![]() |
|
|
Nutrition & Dietetics Unit, Department of Medicine, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa
2To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: kc{at}uctgsh1.uct.ac.za.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
KEY WORDS: nutritional status Africa elderly food security
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The lack of attention to the elderly in policies and programs is
mirrored by the paucity of information from research studies on their
condition. The scant information that is available suggests that the
nutrition problems of the elderly are sizable. Given that the older
population in Africa is rapidly increasing (1)
,
researchers and policymakers would do well to focus more attention on
this group.
Our aim in this article is to synthesize what little is known about the nutrition of older adults in Africa. In particular, we review two broad areas of research: 1) the nutritional status of elderly Africans, in terms of both under- and overnutrition, and 2) the social and economic determinants of undernutrition among the aged in Africa. We choose these areas because they form the core of a problem statement on elderly nutrition, a key starting point for designing nutrition policies and programs for this group. As will be seen throughout, there are substantial gaps in the literature. A final section outlines some suggested future research and policy priorities.
| Nutritional status of elderly Africans |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Anthropometric status.
In 1992, the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, in
collaboration with HelpAge International, began a program of research
on the nutrition of older people in developing countries. Two sites in
Africa were researched: a Rwandan refugee camp in Tanzania
(2)
and rural communities near Lilongwe, Malawi
(3)
. Using a BMI cut-off of 18.5 (4)
, the
prevalence of undernutrition in both countries was higher in men than
women, ranging from 19.5% in Tanzania to 36.1% in Malawi among men
and from 13.1% in Tanzania to 27% in Malawi among women. The
prevalence of undernutrition in elderly refugees in Tanzania was lower
than that found in another study of older refugees in Algeria (25% for
men and 11.5% for women) (5)
. This discrepancy is
probably explained by the fact that the subjects who had reached the
refugee camp had already been there for a year at the time of the
survey, during which time relief agencies had been providing food.
It has been suggested that conventional BMI reference values may not be
appropriate for identifying poor nutritional status in elderly people,
because of changes in body composition and kyphosis. The mid-upper
arm circumference
(MUAC)3
is an easy-to-perform measurement that requires only a tape measure.
The London School group demonstrated that an arm circumference
cut-off of 21.7 cm had 86% sensitivity in relation to a BMI
cut-off of 16 (i.e., severe undernutrition) in the two African
samples (6)
. The researchers proposed MUAC as an
alternative to BMI as a screening tool, particularly in the acute phase
of an emergency (See Table 1
). Interestingly,
undernutrition, as measured by MUAC, was associated with
functional abilityincluding handgrip strength, psychomotor
speed and co-ordination, mobility, and the ability to carry out
activities of daily living independentlyin both the Tanzanian and
Malawian sites (7
,8)
.
|
55 y were categorized as being undernourished
(9)
Using three anthropometric indices (and/or low serum albumin
concentrations), a study of 201 low income elderly women living in
slums and poor urban areas in Nairobi, Kenya, found a prevalence of
marasmic-like protein-energy malnutrition (PEM) of 10.4%
(10)
.
Biochemical and hematological indicators.
Using other indicators of nutritional status, a study conducted in
three areas in Zimbabwe (two rural and one urban; n = 278) in community-dwelling subjects aged 60 y and older found
that almost a quarter (23%) of subjects were anemic (Hb <13g/dL in
men and <12 g/dL in women); 3% had microcytic anemia and 20% had
macrocytic anemia (11)
. Red blood cell folate levels were
low in 30% of subjects, while 13% had low serum vitamin B-12 levels.
Dietary intake.
In South Africa, black seniors have been shown to have a low energy
intake. In a sample of elderly living in informal settlements in
peri-urban Cape Town, over a quarter (27%) of men and over a third
(36%) of women had energy intakes <67% of the RDA, a cut-off
often used to indicate a low intake (12)
. Micronutrient
density was inadequate and was explained by the low mean intake from
the vegetable and fruit group of <2.5 servings a day. Although
three-quarters of the sample had consumed fruit and/or vegetables
in the 24-h period prior to the survey, only 20 and 26% had consumed
vitamin Crich or carotene-rich sources, respectively.
