![]() |
|
|

*
Nutrition Research Division,
Toxicology Research Division,
**
Bureau of Biostatistics and Computer Applications, Food Directorate, Health Protection Branch, Health Canada, Banting Research Centre, Ottawa, ON, Canada K1A 0L2
3To whom correspondence should be addressed,
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
KEY WORDS: canola oil cell membrane deformability life span phytosterols stroke-prone spontaneously hypertensive rats
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Research conducted over the last four decades has demonstrated that
dietary phytosterols can inhibit the intestinal absorption of dietary
and biliary cholesterol, thus reducing serum cholesterol levels
(Ling and Jones 1995
, Pollak and Kritchevsky 1981
). Phytosterols can also replace cholesterol in the cell
membranes and thereby alter cell membrane physical properties. In an in
vitro experiment, treatment of isolated human RBC with various types of
sterols led to partial replacement of membrane cholesterol by sterols,
resulting in a significant increase in the osmotic fragility of RBC
(Bruckerdorfer et al. 1969
). In an in vivo study, the
rigidity of liver microsomes was significantly increased in Wistar rats
fed a diet enriched with ß-sitosterol and campesterol (Leiken and Brenner 1989
).
SHRSP rats have defective, abnormal and more fragile cell membranes
than other rat strains; this is thought to be a contributing factor in
their development of cerebral hemorrhage (Yamori et al. 1980
and 1984a
). The cell membrane abnormalities in SHRSP rats are due
primarily to a deficiency of cholesterol in blood and in cell
membranes. Hamano et al. (1995)
demonstrated that
incorporation of cholesterol into the diet delays the development of
stroke and prolongs the life span of SHRSP rats, which suggests that
cholesterol is an essential dietary component for this strain of rats.
Most likely, the integrity of the cell membrane was improved by dietary
cholesterol.
Considering the above, we suggest that increased intakes of phytosterols might result in partial replacement of cholesterol in cell membranes, making the cell membrane more fragile, thereby exacerbating the development of hemorrhagic stroke and shortening the life span of SHRSP rats. Vegetable oils are the primary sources of phytosterols. Canola oil, compared with soybean oil and other common vegetable oils such as olive oil, contains more phytosterols because of its higher proportions of ß-sitosterol, campesterol and brassicasterol. The objective of this study was to determine whether the life-shortening effect of canola oil on SHRSP rats was due to its high concentration of phytosterols. To assess the underlying mechanism of action of phyotsterols, we also investigated the effects of phytosterols on hematologic variables and the deformability of RBC membranes of SHRSP rats.
The study compared the effects of canola oil on the above-mentioned variables in SHRSP rats, with soybean, canola and soybean oils fortified with a mixture of phytosterols isolated from a canola oil deodorizer distillate, corn oil and olive oil. A mixture of fats that mimicked the fat composition of a representative Canadian diet was also included in the study. The Canadian fat mimic contained both cholesterol and phytosterols.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A mixture of phytosterols was prepared from canola oil deodorizer
(CanAmera Foods, Altona, Canada). In a typical preparation, 1 kg of
canola deodorizer distillate containing 19.9 g total sterols/100 g
material was dissolved in methanol (1 L) and saponified for 1 h
with 500 g/L NaOH (196 g). The resulting soaps were acidified with 370
g/L HCl (35 mL) and esterified by adding to the saponification reaction
mass 370 g/L HCl (255 mL) and refluxing for 1 h. On cooling to
room temperature, the reaction mixture was separated into a top oily
layer and a bottom aqueous layer of salt/glycerine/methanol. The
aqueous layer was discarded. Methanol (500 mL) and 370 g/L HCl (20 mL)
were added to the oily layer and refluxed for 1 h to drive the
esterification to completion. The mixture was stirred with cold water
(1 L) for 15 min and centrifuged at 1000 x g at 15°C. The
centrifuged cake was rinsed with 500 mL of a mixture of
acetone/methanol/water (75:20:10, v/v/v) and then recrystallized from
heptane (1 L). This produced 124 g of 100% pure sterols
containing (per 100 g material) 1.0 g cholesterol, 20.5 g brassicasterol, 3.7 g 24-methylene cholesterol, 0.8 g
stigmasterol, 29.4 g campesterol, 0.2 g
5,23-stigmastadienol, 0.1 g clerosterol, 0.1 g sitastanol,
43.2 g ß-sitosterol, 0.4 g
5-avenasterol and 0.5 g
5,24-stigmastadienol [determined by gas-liquid chromatography
(GLC) and TLC].
Test diets.
Seven casein-based semipurified diets containing 10 g fat/100
g were tested (Table 1
). The fat sources included canola oil (Diet CA), soybean oil (Diet SO),
canola oil fortified with the above mentioned phytosterol mixture
isolated from canola oil deodorizer distillate (Diet CA + P) and
soybean oil fortified with the same phytosterol mixture (Diet SO + P)
[the phytosterol fortification of canola and soybean oils was such
that the levels of total sterols in dietary oils CA + P and SO + P were
two times that in regular canola oil], corn oil (Diet CO), olive oil
(extra virgin, Diet OO) and a blend of fat that mimicked the fat
composition of a representative Canadian diet (Canadian fat mimic; Diet
CFM). All of the dietary oils were purchased from a local supermarket.
|
18 y) and sex, 7 d/wk over two seasons
(spring and fall 1990). The composition of the representative Canadian
diet was calculated by adjusting the food intake data by the
population, sex and age distributions reported for Nova Scotia and
Quebec in the 1991 Canadian Census (The Canadian Global Almanac 1996The above fat mixture of Diet CFM, in addition to the 100% pure fats and oils, contained whole-egg powder, butter and margarine as sources of fat. These three fat sources contained appreciable amounts of protein and carbohydrates (whole-egg powder: 42% fat, 46% protein, 4.8% carbohydrates and 3.5% ash; butter: 81% fat, 1% protein, 2% ash, 16% water; margarine: 80% fat, 0.5% protein, 16% water). Therefore, to maintain similar levels of protein and carbohydrates in all of the diets, the amounts of casein and cornstarch used in the preparation of Diet CFM were reduced in proportion to the amounts of protein and carbohydrates contributed by whole-egg powder, butter and margarine. Each diet was prepared in 10-kg lots and stored at -4°C.
