![]() |
|
|
,**
Department of Food Science and Human Nutrition, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO 80523,
* Division of Nutrition and Physical Activity, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (NCCDPHP), Atlanta, GA 30341,
California Department of Health Services, Maternal and Child Health Branch, Sacramento CA 95815 and
** Division of Reproductive Health, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (NCCDPHP), Atlanta, GA 30341
3To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: adams{at}cahs.colostate.edu.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
30 kg/m2) are evaluated using data from the 1998 and 1999 California Womens Health Survey. A total of 8169 women aged
18 y were randomly selected and interviewed by telephone. Food insecurity was evaluated by use of four questions adapted from the U.S. Household Food Security Module. Logistic regression was used to examine the relationship between food insecurity and obesity, controlling for income, race/ethnicity, education, country of birth, general health status and walking. Food insecurity without hunger affected 13.9% of the population and food insecurity with hunger, 4.3%. Almost one fifth (18.8%) of the population was obese. Obesity was more prevalent in food insecure (31.0%) than in food secure women (16.2%). Food insecurity without hunger was associated with increased risk of obesity in whites [odds ratio (OR) = 1.36] and others (OR = 1.47). Food insecurity with hunger was associated with increased risk of obesity for Asians, Blacks and Hispanics (OR = 2.81) but not for non-Hispanic Whites (OR = 0.82). Food insecurity is associated with increased likelihood of obesity and risk is greatest in nonwhites.
KEY WORDS: food insecurity hunger obesity women California
Although extreme forms of hunger are uncommon in the United States, food insecurity and less severe forms of hunger have remained persistent problems (1 ,2 ). Food insecurity, which has been defined as "the limited or uncertain availability of nutritionally adequate and safe foods," can exist with or without hunger, the uneasy or painful sensation caused by lack of food (2 ). Not surprisingly, food insecurity has been associated with increased risk for poor nutritional status (3 5 ) and poor health outcomes (3 ,6 ). The presence of food insecurity and hunger seems to contrast sharply with the economic prosperity of the United States and increasing rates of obesity in this country (7 ,8 ). However, food insecurity can be associated with either overnutrition or undernutrition (3 ,9 ). In addition, economic prosperity notwithstanding, millions of Americans live in poverty (10 ). For many of these persons, purchasing enough nutritious foods may strain the household budget.
Dietz brought attention to the idea that the food insecure are at increased risk of obesity (11 ). Since then, this association has been documented in studies of rural women in New York State (4 ) and in a sample representative of the U.S. population (12 ). This relationship may not hold in all populations, however, and may vary, depending on coping strategies adopted in response to food insecurity.
Obesity has been clearly linked to numerous poor health outcomes such as high blood pressure, diabetes and heart disease, all of which increase morbidity and premature mortality (7
). Over the past decade, the prevalence of obesity has increased dramatically in the United States and reduction of obesity has been identified as a national health priority (7
,8
). Given its potential impacts on health, understanding the relationship between obesity and food insecurity is essential. The purposes of this study were to determine the prevalence of food insecurity with and without hunger in women living in California in 1998 and 1999, and to examine the relationship between food insecurity and obesity as identified by body mass index (BMI) of
30 kg/m2.
| SUBJECTS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Data were obtained from the 1998 and 1999 California Womens Health Survey (CWHS) (13
). The CWHS, an ongoing telephone survey, collects self-reported information on a variety of health-related behaviors, attitudes and outcomes in women in California. Women aged >18 y were randomly selected through random-digit dialing and interviewed anonymously by telephone. There were 8169 participants, with response rates of 70% in 1998 and 81% in 1999 (13
). All interviewers were trained in standard procedures for administering the CWHS (13
). The survey was administered in English or Spanish, depending on participants preferences, with most participants selecting English. The CWHS was developed in English and translated into Spanish by a native Spanish speaker. The survey included
200 questions and took about 30 min to administer in English. This study was determined to be exempt from review by the Committee for the Protection of Human Subjects at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Assessment of food insecurity.