In the Nairobi study that found marasmic-like PEM, protein intake
was low in all women40.8 (±1.7) and 51.6 (±2.4) g/d in slum and
poor areas, respectively (10)
. In subjects with PEM, a
mean of only 6g protein/d was of high quality, with vegetable and
cereal sources providing the remainder (48 and 36% total protein,
respectively).
An investigation of dietary patterns in the Zimbabwean group mentioned
above found that the staple diet was maize meal and vegetables, and
that 27% of subjects ate a protein-containing meal less than once
a week (11)
.
Overnutrition and risk for chronic diseases of lifestyle.
Evidence of the "nutrition transition," whereby diets high in
unrefined carbohydrates and fiber are replaced by diets containing a
higher proportion of fats, particularly saturated fatty acids, and
sugars (13
,14)
, can be seen in Africa as well. Data from a
study conducted in almost 1,000 individuals in informal settlements on
the outskirts of Cape Town in 1990 demonstrated an association between
duration of life spent in a city and percentage of energy in the diet
supplied by fat (15)
. The ratio of protein, fat and
carbohydrate to total energy intake provides an indication of the
atherogenicity of the diet and identifies a populations position in
the nutrition transition. In this regard, the available data for older
South Africans suggest that elderly white South Africans have a high
fat intake (>35% E) (16)
, while elderly of mixed
ancestry have an intermediate fat intake (32% E) (17)
as
compared with a low fat intake in black elderly (2426% E)
(12
,18
,19)
.
Regarding overnutrition, urban-rural differences in the prevalence
of obesity have been shown in older South Africans. Obesity (BMI
30)
has been shown to be fourfold higher in urban black women in Cape Town
than in women in a rural area (12)
. Differences are seen
in the prevalence of other risk factors for chronic diseases of
lifestyle when comparing the results of various studies of elderly
South Africans. Favorable lipid profiles (i.e., low levels of total
serum cholesterol and HDL:total cholesterol ratios of >20%) are seen
for the black elderly population, which probably reflects their
lifetime exposure to a low fat intake, whereas older white South
Africans have a high cardiovascular risk (20)
(Fig. 1
). Black elderly who speak different languages and who live in different
parts of the country have different lipid profiles. In Cape Town,
Xhosa-speaking black elderly (20)
had a more
protective lipid profile than Sesotho-speaking black people of a
similar age in either an urban (Mangaung) or rural (Qwaqwa) area
(21)
.
|
160/95 mmHg) of 38.8% (when age- and sex-standardized to the 1991 census data for the population aged
60 y) than reported for either the urban Manguang (70.6%) or the
rural QwaQwa (56.7%) groups. The differences in hypertension could not
be explained by differences in the prevalence of obesity between the
groups. This suggests that differences may exist in the cardiovascular
disease risk profiles among various black South African populations,
even given comparable living conditions and lifestyles. Studies are
currently underway to investigate the genetic predisposition of various
African groups to salt sensitivity. In summary, there are substantial gaps in our knowledge of the nutritional condition of older Africans. Much of what we know comes from scattered studies in diverse populations. Available data indicate serious problems of both undernutrition, including energy and protein deficiency, as evidenced by both anthropometric and dietary indicators, and micronutrient deficiencies, as evidenced by biochemical and dietary measures. The provision of nutrition services to elderly people in urban areas is complicated by the apparent double burden of nutrition-related disease. On the one hand, there is evidence of energy and micronutrient undernutrition in older adults, while, on the other hand, there is evidence of high risk for chronic diseases of lifestyle in certain groups. Coupled with this complex situation is the current prioritization of other sectors of the population, namely women and children, for the targeting of nutrition services.
| Determinants of poor nutritional status in older Africans |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Household food security.
Household food insecurity, through its effect on dietary intake, is an
underlying cause of undernutrition in Africa. There is limited
information on the food security situation among the elderly in Africa,
but some insights were obtained recently from an analysis of food
expenditure data in South Africa. Results showed that 43% of South
African households experienced food poverty in 1995 (24)
;
food poverty was defined as household food spending less than the cost
of a nutritionally adequate subsistence diet. Subsequent analyses,
reported here for the first time, showed that 50% of elderly
households (age of head
60 y) were in food poverty,
compared with 40% of younger households (P < 0.05).