Animals.
SHRSP rats (male, 28 d old) obtained from Seac Yoshitomi (Yoshitomi-Cho, Chikujyo-gun, Fukuoka, Japan) were used. The rats were acclimated to the environment of the animal care facility of Health Canada, Ottawa for 9 d. During this period, they were fed a nonpurified diet (Laboratory Rodent Diet 5001, PMI Feeds, St. Louis, MO). After the acclimation period, rats were placed in the seven dietary groups of 28 rats/group in a randomized block according to body weight (mean body wt 64.3 g). Each group was divided into two subgroups. Ten rats from each group were randomly identified for killing after 3032 d of dietary treatment (at 6567 d of age) for collection of blood and tissue samples for biochemical analyses and pathologic examination. The remaining rats (18/group) were used for determination of the life span.
The rats were housed individually in metal cages in a climate-controlled room maintained at 22 ± 1°C and 60% relative humidity with 12-h day:night cycle. Drinking water contained 10 g NaCl/L. The rats had free access to one of the seven diets and drinking water. The diets were replaced every 4 d to minimize deterioration. When a rat in the life span study group was found in pain or judged to be unable to survive overnight, it was killed.
The rats selected for killing at d 3032 were killed by exsanguination while under 3% isoflurane anesthesia. Blood was withdrawn immediately from the aorta. To ensure that blood samples were processed immediately after being obtained, these were collected from the seven dietary groups over experimental d 3032; each group was sampled equally on each day. About 7 mL of blood was collected from each rat; 2 mL was stored in EDTA tubes and 5 mL in heparanized polystyrene tubes. The liver, kidneys, heart, a sample of adipose tissue and brain were extracted. Tissue samples intended for lipid analyses were frozen immediately in liquid nitrogen and stored in a freezer maintained at -70°C until analysis. Tissue samples collected for histologic analyses were stored in formalin at room temperature. Health Canadas guide for the care and use of laboratory animals was followed and the study protocol was approved by the Animal Care Committee of Health Canada.
Hematologic measurements.
Complete blood cell count was measured using a Coulter Counter S-PLUS IV system (Coulter Electronic, Hialeah, FL) on whole-blood samples collected in EDTA tubes.
Erythrocyte deformability.
Erythrocyte deformability was measured on whole-blood samples
(collected in heparanized polystyrene tubes) on the day of blood
sampling using the ektacytometer (Model 152, Technicon Instruments
Corporation, Tarrytown, NY). The principle of the instrument has been
described in detail by Clark et al. (1983)
. Briefly, the
ektacytometer provides measurements of cell deformation at constant
shear stress as a continuous function of increasing osmolality of the
suspending medium. Such ektacytometric measurements, conducted over a
wide osmotic range, from low hypotonic to hypertonic concentrations,
provide deformability profiles that vary in qualitatively different
ways for several RBC disorders. This single measurement can detect
relatively minor alterations in RBC membrane rigidity, internal
viscosity and the ratio of surface area to volume.
The procedure used for deformability measurements (deformabilty index,
DI) was essentially as described by Paterson and Card (1993)
. Whole blood (100 µL) was suspended in
3.0 mL of a solution containing 0.086 mmol/L polyvinylpyrrolidone
(PVP360), 6.3 mmol/L Na2HPO4, 2 mmol/L
NaH2PO4, 6.15 mmol/L NaN3 (pH 7.35
± 0.05) and 0.136 mol/L NaCl (290 mOsmol/kg). The viscosity of
the suspending solution was adjusted with PVP360 to achieve a final
viscosity of 20 ± 1 cP (falling ball viscometer, Gilmont
Instruments, Barrington, IL). The erythrocytes were subjected to
constant shear stress (160 dyn/cm2) in the instrument as
the osmolality of the suspending medium was increased progressively
from 50 to 500 mOsm/kg by varying the amount of NaCl. The osmolality of
the gradient solutions was measured using a micro-osmometer (Model
3M0, Advanced Instruments, Needham Heights, MA). The elongation index
(also termed deformability index) of cells, which is defined as the
ratio of length to width of the diffraction pattern of deforming cells,
was obtained with a helium-neon laser beam and then recorded
continuously on a linear X-Y recorder. From this elongation vs.
osmolality plot, the cell DI was calculated as the difference between
the maximum (EI max) and minimum elongation (EI min). The EI max is
influenced by membrane deformability and surface area of the cell and
is reached at ~290 mOsmol/kg, the physiologic osmolality at which
normal erythrocytes have maximum flexibility. The EI min is the
elongation cells would have reached just before hemolysis. The EI is
measured in hypotonicity.
The other indices measured using the elongation vs. osmolality plot
included the following: 1) Ohyper, which
gives an estimate of internal viscosity and hence indirectly, the mean
corpuscular hemoglobin concentration; 2)
Omin, which is the osmolality at EI min. It is the
osmolality at which 50% of cells hemolyze in an osmotic fragility
assay. It is indicative of the surface area/volume ratio of the cells
and reflects the maximum value possible before hemolysis at
Omin; and 3) Omax, which is the
osmolality associated with EI max (Paterson and Card 1993
).