In both survey years, food insecurity was evaluated using a subset of four questions (Table 1 ) adapted from the U.S. Household Food Security Module (HHFSM) (2 ). Classification was by the number of questions answered affirmatively ("often" or "sometimes" to questions 1 and 2, and "yes" to questions 3 and 4). Women with zero or one affirmative response were classified as food secure, those with two or three affirmative responses as food insecure without hunger and those with four affirmative responses as food insecure with hunger. Questions included in the CWHS were selected after discussion with U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) staff to bracket thresholds for these categories of food insecurity. Questions for the 1998 CWHS were selected in 1997, before a standard short form of the HHFSM had been published (14 ). Severe food insecurity could not be evaluated using the subset of questions included in the 1998 and 1999 CWHS.
|
Outcome measures and covariates used in the analysis were categorized (see Table 2
). Obesity was identified by a BMI
30 kg/m2. Income was categorized by percentage of the federal poverty level. Walking was used as a proxy for activity and was characterized as city blocks walked per day. Participants were asked to report the single race/ethnicity with which they most identified and to rate their health status as excellent, very good, good, fair or poor.
|
The prevalence of obesity was determined relative to food security status and race/ethnicity; linear trends were evaluated using chi-square analysis. Logistic regression was used to evaluate the relationship between food insecurity and obesity, with the model controlling for characteristics expected to be related to obesity status, including income level, a four-category [Asian, Black, Hispanic and non-Hispanic White (NHW)] or a two-category (NHW and other race/ethnicities) race/ethnicity variable, age group, education, country of birth, walking and general health status. Two-way interactions between food insecurity status and all other variables in the model were tested individually; the interactions with NHW (P < 0.01), race/ethnicity (P < 0.05) and country of origin (P < 0.05) were significant. Because the interaction between NHW race/ethnicity and food security status was significant, and to maintain adequate numbers for analysis in each strata, logistic regression analyses were stratified by NHW and other race/ethnicities. Within these strata, there were no significant two-way interactions with food security status. All analyses were weighted for discrepancies in age and race between the CWHS sample and the California female population (13 ) and were carried out by use of SAS (Statistical Analysis System, Release 8.1 for Windows; SAS Institute, Cary, NC) and Epi-Info 2000 (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA).
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
27.3 kg/m2). Our findings are consistent with those of Olson and Townsend despite differences in tools used to identify food insecurity, BMI cutoffs used to identify obesity and in populations studied. The CWHS used questions from the HHFSM, whereas Townsend used the USDA food sufficiency indicator (12 ). Food insufficiency is a concept closely related to food insecurity; it is more severe than the concept of food insecurity, and less severe than the concept of hunger (15 ). The CWHS population included greater ethnic diversity than did Olsons or Townsends and this may have enabled us to observe contrasts in the relationships between food insecurity with hunger and obesity for NHW women vs. others. Findings may have implications for other states with similarly diverse populations and comparable levels of food insecurity.
Other researchers have also reported that risk of obesity or overweight is not increased with increasing severity of food insecurity as we found in NHW women. Olson reported that although BMI increased with moderate food insecurity, it decreased as the condition became more severe for women in rural New York State (3 ). Similarly, at the more severe levels of food insecurity, Townsend found that risk for overweight did not differ from that of food secure women. As noted in the Methods, we were unable to analyze the relationship between severe food insecurity and obesity using CWHS data.
Unlike earlier studies, the current study revealed contrasting relationships between obesity and food insecurity with hunger for NHW women compared to others. In women of other race/ethnicities, the risk for obesity increased with increasing severity of food insecurity, suggesting a doseresponse relationship. In contrast, for NHW women, adjusted analyses revealed an increased risk of obesity associated with food insecurity without hunger, but not with the more severe food insecurity with hunger. Reasons for observed differences could not be determined from these analyses. However, factors that may contribute to observed differences include differences in strategies used to cope with food insecurity, cultural attitudes toward body size and characteristics of those experiencing food insecurity in each group. The language of interview is not thought to explain differences between groups. Although we did not control for language in our regression analyses because of collinearity with ethnicity, similar relationships between obesity and food insecurity were observed for Blacks, Asians and Hispanics (Table 3) , suggesting that differences between strata are not fully explained by language.
