers of whole-body cholesterol synthesis and intestinal sterol absorption. Plasma intermediates of cholesterol synthesis (lathosterol, lanosterol, and squalene) were used as markers of whole-body cholesterol synthesis, and plant sterols (campesterol and ß-sitosterol) were used as markers of intestinal sterol uptake. Plasma concentrations of these markers were determined as previously described (24).
Statistical analysis. All data are presented as means ± SD. Data were analyzed using the Mann-Whitney U test. Food intake data were analyzed by repeated measures for the nonpurified and Western diet testing periods. Differences were considered significant at values of P < 0.05.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-glutamyl-S-allylcysteine content, compared with kwai (1.29 vs. 1.36%). However, morado had a higher
-glutamyl-1-propenylcysteine content, compared with kwai (2.14 vs. 1.31%). The food intake and body weight of mice fed nonpurified and Western diets supplemented with allicin, kwai, and morado did not differ from those of the control group (data not shown). The DADS group had 10% lower body weight after 8 wk of consuming the Western diet, compared with controls (21.0 ± 1.5 vs. 23.3 ± 2.8 g, P = 0.005). This lower body weight was associated with reduced food intake (2.6 ± 0.3 vs. 3.2 ± 0.3 g · mouse1 · d1, P = 0.049). Water intake did not differ among groups (2.93.0 mL · mouse1 · d1).
The true allicin-equivalent dose was calculated from the food and water intake, body weight, and garlic powder composition data for each group (Table 1). The morado group received a lower experimental dose than the other treatment groups over both diet testing periods, as expected (Table 1). This was mainly due to the lower allicin liberation capacity of morado powder, compared with kwai powder (Table 1).
|
|
Markers of whole-body cholesterol synthesis and intestinal sterol absorption. Control levels of the whole-body cholesterol synthesis markers squalene, lathosterol, and lanosterol in mice fed the nonpurified diet were 1.0 ± 0.3, 0.3 ± 0.1, and 0.4 ± 0.1 µmol · mmol plasma cholesterol1, respectively. Control levels of the intestinal sterol absorption markers ß-sitosterol and campesterol were 8.6 ± 0.5 and 31.1 ± 3.3 µmol · mmol plasma cholesterol1, respectively. As expected, switching the mice from the nonpurified (cholesterol-free) diet to the Western (cholesterol-containing) diet markedly decreased plasma concentrations of squalene, lathosterol, lanosterol, ß-sitosterol, and campesterol (by 50, 69, 50, 79, and 97%, respectively). These data indicated that increasing the amount of cholesterol in the diet decreased both endogenous cholesterol synthesis and the uptake of dietary sterols. In addition, plasma concentrations of the synthesis and uptake markers did not differ between the nonpurified and Western diet periods for any treatment group (data not shown). Hence, the allicin, DADS, kwai, and morado dietary treatments did not affect endogenous cholesterol synthesis and intestinal sterol absorption in the current experiment.
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
All treatment groups ingested an equal amount of allicin, either in its pure form, in the form of its bioactive metabolite DADS, or in the form of its precursor alliin (in powdered kwai and morado garlic), equal to an allicin or allicin-equivalent dose of 3045 mg · kg body wt1 · d1 (Table 1). The present study demonstrated that allicin lacks a hypolipidemic effect in all these forms, at least at the maximum dose tolerated by mice with free access to food. The powdered kwai and morado garlic are complex mixtures that also contain the sulfur-rich compounds
-glutamyl-S-allylcysteine and
-glutamyl-1-propenylcysteine.
-Glutamyl-S-allylcysteine inhibits cholesterol synthesis in rat hepatocytes (16). The present study showed that the
-glutamyl-S-allylcysteine and
-glutamyl-1-propenylcysteine components of the garlic preparations do not modulate the hypolipidemic effect of allicin at the dosage applied, nor do they have hypolipidemic potential themselves. In addition, the kwai and morado preparations contained no other sulfur-rich or nonsulfur compounds with hypolipidemic properties.
The Western diet used in the present study contained 0.25% cholesterol by weight. Consumption of this low-cholesterol diet itself induces plasma cholesterol levels up to 10 mmol · L1 in APOE*3-Leiden mice. In contrast, it is difficult to induce hypercholesterolemia in normal mice, rats, and rabbits, and (mild) elevation of plasma cholesterol can be induced only by supplementing diets with high concentrations (1 to 2%) of cholesterol. Most hypolipidemic effects of garlic reported in mice, rats, and rabbits were observed under these extreme dietary cholesterol conditions, and the relevance of the outcome of these studies is debatable (4,610,12). Whether cholesterol intake is an important determinant of the outcome of a garlic study is subject to speculation. However, in this light it is noteworthy that most human studies, like the present transgenic mouse study, report a negative outcome regarding the effect of garlic on plasma lipid levels.