Dramatic differences in food poverty were evident according to
ethnicity and age of household head, with black elderly-headed
households having the highest food poverty rates of all groups (65.4%)
(Fig. 2
).
|
This study highlights the important role of household context in understanding the nutrition problems of the elderly. Effective nutrition interventions will need to take into account social and demographic factors such as household size, urbanization and race.
Famine, war and natural disasters.
In Africa, population growth rates already exceed those of food
production in most sub-Saharan countries, forcing them into food
crises whenever bad weather, civil unrest or war strikes
(25)
. The effects of seasonal changes in food availability
on the nutritional status of 41 elderly subjects living in smallholder
rural households in Kenya was investigated over a 15-mo period
(26)
. Large interseasonal changes in body weight were
demonstrated, in which the men had a mean weight loss in the lean
season of 4 kg (
7% of total body weight) compared with 1.7 kg in
women (3% body weight). The authors concluded that older people who
rely on their own land for food availability are likely to suffer high
nutritional stress during periods of heavy physical activity and
seasonal food shortages.
Thenumber of refugees and internally displaced persons grew by 40%
between 1990 and 1993. The United Nations High Commission for Refugees
has estimated that, on average, 10% of refugees are over 60 y
old. On the African continent, war and civil strife are prime causes of
population displacements and food shortages, which affect large numbers
of people in a geographical area. Older adults are a particularly
vulnerable group in unstable conditions, yet consideration of their
health and nutritional status is often overlooked and relief efforts
are targeted toward young children. In Bosnia-Herzegovinia,
undernutrition was not found in children; however, the prevalence in
older adults was 1020% (27)
. This information suggests
that older people may forgo their food rations in favor of younger
relatives or may have increased requirements due to underlying disease.
HIV/AIDS.
Of all world regions, the largest impact of the AIDS pandemic has been
in sub-Saharan Africa. In 21 countries in the sub-Saharan
region, >5% of the urban adult population is HIV positive. Severely
affected countries at present are Namibia, Swaziland, Zambia and
Zimbabwe: 1925% of all adults in these countries are HIV positive.
Projected declines in life expectancies that take AIDS-related
mortality into account in the southern African region have demonstrated
declines from 62 to 40 y in Botswana, from 65 to 56 y in
South Africa and from 56 to 37 y in Zambia (28)
.
The AIDS epidemic in sub-Saharan African countries has been called
the "grandmothers curse" (29)
, because it is the
grandmothers who must care for adult children with AIDS, as well as for
grandchildren who have AIDS or who have been orphaned. In Zimbabwe, in
1997, 43% of households with AIDS orphans were headed by a grandmother
(30)
. Information from Kenya has shown that households
with AIDS orphans that are headed by grandmothers typically suffer
abject poverty and usually fall below the poverty line
(31)
. The potential devastating socioeconomic and
demographic impact of the AIDS epidemic, together with the psychosocial
burden of caregiving, loneliness and bereavement associated with the
outcomes of the disease (32)
, is likely to be a major
determinant of health status, including nutritional status, in older
Africans.
| Future research and policy priorities |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The development of valid and reliable, but simple-to-administer, instruments is needed to screen for risk of malnutrition. Identification of the most appropriate anthropometric indices and accompanying reference values to use in the determination of either under- or overnutrition in this age group requires an extension of the type of surveys that have been conducted in Malawi and Tanzania by researchers from the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine. In these studies, measurement of MUAC has been shown to be a sensitive indicator of undernutrition and is able to predict functional status, particularly handgrip strength.
Regarding micronutrient status, in developed countries there is a rapidly changing paradigm from the prevention of deficiency states to the maintenance of an optimal status in the elderly, particularly for the role of folate, vitamin B-12 and vitamin B-6 in homocysteine metabolism and cognitive function. The micronutrient status of older Africans is largely unknown; however, it would be expected that the typically low animal protein and low nutrient-dense dietary patterns would result in inadequate intakes. Indeed, folate deficiency has been identified as the primary cause of anemia in noninstitutionalized elderly Zimbabweans. Unlike the U.S., no African countries have adopted the mandatory fortification of grain products with folate. This area of research should be considered high priority, considering the rapid urbanization trends and demographic transition taking place and the relative safety and cost-effectiveness of either fortification or supplementation with water-soluble B vitamins.