To explore the relationship between overweight (BMI > 25 kg/m2) and food insecurity, additional analyses were carried out using the same logistic regression model that was used to assess the relationship between food insecurity and obesity. Risk of overweight associated with food insecurity followed similar patterns as risk for obesity in NHW and other women, but the magnitude of the odds ratios was smaller and significant only for women of Asian, Black and Hispanic race/ethnicity.
Questions remain about the direction of the association between food insecurity and obesity and the mechanisms that may explain it. One possibility is that obesity causes food insecurity attributed to increased food consumption. Although the relative energy needs of the obese are likely to be increased for weight maintenance or movement compared to others (16 ), food-related costs will depend in part on foods selected, and may not be directly related to total caloric intake, making obesity an unlikely cause of food insecurity.
A growing body of evidence suggests that the association may be reversed, with food insecurity causing obesity. However, a causal relationship between food insecurity and obesity has not been established, although some of the criteria supporting causality have been met, including plausibility, evidence of doseresponse relationship and consistency of findings across studies. A variety of mechanisms support the biological, social and behavioral plausibility of a causal association. Increased risk for obesity in women who are food insecure may be related to the direct effects of food insecurity on diet. Food insecurity may limit the variety of foods available and result in consumption of high energy, low cost foods. Diets of food insecure or food insufficient women have been shown to include fewer fruits and vegetables (3 ) and to be deficient in a variety of nutrients (4 ,5 ) compared with those who are food secure or food sufficient.
Less direct mechanisms by which food insecurity may cause obesity are supported by other research. There is strong evidence from populations of dieters, prisoners of war and children with food-restrictive parents that food deprivation may lead to overconsumption of previously restricted foods after the restriction ends (17 19 ). As proposed by Dietz (11 ), "either food choices or physiologic adaptations in response to episodic food shortages could cause increased body fat." Adverse environmental and health effects associated with an inadequate food supply may also be associated with increased risk for obesity. Food insufficiency has been linked with depression, poor health and physical limitations in adults (20 ), and with depression, poor health and impaired cognitive and psychosocial development in children (21 23 ). Interrelationships among food insecurity and BMI and factors such as sociodemographic characteristics, health status and cognitive abilities need further study.
Positive relationships between poverty and BMI (24 ) and between poverty and food insecurity (25 ) have been documented. In this study the effect of food insecurity with and without hunger remained significant, even after controlling for poverty status, suggesting that food insecurity is not simply a proxy for income.
In addition to poverty status, other potential confounders of the relationship between food insecurity and obesity were controlled in these analyses, including education, race/ethnicity, country of birth, health status and walking. However, the possibility that the association between food insecurity and obesity is explained by confounding cannot be ruled out by this or previous studies; further investigation of the possible role of confounding is needed.
Limitations of some variables used in this analysis and in methods of data collection must be considered, but are unlikely to explain study results. Food insecurity was determined from a four-question subset of the 18-item HHFSM. The subset used has not been validated as a tool to detect food insecurity, although questions were selected to identify food insecurity thresholds used in the 18-item scale. Although two or more affirmative responses roughly correspond to food insecurity as reported in the USDA national reports, and three or more roughly correspond to food insecurity with hunger, the scale is not precise enough to directly compare our findings with prevalence rates obtained from the 18-item scale (personal communication, M. Nord, Economic Research Service, Washington, DC, May 14, 2002). However, shifts in cutoff points used to identify food insecurity with and without hunger would not be expected to create the associations reported here and are not thought to explain the results of this study.