Fatty acid and sterol analyses.
Whole blood (3 mL) was immediately collected in tubes lined with
silicone. Red blood cells were isolated by centrifuging at 2500 x g for 20 min. Total lipids in RBC, serum and other
tissues were extracted according to Bligh and Dyer (1959)
. Fat from the diets was extracted using 25 vol of
CHCl3/MeOH (1:2, v/v).
For analysis of fatty acid composition, extracted lipid samples were methylated with BF3/MeOH (140 g/L) and then analyzed by GLC using an SP-2560 flexible fused silica capillary column (100 m x 0.25 mm i.d., Supelco, Bellefonte, PA).
For analysis of sterol composition, ~520 mg of the original oil samples or extracted lipid samples were mixed with betulin (GLC internal standard; Lup-20-[29]-ene-3ß,28-diol, Sigma Chemical, St. Louis, MO) and the mixture saponified with ethanolic-KOH (0.5 g KOH, 0.4 mL water, 5 mL EtOH). The nonsaponifiable matter was extracted with hexane/methylene chloride (85:15, v/v) and purified by successive washes with water and water/ethanol (80:20, v/v). The extract was dried with anhydrous sodium sulfate, solvents were evaporated in a hot water bath under a stream of nitrogen and then treated with 100 µL of 1-methyl imidazole/N-methyl-N-(trimethylsilyl)-heptafluorobutyramide (1:20, v/v) for converting the free sterols to trimethyl silyl ether derivative. The content and composition of the silylated sterols were determined in relation to the internal standard by GLC using a DB-1 flexible fused silica capillary column (30 m x 0.25 mm i.d.; J & W Scientific, Folsom, CA). Sterols were identified by comparing their GLC retention times with those of authentic standards (Sigma Chemical) and a mixture of phytosterols derived from canola oil.
Blood lipid and clinical measurements.
Blood (~3 mL) was collected from food-deprived rats, centrifuged at 1300 x g for 20 min, and serum separated. Serum total triglycerides and total sterols (cholesterol + phytosterols) were determined using an Abbott-VP Bichromatic Analyzer, with the A-Gent Triglyceride test and A-Gent Cholesterol test kits (Abbott Laboratories, Mississauga, Canada). HDL total sterols were isolated by selectively precipitating LDL and VLDL total sterols with A-Gent HDL reagent (Abbott Laboratories).
Statistics.
Survival data were analyzed using Log-rank and Wilcoxon
nonparametric tests for comparing survival curves to provide tests for
the effects of diets (Lawless 1982
). Note that the
Wilcoxon test for differences in the survival function is more
sensitive to differences in survival rates near the beginning of the
study than is the Log-rank test. Other data were analyzed by ANOVA
followed by Tukeys Least Significant Difference test when indicated
by the F-value using Statistica for Windows (1998;
Statsoft, Tulsa, OK). Differences were considered significant when
P < 0.05. All data in the tables are reported as
means and SD. Simple correlations between mean survival
times and various blood indices were calculated by linear regression
analysis.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The diets were designed to provide a wide range of phytosterol levels
(Table 2
). Total phytosterol concentrations ranged from 27 to 207 mg/100 g diet
with OO and CFM diets providing the lowest levels, and CA + P and SO +
P diets providing the highest levels. The unfortified canola oil
provided 97 mg sterol/100 g diet, which was ~1.5 times greater than
that in unfortified soybean oil. The CO diet had a slightly higher
amount of sterols than the CA diet, due primarily to its high
ß-sitosterol content. In addition to phytosterols, the CFM had a
relatively high cholesterol concentration derived from the dairy
products and animal fats used in the preparation of this diet. The CFM,
compared with other dietary fats, was characterized by high levels of
total saturated fatty acids and trans fatty acids, and a low
level of linoleic acid [18:2(n-6)] (Table 3
).
|
|
Rats in all groups grew normally, and there were no significant differences in weekly body weights (data not shown). The body, kidney and brain weights of the SHRSP rats killed after feeding for 3032 d were also not different among the dietary groups (data not shown).
Length of survival.
There was a significant effect of diet on survival rates (Log rank and
Wilcoxon tests, P
0.0001) (Figs. 1
,
2
). The OO group exhibited the lowest survival rate, whereas the CFM and
SO groups exhibited the greatest survival rates. Both CA and CO groups
showed significantly lower (Log rank and Wilcoxon tests, P
0.0001) survival rates than those of the SO and CFM groups, but
higher than that of the OO group, particularly at the later stages of
the study (Log rank test, P = 0.039; Wilcoxon test,
P = 0.075). When compared directly with the SO group,
the CA group also had a significantly lower survival rate (Log-rank
test, P = 0.0034; Wilcoxon test P = 0.0031). No difference was found between the CA and CO groups (Log rank
test, P = 0.59; Wilcoxon test, P = 0.56). At the beginning of the study, there was no significant
difference between the SO and the CFM groups (Wilcoxon test,
P = 0.43), but the CFM group had a slightly greater
survival rate later in the study (Log-rank test, P = 0.088).
|
|
General necropsy findings.
There were no significant pathologic abnormalities in the rats killed
at 3032 d. In rats that died or were killed with severe clinical
symptoms, acute intracranial and/or intracerebral hemorrhage was
evident in the majority of cases. The lesions were typical for the
SHRSP strain (Yamori 1989
) and consistent with those
observed in our previous study (Ratnayake et al. 2000
).