In Africa, the elderly are not considered a priority for targeting of nutrition interventions, so it is not surprising that the effectiveness of different types of nutrition interventions has not been described in this population. Only a handful of nutritionists are working with older people in African countries, and there are even fewer practitioners conducting high-quality research in the field. Indeed, apart from emergency relief and supplementary feeding program, including luncheon clubs operated by volunteer or donor organizations, little else has been attempted. Outcome measures of effectiveness should include improvements in physical and cognitive functional ability, as well as cost savings related to medical care and utilization of limited health care resources.
On a positive note, HelpAge International has launched a program of
training and advocacy aimed at nutritionists and nongovernmental
organizations (NGOs), with a coordinator based in the Kenya regional
office. Another notable landmark is the recent development of a draft
Policy Framework and Plan of Action on Ageing by the Organization of
African Unity (OAU), drafted after a meeting of experts from 27 OAU
member states in November 2000 (33)
. This effort is an
attempt to guide OAU member states in the design, implementation,
monitoring and evaluation of their own appropriate national policies
for the elderly. "Food and Nutrition" has been identified as one of
twelve key areas in the draft policy document, which will be presented
to the 37th Session of Heads of State and Government in July 2001 for
official adoption and endorsement. For successful implementation of any
such policies on aging, intersectoral cooperation between ministries of
Health and Welfare, as well as NGOs and aid agencies, is required. The
integral existence of informal services, social support networks and
kin support needs to be engaged, and public-sector finance needs to
be made available to support these systems.
In conclusion, optimal nutrition in the elderly has implications for improving their health status and general well-being, as well as for reducing the burden on limited health care resources. The challenge is to identify and tackle the basic and underlying causes of poor nutritional status in older adults in African countries, which may differ from country to country.
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
3 Abbreviations: MUAC, mid-upper arm
circumference; PEM, protein-energy malnutrition; NGO,
nongovernmental organization; OAU, Organization of African Unity. ![]()
| LITERATURE CITED |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1. United States Bureau of the Census (1997) International Brief. Aging trends: South Africa 1997 Department of Commerce Washington, DC. .
2. Pieterse S., Manandhar M. & Ismail S. (1998) The nutritional status of older Rwandan refugees. Pub. Health Nutr. 1:259-264.
3. Chilima D. M. & Ismail S. J. (1998) Anthropometric characteristics of older people in rural Malawi. Eur. J Clin. Nutr. 52:643-649.[Medline]
4. Shetty P. & James W. (1994) BMI: a measure of chronic energy deficiency in adults 1994 Food and Agriculture Organization Rome, Italy. .
5. Branca F. (1998) The nutritional status and nutritional vulnerability of Sabarawi refugees 1998 Instituto Nazionale della Nutrizone Italy (Unpublished report). .
6. Ismail S. & Manandhar M. (1999) Better nutrition for older people: assessment and Action 1999 HelpAge International and London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine London, UK. .
7. Chilima D. M. & Ismail S. J. (2000) Nutrition and handgrip strength of older adults in rural Malawi. Pub. Health Nutr. 4:11-17.
8. Pieterse S. (1999) Nutritional vulnerability of older refugees 1999 PhD thesis London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, UK. .
9. GOAL Ethiopia (2000) Findings of nutrition survey. Borona, Zone-Oromia Region, June 1226th (Unpublished report) 2000.
10. Ethangatta L. K., Gee M. I. & Hawrysh Z. J. (1996) Protein-energy malnutrition in low-income elderly Nairobi women. Int. J Food Sci. Nutr. 47:147-157.[Medline]
11. Allain T. J., Gomo Z.A.R., Wilson A. O., Ndemera B., Adamchak D. J. & Matenga J. A. (1997) Anaemia, macrocytosis, vitamin B12 and folate levels in elderly Zimbabweans. Centr. Afr. J Med. 43:325-328.[Medline]
12. Charlton K. E., Bourne L. T., Steyn K. & Laubscher R. (2001) Poor nutritional status in older black South Africans. Asia Pac. J Clin. Nutr. 10:31-38.[Medline]
13. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (1970) Income effect on the structure of the diet: provisional indicative world plan for agricultural development. FAO, Rome 2:500-505.
14. Popkin B. M. (1998) The nutrition transition and its health implications in lower-income countries. Publ. Health Nutr. 1:5-21.