Self-reported weight and height data used to determine BMI may underestimate weight and overestimate height (26 ), resulting in underestimation of BMI and prevalence of obesity. Such misclassification would be expected to attenuate relationships observed. When logistic regression analyses were repeated, adjusting weights and heights for expected reporting bias according to the method of Rowland (27 ), results did not change in direction or significance of odds ratios (results not shown).
It should be noted that the variable used to indicate physical activity (city blocks walked per day) may have resulted in some misclassification. For example, some women who are extremely active might walk only a few blocks per day.
Finally, data collection methods used in the CWHS excluded from participation women without a phone and those unable to complete the survey in Spanish or English. It is likely that excluded women differed from participants in characteristics such as income, education and race, and were among those most likely to be food insecure. As a result, the prevalence of food insecurity may be underestimated and conclusions must be limited to the population that could be reached using CWHS methodology.
Despite Californias prosperity in the late 1990s, both food insecurity and hunger are evident in the state. Food insecurity has been linked with obesity, an important public health problem. Increased risk of obesity associated with the more severe form of food insecurity with hunger was not consistent for all race/ethnicities. Diet and physical activity may play a role in this energy imbalance, but further research is needed to clarify which determinants of obesity are associated with food insecurity and to clarify the reasons for differences by race/ethnicity. Results of this and earlier studies (3 ,12 ) suggest that the relationship between food insecurity and obesity could be causal in nature, but this needs further investigation. Work is also needed to develop programs and policies to promote food security, access to healthful foods and a healthy weight for all California women.
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
2 Analyses, findings and conclusions described in this report are not necessarily endorsed by the California Department of Health Services or the California Womens Health Survey Group. ![]()
Manuscript received 2 July 2002. Initial review completed 12 August 2002. Revision accepted 2 January 2003.
| LITERATURE CITED |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1. Anderson, S. A., ed., (Life Sciences Research Office) (1990) Core indicators of nutritional state for difficult-to-sample populations. J. Nutr. 120(suppl.):1557S-1600S.
2. Bickel, G., Nord, M., Price, C., Hamilton, W. & Cook, J. T. (2000) Guide to Measuring Household Food Security, rev 2000 2000 U.S. Department of Agriculture, Food and Nutrition Service Alexandria, VA.
3. Olson, C. M. (1999) Nutrition and health outcomes associated with food security and hunger. J. Nutr. 129:521S-524S.
4. Rose, D. (1999) Economic determinants and dietary consequences of food insecurity in the United States. J. Nutr. 129:517S-520S.
5. Dixon, L. B., Winkleby, M. A. & Radimer, K. L. (2001) Dietary intakes and serum nutrients differ between adults from food-insufficient and food-sufficient families: Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, 19881994. J. Nutr. 131:1232-1246.
6. Nelson, K., Cunningham, W., Andersen, R., Harrison, G. & Gelberg, L. (2001) Is food insufficiency associated with health status and health care utilization among adults with diabetes?. J. Gen. Intern. Med. 16:404-411.[Medline]
7. Mokdad, A., Serdula, M. H., Dietz, W. H., Bowman, B. A., Marks, J. S. & Koplan, J. P. (1999) The spread of the obesity epidemic in the United States, 19911998. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 282:1519-1522.
8. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS). (2000) Healthy People 2010. Understanding and Improving Health and Objectives for Improving Health 2nd ed. 1 and 2 DHHS Washington, DC.
9. Radimer, K. L., Allsopp, R., Harvey, P.W.J., Firman, D. W. & Watson, E. K. (1997) Food insufficiency in Queensland. Aust. N. Z. Public Health 21:303-310.[Medline]
10. Dalaker, J. (2001) Poverty in the United States: 2000. Current Population Reports, Series P60-214. U.S. 2001 Government Printing Office Washington, DC.
11. Dietz, W. H. (1995) Does hunger cause obesity?. Pediatrics 95:766-767.
12. Townsend, M. S., Peerson, J., Love, B., Achterberg, C. & Murphy, S. P. (2001) Food insecurity is positively related to overweight in women. J. Nutr. 131:1738-1745.