There were no qualitative differences between groups. In some cases,
there was evidence of earlier vascular damage accompanied by focal
discoloration of brain tissue. Such foci were characterized
microscopically by nests of macrophages filled with blood pigments,
mixed with small numbers of inflammatory cells. The brain lesions were
accompanied by pathologic changes in adjacent small arteries, i.e.,
atrophy of smooth muscle layers, collagenization of media with
infiltration of macrophages leading to a narrowing of the vascular
lumen, or obstruction. In the kidneys, there was evidence of a high
incidence of interstitial nephritis. Various degrees of ventricular
hypertrophy in the heart did not appear to be linked to dietary
factors.
Hematologic indices.
Dietary phytosterols had a significant effect on platelet
characteristics (Table 4
). SHRSP rats fed CA, CA + P, SO + P and CO (diets high in phytosterols)
had lower platelet counts and higher platelet volumes than SHRSP rats
fed the diets low in phytosterols (SO, OO and CFM) (P
< 0.0045). Although CA is high in phytosterols, differences were
observed only for platelet volume (P < 0.0045).
Further evidence for the effect of phytosterols on platelets comes from
a comparison between fortified and unfortified canola and soybean oils.
Fortification of canola and soybean oils with phytosterols
significantly lowered the platelet count and increased the platelet
volume. CA + P and SO + P groups had platelet counts and volumes
similar to those of the CA and CO groups. There were no differences in
the platelet count or volume among the three low phytosterol groups
(SO, OO and CFM).
|
Erythrocyte deformability profile.
In general, the deformability indices (DI) at 3032d for the high
phytosterol dietary groups (CA, CA + P, SO + P and CO) were lower than
those of the low phytosterol groups (SO, OO and CFM) (Table 5
). The differences were significant except between the CA and SO groups
(P = 0.1099). Furthermore, fortification of soybean oil
with phytosterols caused a significant reduction in the DI
(P = 0.0027).
|
Omin was slightly affected by the type of dietary
fat (Table 5)
. SO + Pfed rats had significantly higher values
compared with those fed the unfortified soybean oil, indicating that
they could be most susceptible to lysis. On the other hand, there was
no significant difference between the CA and CA + P groups, indicating
a minor effect of dietary phytosterols on Omin.
The CFM group, compared with all the other dietary groups, except the
OO group, had significantly lower Omin and would
be least susceptible to lysis.
Sterol composition of erythrocytes.
The cholesterol concentration was significantly (P < 0.05) lower and the total phytosterol concentration and the ratio of
total phytosterol to cholesterol were higher in erythrocytes of SHRSP
rats fed the four high phytosterol diets (CA, CA + P, SO + P and CO)
than those fed the low phytosterol diets (SO, OO and CFM) (Table 6
). A notable exception to this trend was the OO group; the erythrocyte
cholesterol concentration of this group was not different from that of
the high phytosterol dietary groups and significantly lower compared
with the SO and CFM groups. In general, the SHRSP rats fed high
phytosterol diets displayed a higher proportion of phytosterols in
erythrocytes (20, 32.5, 34.4 and 24% of total sterols in CA, CA + P,
SO + P and CO groups, respectively) than in the rats fed low
phytosterol diets (12, 8.6 and 8.8 in SO, OO and CFM groups,
respectively). There were no significant differences in total
phytosterols, cholesterol and the phytosterol/cholesterol ratio between
CA and CO groups, between SO and CFM groups and also between CA + P and
SO + P groups.
|
In rats fed CA, CA + P and SO + P, campesterol was the major
phytosterol in erythrocytes, followed by ß-sitosterol (Table 6)
. This
is to be expected because campesterol is absorbed more efficiently than
ß-sitosterol and other common dietary phytosterols (Ling and Jones 1995
). In the other dietary groups, both of these sterols
were present in almost equal amounts. This is probably because the
diets of these groups contained a very large proportion of
ß-sitosterol and a lower proportion of campesterol compared with the
CA, CA + P and SO + P diets (Table 2)
. The other dietary phytosterols,
including brassicasterol, although present in moderate quantities in
CA, CA + P and SO + P diets (Table 2)
, were barely detectable in
erythrocytes of all of the dietary groups.
Sterol composition of liver and kidneys.
Compared with erythrocytes, liver and kidneys had larger amounts of
cholesterol and phytosterols (Tables 7
and
8
). Nevertheless, the differences in sterol composition among the groups
were similar to those in erythrocytes. However, in contrast to
erythrocytes, cholesterol concentration in liver and kidneys was
significantly higher for the olive group compared with the high
phytosterol dietary groups, except the CO group. Additionally,
cholesterol concentration in tissues of the CO group were also not
significantly different from those of the SO and CFM groups. For the
erythrocytes, fortification of canola and soybean oil with phytosterols
significantly increased liver and kidney total phyotosterols.
Associated with this increase, there was a decrease in the cholesterol
concentration of liver with fortification of soybean oil but not with
canola oil. In kidneys, however, phytosterol fortification did not
affect the cholesterol concentration. These changes, however, increased
the phytosterol/cholesterol ratio in both liver and kidney, and the
increase was considerable for the soybean + phytosterol group.
Furthermore, similar to the erythrocytes, liver total sterols were
unaffected by the fortification of canola and soybean oils with
phytosterols, suggesting that phytosterols are replacing a part of the
cholesterol in the liver. In kidneys, however, the total sterol
concentration was increased, suggesting that phytosterols are
incorporated into the kidney without affecting its cholesterol
concentration.
|
|
Sterol composition of plasma.