The postulated hypolipidemic effects of garlic are thought to be mediated via suppression of hepatic cholesterol synthesis (15,16). Cholesterol synthesis in mice (and in rodents in general) can easily be suppressed by dietary cholesterol (24). Also, in the current mouse model, cholesterol synthesis was suppressed by consumption of a diet containing only 0.25% cholesterol (see Results). As mentioned above, most studies with mice, rats, and rabbits that report a hypolipidemic effect of garlic used diets containing 1 to 2% cholesterol. Under these extreme conditions of dietary cholesterol, it seems unlikely that garlic could still induce hypolipidemic effects via suppression of endogenous cholesterol synthesis. Two recent human trials included markers for cholesterol synthesis in their plasma analysis (27,28). Bolstering the present data, these studies report no effect of garlic on these markers (27,28). In addition, they report no effect of garlic on plasma cholesterol.
The present study supports the conclusion that any beneficial effect of garlic on cardiovascular disease is not caused via modulation of plasma lipid levels. Whether garlic might exert other beneficial effects relevant to cardiovascular disease remains an open question. Several animal and human studies report that garlic may lower systolic blood pressure (12). However, as with plasma lipids, the literature reports conflicting data regarding blood pressure (3). In the current study, treatment with allicin, DADS, and kwai and morado garlic powder did not affect basal systolic blood pressure (99 ± 3 and 103 ± 8 mmHg for the nonpurified and Western diets, respectively), whereas previous studies reported that APOE*3-Leiden mice do respond to blood-pressure-lowering compounds such as the calcium antagonist amlodipine (unpublished data). Hence, the present data do not support the hypothesis that garlic exerts a beneficial effect on cardiovascular disease via modulation of systolic blood pressure.
In summary, this study found no hypolipidemic effect of garlic components and preparations. Further examination of the possible beneficial effects of garlic in cardiovascular disease by directly determining its effects on the progression of atherosclerotic disease is needed. Studying these effects under highly standardized conditions with a sensitive animal model that has a human-like lipid profile will enhance the relevance of the findings to humans. APOE*3-Leiden transgenic mice would be a helpful tool in this regard.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
3 Abbreviations used: ALAT, alanine aminotransferase; DADS, diallyldisulfide; INRA, Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique. ![]()
Manuscript received 19 December 2003. Initial review completed 18 January 2004. Revision accepted 25 February 2004.
| LITERATURE CITED |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1. Orekov, A. N. & Grunwald, J. (1997) Effects of garlic on atherosclerosis. Nutrition 13:656-663.[Medline]
2. Brace, L. D. (2002) Cardiovascular benefits of garlic (Allium sativum L). J. Cardiovasc. Nurs. 16:33-49.[Medline]
3. Banerjee, S. K. & Maulik, S. K. (2002) Effect of garlic on cardiovascular disorders: a review. Nutr. J. 1:1-14.[Medline]
4. Bordia, A. K. & Verma, S. K. (1978) Garlic on the reversibility of experimental atherosclerosis. Indian Heart J. 30:47-50.[Medline]
5. Eilat, S., Oestraicher, Y., Rabinkov, A., Ohad, D., Mirelman, D., Battler, A., Eldar, M. & Vered, Z. (1995) Alteration of lipid profile in hyperlipidemic rabbits by allicin, an active constituent of garlic. Coron. Artery Dis. 6:985-990.[Medline]
6. Ismail, M. F., Gad, M. Z. & Hamdy, M. A. (1999) Study of the hypolipidemic properties of pectin, garlic and ginseng in hypercholesterolemic rabbits. Pharmacol. Res. 39:157-166.[Medline]
7. Kwon, M. J., Song, Y. S., Choi, M. S., Park, S. J., Jeong, K. S. & Song, Y. O. (2003) Cholesteryl ester transfer protein activity and atherogenic parameters in rabbits supplemented with cholesterol and garlic powder. Life Sci. 16:2953-2964.
8. Chi, M. S., Koh, E. T. & Stewart, T. J. (1982) Effects of garlic on lipid metabolism in rats fed cholesterol or lard. J. Nutr. 112:241-248.
9. Heinle, H. & Betz, E. (1994) Effects of a dietary garlic supplementation in a rat model of atherosclerosis. Arzneim.-Forsch. 44:614-617.[Medline]
10. Ali, M., Al-Quattan, K. K., Al-Enezi, F., Khanafer, R. M. & Mustafa, T. (2000) Effect of allicin from garlic powder on serum lipids and blood pressure in rats fed with high cholesterol diet. Prostaglandins Leukot. Essent. Fatty Acids 62:253-259.[Medline]
11. Slowing, K., Ganado, P., Sanz, M., Ruiz, E. & Tejerina, T. (2001) Study of garlic extracts and fractions on plasma cholesterol levels and vascular reactivity in cholesterol-fed rats. J. Nutr. 131:994S-999S.
12. Augusti, K. T., Narayanan, A., Pillai, L. S., Ebrahim, R. S., Sivadasan, R., Sindhu, K. R., Subha, I., Abdeen, S. & Nair, S. S. (2001) Beneficial effects of garlic (Allium sativum Linn) on rats fed with diets containing cholesterol and either of the oil seeds, coconuts or groundnuts. Indian J. Exp. Biol. 39:660-667.[Medline]
13. Bordia, A., Verma, S. K. & Srivastava, K. C. (1997) Effect of garlic (Allium sativum) on blood lipids, blood sugar, fibrinogen and fibrinolytic activity in patients with coronary artery disease. Prostaglandins Leukot. Essent. Fatty Acids 58:257-263.