13. Induni, M. & Davis, B. (2000) California Womens Health Survey: SAS Dataset Documentation and Technical Report 2000 2000 California Department of Health Services Sacramento, CA.
14. Blumberg, S. J., Bialostosky, K., Hamilton, W. L. & Briefel, R. R. (1999) The effectiveness of a short form of the household food security scale. Am. J. Public Health 89:1231-1234.
15. Alaimo, K., Olson, C. & Frongillo, E. A. (2001) Low family income and food insufficiency in relation to overweight in US children. Arch. Pediatr. Adolesc. Med. 155:1161-1167.
16. Galuska, D. A. & Kahn, L. K. (2001) Obesity: a public health perspective. Bowman, B. A. Russell, R. M. eds. Present Knowledge in Nutrition 8th ed. 2001 ILSI Press Washington, DC. .
17. Fisher, J. O. & Birch, L. L. (1999) Restricting access to palatable foods affects childrens behavioral response, food selection, and intake. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 69:1264-1272.
18. Polivy, J., Zeitlin, S. B., Herman, C. P. & Beal, A. L. (1994) Food restriction and binge eating: a study of former prisoners of war. J. Abnorm. Psychol. 103:409-411.[Medline]
19. Polivy, J. (1996) Psychological consequences of food restriction. J. Am. Diet. Assoc. 96:589-592.[Medline]
20. Siefert, K., Heflin, C. M., Corcoran, M. E. & Williams, D. R. (2001) Food insufficiency and the physical and mental health of low-income women. Women Health 32:159-177.[Medline]
21. Alaimo, K., Olson, C. M. & Frongillo, E. A. (2002) Family food insufficiency, but not low family income is positively associated with dysthymia and suicide symptoms in adolescents. J. Nutr. 132:719-725.
22. Alaimo, K., Olson, C. M. & Frongillo, E. A. (2001) Food insufficiency and American school-aged childrens cognitive, academic, and psychosocial development. Pediatrics 108:44-53.
23. Alaimo, K., Olson, C. M., Frongillo, E. A. & Briefel, R. R. (2001) Food insufficiency, family income, and health in U.S. preschool and school-aged children. Am. J. Public Health 91:781-786.[Abstract]
24. James, P. T., Leach, R., Kalamara, E. & Shayeghi, M. (2001) The worldwide obesity epidemic. Obes. Res. 9:228S-233S.
25. Nord, M., Andrews, M. & Carlson, S. (2002) Household Food Security in the United States. ERS Food Assistance and Nutrition Research Report no. FANRR29 2002:2001 Washington, DC.
26. Willett, W. C. (1998) Nutritional Epidemiology 2nd ed. 1998 Oxford University Press New York, NY.
27. Rowland, M. L. (1990) Self-reported weight and height. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 52:1125-1133.