15. Bourne L. T., Langenhoven M. L., Steyn K., Jooste P. L., Laubscher J. A. & Van der Vyver E. (1993) Nutrient intake in the urban African population of the Cape Peninsula, South Africa: the Brisk study. Centr. Afr. J Med. 39:238-247.[Medline]
16. Kruger A., Vorster H. H. & Viljoen M. T. (1993) Nutritional status of healthy elderly Caucasians: evaluation of standard criteria in a group of 100 free living subjects. S. Afr. Food Sci. Nutr. 5:85-89.
17. Charlton K. E., Wolmarans P., Marais A. D. & Lombard C. J. (1997) Nutritional status of older coloured South Africans: macronutrient intake, food habits and cardiovascular risk profiles. East Afr. Med. J 74:478-486.[Medline]
18. Johnson S. & van der Westhuizen J. (1992) Nutritional evaluation of the black elderly in a rural village. S Afr. J Food Sci. Nutr. 1:23-28.
19. Bester F.C.J., Weich D.J.V. & Danhauser A. (1993) Nutrient intakes of elderly blacks in the Orange Free State. S Afr. J Clin. Nutr. 6:6-11.
20. Patel M, Steyn K., Bourne L. T., Charlton K. E., Jooste P. & Laubscher R. (2000) The risk profile for chronic diseases of lifestyle in older black persons of the Cape Peninsula: the BRISK study. S. Afr. J Gerontology 9:20-24.
21. Mollentze W. F., Moore A. J., Steyn A. F., Joubert G., Steyn K., Ossthuizen G. M. & Weich D. J. (1995) Coronary heart disease risk factors in a rural and urban Orange Free State black population. S. Afr. Med. J 85:90-96.[Medline]
22. Seedat Y. K., Mayet F.G.H., Khan S., Somers S. R. & Joubert G. (1990) Risk factors for coronary heart disease in the Indians of Durban. S. Afr. Med. J 78:447-454.[Medline]
23. Seedat Y. K., Mayet F.G.H. & Gouws E. (1994) Risk factors for coronary heart disease in the white community of Durban. S. Afr. Med. J 84:257-262.[Medline]
24. Rose D. & Charlton K. E. (2000) Food insecurity and food poverty in South African households. S. Afr. J Clin. Nutr. 13:105(Abs).
25.
Herdt R. W. (1998) Assisting developing countries toward self-reliance. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 95:1989-1992.
26. Kigutha H. N., van Staveren W. A. & Hautvast J.G.A.J. (1998) Elderly under nutritional stress: a seasonal study on food consumption and nutritional status in Kenya. Int. J Food Sci. Nutr. 49:423-433.
27.
Vespa J. & Watson F. (1995) Who are nutritionally vulnerable in Bosnia-Hertzegovina?. Br. Med. J 311:652-654.
28. United States Bureau of the Census () HIV/AIDS in the developing world. Report WP/982 US Government Printing Office Washington, DC .
29. Wilson A. O. & Adamchak D. J. (2000) AIDS in Africa: the grandmothers disease. Comment. J Age Related Disorders 12:5-6.
30. Foster G. (1997) Children rearing children: a study of child-headed households. Paper read at the Socio-Demographic Impact of AIDS in Africa Conference 1997 Durban South Africa, February 36. .
31. Saoke P., Mutemi R. & Blair C. (1996) Another song begins: children orphaned by AIDS. Forsythe S. Rau B. eds. AIDS in Kenya: Socioeconomic Impact and Policy Implications 1996:45-64 US Agency for International Development, AIDSCAP, Family Health International New York. .
32. Ferreira M. (2000) AIDS: the mad-dog curse of Africa. Southern Afr. J Gerontol. 9:1-3.
33. Organization of African Unity (OAU) (2001) Final report of the experts meeting to develop an OAU policy framework and plan of action on ageing, 27 November1 December 2000 2001 OAU Kampala, Uganda. .
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
C. Oppong Familial Roles and Social Transformations: Older Men and Women in Sub-Saharan Africa Research on Aging, November 1, 2006; 28(6): 654 - 668. [Abstract] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. Rose and K. E. Charlton Quantitative Indicators from a Food Expenditure Survey Can Be Used to Target the Food Insecure in South Africa J. Nutr., November 1, 2002; 132(11): 3235 - 3242. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||