Table 9
shows plasma lipid data measured according to enzymatic methods. It
should be noted here that the enzymatic method for cholesterol is not
specific for this sterol or any other individual sterol. The method
measures the total sterols; therefore, the values shown in Table 9
for
whole-plasma and HDL sterols represent the sum of cholesterol and
phytosterols. The composition of individual sterols in whole plasma,
however, was measured by GLC and the values, expressed as percentage of
total sterols, are shown in Table 10
.
|
|
In general, plasma triglyceride concentration was lower for the low phytosterol diet groups compared with the high phytosterol diet groups, but the values were significantly (P < 0.05) lower only for the SO group.
Phytosterol fortification significantly (P < 0.05)
increased the plasma total and HDL sterols (Table 9)
. These increases
were greater in particular for the fortified soybean oil group
(P = 0.002 for both total and HDL sterols). Phytosterol
fortification also affected the plasma sterol profile. Cholesterol
proportion was decreased significantly with a concomitant increase in
the proportion of phytosterols; specifically, there was a large
increase in the proportions of campesterol and ß-sitosterol (Table 10)
. Thus, the increase in plasma total sterol with phytosterol
fortification could be attributed to increased phytosterol
incorporation into plasma.
Plasma triglyceride levels also increased with phytosterol fortification, but this was significant only for the fortified soybean oil group (P = 0.033).
Fatty acid composition of erythrocytes.
There was a very little variation in the fatty acid composition of erythrocytes among the dietary groups (data not shown). The most noticeable difference was the significantly (P < 0.05) lower percentage of (n-3) docosahexaenoic acid in the erythrocytes of the OO and CO groups compared with all other dietary groups. Fortification of canola oil and soybean oil with phytosterols also had no major effect on erythrocyte fatty acid profile. In general, there was no apparent relationship between the erythrocyte fatty acid profile and the dietary level of phytosterols.
Correlations between mean survival times and, erythrocyte sterol content, deformability index of erythrocytes and platelet number.
The erythrocyte cholesterol concentration was strongly correlated with
the mean survival time as well as with the erythrocyte DI (Table 11
). There was also a correlation between mean survival time and the
erythrocyte DI. These correlations became very strong
(r2 > 0.90) and significant
(P < 0.005) when the data for the OO group were not
included in the regression analysis. In contrast to cholesterol,
erythrocyte total phytosterols, campesterol and ß-sitosterol
displayed weak, negative correlations
(r2 < 0.40, P > 0.05) with mean survival time and the erythrocyte DI. The correlations
between erythrocyte phytosterol concentrations and mean survival time,
however, were stronger (r2 > 0.40,
P < 0.05, except for campesterol and
campesterol/cholesterol) when the data for the OO group were excluded
from the regression analysis. The inverse relationships of erythrocyte
campesterol, ß-sitosterol and total phytosterol concentrations with
the DI, however, were strong (r2 >
0.40) and significant (P < 0.05) in both scenarios,
i.e., with and without the inclusion of data for the OO group in the
regression analysis. Furthermore, there was a very strong negative
correlation between the total phytosterol concentration in the diet and
platelet number (r2 = 0.90,
P = 0.0013 with OO data and
r2 = 0.87, P = 0.0063
without OO data) and a strong positive correlation between DI and
platelet number (r2 > 0.90,
P < 0.005 both with and without OO data).
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Feeding phytosterol-enriched diets to SHRSP rats resulted in significant alterations in the sterol profile of various tissues. There was a large incorporation of phytosterols, particularly campesterol and ß-sitosterol, in RBC, plasma, liver and kidneys; this was accompanied by a reduction in the cholesterol concentration, which shows that dietary phytosterols replace some of the cholesterol in various tissues in SHRSP rats. Consequently, these changes markedly increased the phytosterol/cholesterol ratio in plasma, RBC membranes, liver and kidney. These changes in the tissue sterol profiles were associated with shorter survival rates and poorer cell membrane integrity, as shown by the lower DI of erythrocytes of SHRSP rats fed the phytosterol-enriched diets.
The DI gives a quantitative measurement of the mechanical stability and
flexibility of a population RBC or RBC membranes in response to a
constant shear stress as a function of increasing osmolality
(Clark et al. 1983
). Unstable, less flexible and less
deformable cell membranes give low DI values in the ektacytometer.
Thus, the low DI values seen in this study for SHRSP rats fed
phytosterol-enriched diets suggest that the phytosterols make the
cell membrane more rigid and less flexible. Increased membrane rigidity
was also observed in liver microsomes of healthy Wistar rats fed a diet
supplemented with 3% ß-sitosterol + 2% campesterol (Leiken and Brenner 1989
). The increase in the membrane rigidity was
attributed to partial replacement of liver microsome cholesterol by
ß-sitosterol and campesterol. In another study, in vitro replacement
of a part of the cholesterol complement in human erythrocyte cell
membranes by phytosterols caused a significant increase in the osmotic
fragility of cell membranes (Bruckerdorfer et al. 1969
).
Increased RBC membrane phytosterol incorporation, resulting in
increased osmotic fragility, has also been observed in patients with
phytosterolemia (Wang et al. 1981
), a very rare inborn
disease due to a defect in cholesterol metabolism (Bhattacharyya and Connor 1974
, Miettinen 1980
, Wang et al. 1981
).
Impaired cell deformability can cause a reduction in cell survival
because the inextensible membranes are easily ruptured during physical
stress (Weed 1970
). This effect may be particularly
noticeable in SHRSP rats because they have defective and more fragile
cell membranes than other rat strains (Yamori et al. 1980
and 1984b
). The cell abnormalities include higher membrane
rigidity, increased permeability for Na+ and
K+, abnormally low Ca2+
binding factor and high osmotic fragility. These abnormalities were
noted not only in the erythrocytes but also in vascular muscle cells
and are believed to be of pathogenic importance in hypertensive
vascular lesions because the cerebral hemorrhage and infarction noted
in SHRSP rats were commonly caused by arterionecrosis (Yamori 1989
). The cell abnormalities are due primarily to the low
amount of cholesterol in cell membranes, which is presumably a genetic
defect of SHRSP rats. Blood cholesterol concentration is also
abnormally low in these rats (Yamori et al. 1980
).