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
P. Valera, J. Gallin, D. Schuk, and N. Davis ''Trying to Eat Healthy'': A Photovoice Study About Women's Access to Healthy Food in New York City Affilia, August 1, 2009; 24(3): 300 - 314. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Chilton and D. Rose A Rights-Based Approach to Food Insecurity in the United States Am J Public Health, July 1, 2009; 99(7): 1203 - 1211. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Widome, D. Neumark-Sztainer, P. J. Hannan, J. Haines, and M. Story Eating When There is Not Enough to Eat: Eating Behaviors and Perceptions of Food Among Food-Insecure Youths Am J Public Health, May 1, 2009; 99(5): 822 - 828. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M.-C. Yeh, A. Viladrich, N. Bruning, and C. Roye Determinants of Latina Obesity in the United States: The Role of Selective Acculturation J Transcult Nurs, January 1, 2009; 20(1): 105 - 115. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
E. Feinberg, P. L. Kavanagh, R. L. Young, and N. Prudent Food Insecurity and Compensatory Feeding Practices Among Urban Black Families Pediatrics, October 1, 2008; 122(4): e854 - e860. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A.-A. Lyons, J. Park, and C. H. Nelson Food Insecurity and Obesity: A Comparison of Self-Reported and Measured Height and Weight Am J Public Health, April 1, 2008; 98(4): 751 - 757. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Isanaka, M. Mora-Plazas, S. Lopez-Arana, A. Baylin, and E. Villamor Food Insecurity Is Highly Prevalent and Predicts Underweight but Not Overweight in Adults and School Children from Bogota, Colombia J. Nutr., December 1, 2007; 137(12): 2747 - 2755. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. C. Whitaker and A. Sarin Change in Food Security Status and Change in Weight Are Not Associated in Urban Women with Preschool Children J. Nutr., September 1, 2007; 137(9): 2134 - 2139. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
V. Tarasuk, L. McIntyre, and J. Li Low-Income Women's Dietary Intakes Are Sensitive to the Depletion of Household Resources in One Month J. Nutr., August 1, 2007; 137(8): 1980 - 1987. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K. L. Hanson, J. Sobal, and E. A. Frongillo Gender and Marital Status Clarify Associations between Food Insecurity and Body Weight J. Nutr., June 1, 2007; 137(6): 1460 - 1465. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. McLaren Socioeconomic Status and Obesity Epidemiol. Rev., May 2, 2007; (2007) mxm001v1. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
K. Kim and E. A. Frongillo Participation in Food Assistance Programs Modifies the Relation of Food Insecurity with Weight and Depression in Elders J. Nutr., April 1, 2007; 137(4): 1005 - 1010. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Engler-Stringer and S. Berenbaum Exploring Food Security With Collective Kitchens Participants in Three Canadian Cities Qual Health Res, January 1, 2007; 17(1): 75 - 84. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. H. Casey, P. M. Simpson, J. M. Gossett, M. L. Bogle, C. M. Champagne, C. Connell, D. Harsha, B. McCabe-Sellers, J. M. Robbins, J. E. Stuff, et al. The Association of Child and Household Food Insecurity With Childhood Overweight Status Pediatrics, November 1, 2006; 118(5): e1406 - e1413. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. C. Whitaker and S. M. Orzol Obesity Among US Urban Preschool Children: Relationships to Race, Ethnicity, and Socioeconomic Status Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med, June 1, 2006; 160(6): 578 - 584. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. E. Wilde and J. N. Peterman Individual Weight Change Is Associated with Household Food Security Status J. Nutr., May 1, 2006; 136(5): 1395 - 1400. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. J. Jones and E. A. Frongillo The Modifying Effects of Food Stamp Program Participation on the Relation between Food Insecurity and Weight Change in Women J. Nutr., April 1, 2006; 136(4): 1091 - 1094. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. Rose and J. N. Bodor Household Food Insecurity and Overweight Status in Young School Children: Results From the Early Childhood Longitudinal Study Pediatrics, February 1, 2006; 117(2): 464 - 473. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. Normen, K. Chan, P. Braitstein, A. Anema, G. Bondy, J. S. G. Montaner, and R. S. Hogg Food Insecurity and Hunger Are Prevalent among HIV-Positive Individuals in British Columbia, Canada J. Nutr., April 1, 2005; 135(4): 820 - 825. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L. L Kaiser, M. S Townsend, H. R Melgar-Quinonez, M. L Fujii, and P. B Crawford Choice of instrument influences relations between food insecurity and obesity in Latino women Am. J. Clinical Nutrition, November 1, 2004; 80(5): 1372 - 1378. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. E. Stuff, P. H. Casey, K. L. Szeto, J. M. Gossett, J. M. Robbins, P. M. Simpson, C. Connell, and M. L. Bogle Household Food Insecurity Is Associated with Adult Health Status J. Nutr., September 1, 2004; 134(9): 2330 - 2335. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||