14. Chernyadeva, I. F., Shilnikova, S. V., Rogoza, A. N. & Kukharchuk, V. V. (2003) Dynamics of interrelationships between the content of lipoprotein particles, fibrinogen, and leukocyte count in the plasma from patients with coronary heart disease treated with kwai. Bull. Exp. Biol. Med. 135:436-439.[Medline]
15. Gebhardt, R. (1993) Multiple inhibitory effects of garlic extracts on cholesterol biosynthesis in hepatocytes. Lipids 28:613-619.[Medline]
16. Yeh, Y. Y. & Liu, L. (2001) Cholesterol-lowering effect of garlic extracts and organosulfur compounds: human and animal studies. J. Nutr. 131:989S-993S.
17. Mand, J. K., Gupta, P. P., Soni, G. L. & Singh, R. (1985) Effect of garlic on experimental atherosclerosis in rabbits. Indian Heart J. 37:183-188.[Medline]
18. Abramovitz, D., Gavri, S., Harats, D., Levkovitz, H., Mirelman, D., Miron, T., Eilat-Adar, S., Rabinkov, A. & Wilchek, M., et al (1999) Allicin-induced decrease in formation of fatty streaks (atherosclerosis) in mice fed a cholesterol-rich diet. Coron. Artery Dis. 10:515-519.[Medline]
19. Satitvipawee, P., Rawdaree, P., Indrabhakti, S., Ratanasuwan, T., Getn-gern, P. & Viwatwongkasem, C. (2003) No effect of garlic extract supplement on serum lipid levels in hypercholesterolemic subjects. J. Med. Assoc. Thai. 86:750-757.[Medline]
20. Kik, C., Kahane, R. & Gebhardt, R. (2001) Garlic and health. Nutr. Metb. Cardiovasc. Dis. 11:57-65.
21. Reuter, H. D. & Sendl, A. (1994) Allium sativum and Allium ursinum: chemistry, pharmacology and medicinal applications. Wagner, H. Farnsworth, N. R. eds. Economic and Medicinal Plant Research 6th ed. 1994:36-42 Academic Press London, UK. .
22. Van Vlijmen, B.J.M., van den Maagdenberg, A. M., Gijbels, M. J., van der Boom, H., HogenEsch, H., Frants, R. R., Hofker, M. H. & Havekes, L. M. (1994) Diet-induced hyperlipoproteinemia and atherosclerosis in apolipoprotein E3-Leiden transgenic mice. J. Clin. Invest. 93:1403-1410.
23. van Vlijmen, B. J., Mensink, R. P., van t Hof, H. B., Offermans, R. F., Hofker, M. H. & Havekes, L. M. (1998) Effects of dietary fish oil on serum lipids and VLDL kinetics in hyperlipidemic apolipoprotein APOE*3-Leiden transgenic mice. J. Lipid Res. 39:1181-1188.
24. Volger, O. L., van der Boom, H., de Wit, E. C., van Duyvenvoorde, W., Hornstra, G., Plat, J., Havekes, L. M., Mensink, R. P. & Princen, H. M. (2001) Dietary plant stanol esters reduce VLDL-cholesterol secretion and bile saturation in APOE*3-Leiden transgenic mice. Arterioscler. Thromb. Vasc. Biol. 21:1046-1052.
25. Delsing, D. J., Jukema, J. W., Emeis, J. J., van der Laarse, A., Havekes, L. M. & Princen, H. M. (2003) Differential effects of amlodipine and atorvastatin treatment and their combination on atherosclerosis in APOE*3-Leiden transgenic mice. J. Cardiovasc. Pharmacol. 42:63-70.[Medline]
26. Arnault, I., Christides, J. P., Mandon, N., Haffner, T., Kahane, R. & Auger, J. (2003) High-performance ion-pair chromatography method for simultaneous analysis of alliin, deoxyalliin, allicin and dipeptide precursors in garlic products using multiple mass spectrometry and UV detection. J. Chromatogr. A 991:69-75.[Medline]
27. Simons, L. A., Balasubramaniam, S., von Konigsmark, M., Parfitt, A., Simons, J. & Peters, W. (1995) On the effect of garlic on plasma lipids and lipoproteins in mild hypercholesterolaemia. Atherosclerosis 113:219-225.[Medline]
28. Berthold, H. K., Sudhop, T. & von Bergmann, K. (1998) Effect of a garlic oil preparation on serum lipoproteins and cholesterol metabolism: a randomized controlled trial. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 279:1900-1902.
29. Germain, E., Auger, J., Ginies, C., Siess, M. H. & Teyssier, C. (2002) In vivo metabolism of diallyldisulphide in the rat: identification of two new metabolites. Xenobiotica 32:1127-1138.[Medline]
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||