Consistent with these observations, laboratory feeding studies have
shown that dietary cholesterol is beneficial to these rats.
Low-to-moderate diet-induced increases in serum cholesterol were
associated with a significant reduction in the degree of
arterionecrosis and the occurrence of stroke (Ooneda et al. 1978
, Yamori et al. 1976
). In a more
recent study, a diet containing cholesterol (1 g/100 g diet)
significantly (P < 0.05) delayed the onset of stroke
and prolonged the life span of SHRSP rats by ~40% in both
NaCl-loaded and unloaded conditions (Hamano et al. 1995
). Diets with no added cholesterol greatly shortened
poststroke survival. These beneficial effects are most likely due to
incorporation of exogenous cholesterol into cell membranes, which leads
to an improvement of the cell membrane physical characteristics.
Considering the above, we suggest that dietary phytosterols and oils
enriched with phytosterols may exacerbate the development of
hemorrhagic stroke in SHRSP rats by further weakening the already
fragile cell membrane with the replacement of a part of the cholesterol
complement in the cell membrane by phytosterols. This could be a
possible mechanism by which phytosterols shorten the life span of SHRSP
rats. Measuring the deformability index with the ektacytometer provides
a unique opportunity to measure the functional properties of the RBC
much earlier than that indicated by measures such as a reduction in
cell count or an increase in RBC distribution width.
The levels of phyotosterols seen in the RBC, plasma and various tissues
of SHRSP rats in this study were very large and at least 510 times
greater than those reported for healthy rats fed diets containing
comparable amounts of phytosterols (Strandberg et al. 1989
, Sugano et al. 1977
). Furthermore,
phytosterols accounted for ~25% of the total sterols in SHRSP
tissues, whereas in normal rats and healthy humans, the proportion of
phytosterols is ~25% of the total sterol (Jones et al. 1997
). High levels of phytosterols in serum and RBC are also
associated with phytosterolemia (Bhattacharyya and Connor 1974
, Miettinen 1980
, Wang et al. 1981
). These patients have hemolytic anemia and defective
RBC membrane morphology, similar to that of SHRSP rats. They develop
premature atherosclerotic arterial disease due to excessive
accumulation of campesterol, sitosterol and other phytosterols in
blood, RBC and body tissues. The high concentration of phytosterols in
SHRSP rats may be caused by enhanced absorption of phytosterols, by
their impaired removal or by a combination of the two. Whatever the
mechanisms by which phytosterols are incorporated, the large
accumulation of phytosterols appears to compensate for the
naturally lower cholesterol concentration in the tissues. It may be
that SHRSP rats cannot synthesize enough cholesterol due to a genetic
defect, leading to increased phytosterol absorption and incorporation
into tissues as a substitute for cholesterol. This implies that SHRSP
rats may not discriminate between phytosterols and cholesterol in
intestinal absorption as effectively as normal rats and humans. A
similar hypothesis was suggested by Salen et al. (1989)
to explain the increased absorption of phytosterols by phytosterolemic
subjects.
Like SHRSP rats, humans with a history of hemorrhagic stroke also have
cell membrane abnormalities due to lower cholesterol concentration in
the cell membranes (Canessa et al. 1980
,
De Mendonca et al. 1980
, Konishi et al. 1982
, Tsuda et al. 1992
, Yamori et al. 1980
and 1984b
). Furthermore, in prospective
studies, hemorrhagic stroke has been found to occur at higher rates in
persons with low levels of blood total cholesterol than in persons with
higher levels. This peculiar lipid-stroke relationship has been
reported in Japanese populations (Kimura et al. 1972
,
Komachi et al. 1977
, Kroes and Ostwald 1971
, Lin et al. 1984
, Okada et al. 1976
, Shimamoto et al. 1989
, Tanaka et al. 1982
, Ueda et al. 1988
, Ueshima et al. 1980
), in Japanese men living in Hawaii (Iribarren et al. 1995
, Kagan et al. 1980
, Yano et al. 1989
) and Caucasian men and women in the U.S.
(Gordon et al. 1981
, Iribarren et al. 1996
, Iso et al. 1989
, Neaton et al. 1992
). Although the reasons behind these associations are
unknown, it is quite plausible that, as in SHRSP rats, the weakening of
cell membranes due to low circulating cholesterol may influence
arterionecrosis. Thus, it will be important for future studies to
consider whether large intakes of phytosterols would exacerbate the
development of hemorrhagic stroke in humans, as seen in SHRSP rats of
this study. A parallel situation exists in patients with
phytosterolemia (Bhattacharyya and Connor 1974
,
Miettinen 1980
, Wang et al. 1981
).
In addition to the detrimental effects on RBC membranes, phytosterols
markedly influenced platelet characteristics. The SHRSP rats fed canola
oil and other dietary fats enriched with phytosterols had lower
platelet counts than those fed soybean oil and the other two diets low
in phytosterols. The more pronounced reduction in platelet count
compared with RBC counts in the phytosterol-fed rats is not
unexpected because platelets have a half-life of 35 d compared
with 2540 d for RBC. A similar lower platelet count was reported in
phytosterolemia (Salen et al. 1989
) and apolipoprotein
Edeficient mice fed phytosterol-enriched diets
(Moghadasian et al. 1999
). In a clinical trial involving
healthy humans, feeding phytosterol-enriched margarine for 12 wk
led to a small, nonsignificant reduction in platelet number (-15.4
x 109/L, P > 0.05) (Plat and Mensink 1998
). Canola oil, compared with soybean oil, also
significantly (P < 0.05) reduced the platelet number
in studies involving very young piglets (Kramer et al. 1994
, Innis and Dyer 1999
). The correlation
between platelet number and the survival time observed in this study
suggests that the lowering of platelet number by dietary phytosterols
may also be associated with the early death of SHRSP rats.
Unfortunately, we did not analyze the sterol composition of platelets;
therefore it is not known whether phytosterols incorporated into the
platelet membrane could have affected the flexibility of platelet
membrane, similar to the effect observed for RBC.
Although the four phytosterol-enriched diets contained different levels of phytosterols, the survival rates, RBC DI and platelet count of SHRSP rats fed these diets were not significantly different. Particularly, there was no significant difference between rats fed canola oil and those fed canola oil fortified with phytosterols. On the other hand, fortified soybean oil produced more adverse effects than unfortified soybean oil. This might imply a threshold limit to the influence of phytosterols on biological variables of SHRSP rats. According to this logic, the threshold might already have been reached in unfortified canola oil, which provided 974 mg phytosterols/100 g oil. It appears that an increase in the dietary phytosterol concentration beyond what is found in canola oil does not produce any further changes. Soybean oil, on the other hand, has a low concentration of phytosterols (363 mg phytosterols/100 g oil). This appears to lie below the threshold limit because fortified soybean oil had significant adverse nutritional effects beyond those observed for unfortified soybean oil.
In this study, the rats fed the Canadian fat mimic diet exhibited the
greatest survival rate; this is clearly attributable to its high
cholesterol concentration and low phytosterol to cholesterol ratio,
relative to the other dietary fats tested. Most likely, dietary
cholesterol counteracted the unfavorable biological effects of
phytosterols. The longer life span of SHRSP rats fed fish oil and lard
found in the study of Huang et al. (1997)
may also be
explained by the presence of cholesterol in these dietary fats.
Of all the dietary fats tested in this study, olive oilfed rats had
the lowest survival rates despite a very low phytosterol concentration
. A similar observation was made by Huang et al. (1997)
who found no significant difference in survival rates between animals
fed canola and olive oils. These results suggest that another factor
(other than phytosterols) is shortening the life span of olive oilfed
SHRSP rats. This factor must operate by another mechanism because the
RBC membrane and platelet characteristics were similar to those of the
other rats fed low phytosterols. In addition to olive oil, Huang et al. (1997)
observed that oils such as high oleate sunflower,
high oleate safflower and evening primrose, which contain
low-to-moderate levels of phytosterols, exhibit life-shortening
activities comparable to those of canola oil. Previous studies in our
laboratory showed that there is no significant association between the
fatty acid composition of dietary fats and the life span of SHRSP rats
(Ratnayake et al. 2000
). Some of these results indicate
that in addition to phytosterols, another minor component in the
nonsaponifiable matter in some vegetable oils also affects the life
span of SHRSP rats.
Unlike in SHRSP rats and phytosterolemic subjects, dietary phytosterols
are usually considered safe and beneficial for both normal humans and
common laboratory animals (Ling and Jones 1995
). This
difference between SHRSP rats and phytosterolemics, and other
species might be attributed primarily to the poor intestinal absorption
and very low incorporation of phytosterols into plasma and tissues by
normal humans and laboratory animals. The beneficial effect of
phytosterols is due mainly to their ability to interfere with the
intestinal absorption of both dietary and biliary cholesterol.
Consumption of ß-sitosterol for 4 y by healthy humans resulted
in no adverse health effects as determined by kidney, liver functions
tests, hematology, urinalysis, electrocardiogram records and
gallbladder visualization (Shipley et al. 1968
).
Long-term (22 mo) oral administration of ß-sitosterol produced no
detrimental effects in rats, rabbits and dogs (Shipley et al. 1968
). Chronic administration of ß-sitosterol subcutaneously
to either male or female rats was well tolerated without any evidence
of tissue abnormalities (Malini and Vanithakumari 1990
).
In apolipoprotein Edeficient mice, phytosterols (2 g/100 g diet) were
antiatherogenic; this beneficial effect of phytosterols was accompanied
by less fragile RBC, unlike the situation in SHRSP rats and
sitosterolemia (Moghadasian et al. 1997
and 1999
). The
observed decrease in the RBC osmotic fragility of apolipoprotein
Edeficient mice was attributed to the decrease in plasma cholesterol
level because of the inhibitory effect of phytosterols on cholesterol
absorption in the intestine and no significant accumulation of
phytosterols in plasma and tissues (Moghadasian et al. 1999
). Furthermore, in contrast to SHRSP rats, which are
sustained by dietary cholesterol, the cholesterol-fed rabbits (0.5
g/10 g diet for 1 y) suffered from a RBC deformability, compared
with controls fed a cholesterol-free diet (Kanakaraj and Singh 1989
). These observations might indicate that more
attention should be given to the cholesterol balance in stabilizing
membrane function and the fact that different species of laboratory
animals may respond differently to the cell membrane cholesterol
balance. The various studies also point out that phytosterols that
exert beneficial antiatherogenic effects in humans and some animal
species, may be toxic to some other species, viz., SHRSP rats and
phytosterolemic subjects, when a gene defect induces a
cholesterol-related membrane abnormality.
Although canola oil, corn oil and olive oil reduced the life span of
SHRSP rats, their safety in human nutrition for the general population
is unquestionable because all of these oils have been used in many
countries over several centuries or decades without any adverse health
consequences. Moreover, SHRSP rats are a model for intracerebral
hemorrhagic stroke (Yamori et al. 1987
), which is not a
major health issue in many countries. In Canada, intracerebral
hemorrhagic stroke incidence is very low and declining (Mayo et al. 1996
) despite a high increase in the consumption of canola
oil over the last two decades. Currently, in Canada, intracerebral
hemorrhagic stroke accounts for 6.77 deaths per 100,000 population.
Coronary heart disease (CHD), on the other hand, is the leading cause
of death in most industrialized countries, and its importance as a
major health problem is increasing in developing countries
(Tunstall-Pedoe et al. 1999
). High serum
cholesterol is one of the main risk factors for CHD, and a high intake
of saturated fatty acids is the main determinant of serum cholesterol
concentration (Hegsted et al. 1993
). Lowering the intake
of saturated fat is one of the approaches used for maintaining a
desirable serum cholesterol concentration. Research conducted over the
last four decades has firmly established the hypocholesterolemic
effects of phytosterols (Ling and Jones 1995
). Thus,
canola oil, because of its low concentration of saturated fatty acids
and high phytosterol concentration, could be considered more beneficial
than other common dietary fats in lowering the blood lipid risk factors
for the development of CHD.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
2 Presented in part at the 90th American Oil
Chemists Society Annual Meeting and Expo, May 912, 1999, Orlando,
FL [Ratnayake, W.M.N., LAbbé, M. R., Mueller, R., Sarwar,
G., Plouffe, L., Hollywood, R., Trick, K. & Hayward, S. (1999) Effects
of vegetable oils and sterols on the life span of stroke prone
spontaneously hypertensive rats. S26S27 (abs.)] and at the 23rd
World Congress and Exhibition of the International Society for Fat
Research, 37 October, 1999, Brighton, UK [Ratnayake, W.M.N. &
LAbbé, M. R. (1999) Adverse health effects of phytosterols
on stroke prone spontaneously hypertensive rats. p. 49 (abs.)]. ![]()
4 Abbreviations used: CA, canola oil; CA +
P, canola oil fortified with phytosterols; CFM, Canadian fat mimic;
CHD, coronary heart disease; CO, corn oil; DI, deformability index; EI
max, maximum elongation; EI min, minimum elongation; GLC,
gas-liquid chromatography; OO, olive oil; SHRSP, stroke-prone
spontaneously hypertensive rats; SO, soybean oil; SO + P, soybean oil
fortified with phytosterols. ![]()
Manuscript received October 15, 1999. Initial review completed December 8, 1999. Revision accepted February 10, 2000.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1. Bertrand L. Santé Québec: Les Québécoises et les Québécois mangent-ils mieux? Rapport de lEnquête sur la Nutrition, 1990 1995 Ministère de la Santé et des Services Sociaux Montreal, Québec, Canada
2. Bhattacharyya A., Connor W. E. ß-Sitosterolemia and xanthomatosis. A newly described lipid storage disease in two sisters. J. Clin. Investig. 1974;53:1033-1043
3. Bligh E. G., Dyer W. J. A rapid method of total lipid extraction and purification. Can. J. Biochem. 1959;37:911-917[Medline]
4. Bruckerdorfer K. R., Demel R. A., De Gier J., Van Deenen L.L.M. The effect of partial replacements of membrane cholesterol by other steroids on the osmotic fragility and glycerol permeability of erythrocytes. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1969;183:334-345[Medline]
5. Canesssa M., Adragna N., Connolly T., Solomon H., Tosteson D. C. Na-Li countertransport is increased in red cells of hypertensive patients. N. Engl. J. Med. 1980;302:772-776[Abstract]
6.
Clark M. R., Mohandas N., Sholet B. Osmotic gradient ektacytometer: comprehensive characterization of red cell volume and surface maintenance. Blood 1983;61:899-910
7.
De Mendonca M., Grichois M. L., Garay R. P., Sassard J., Benlshay D., Meyer P. Abnormal net Na+ and K+ fluxes in erythrocytes of three varieties of genetically hypertensive rats. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 1980;77:4283-4286
8. Gordon T., Kannel W. B., Castelli W. P., Dawber T. R. Lipoproteins, cardiovascular disease and death: the Framingham Study. Arch. Intern. Med. 1981;141:1128-1131[Abstract]
9. Hamano M., Mashiko S., Onda T., Tomita I., Tomita T. Effects of cholesterol-diet on the incidence of stroke and life-span in malignant stroke prone spontaneously hypertensive rats. Jpn. Heart J. 1995;36:511
10. Health Canada The Canadian Nutrient File 1997 Food Directorate Health Protection Branch, Health Canada, Ottawa, Canada.
11.
Hegsted D. M., Ausman L. M., Johnson J. A., Dallal G. E. Dietary fat and serum lipids: an evaluation of the experimental data. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 1993;57:875-883
12. Hobbs L. M., Rayner T. E., Howe P.R.C. Dietary fish oil prevents the development of renal damage in salt-loaded stroke-prone spontaneously hypertensive rats. Clin. Exp. Pharmacol. Physiol. 1996;23:508-513[Medline]
13. Howe P.R.C., Head R. J., Smith R. M. High dietary sodium intake counteracts the antihypertensive effect of fish oil in spontaneously hypertensive rats. Proc. Nutr. Soc. Aust. 1989;14:148
14. Huang M. Z., Naito Y., Watanabe S., Kobayashi T., Kanai H., Nagai H., Okuyama H. Effect of rapeseed and dietary oils on the mean survival time of stroke-prone spontaneously hypertensive rats. Biol. Pharmacol. Bull. 1996;19:554-557
15. Huang M. Z., Watanabe S., Kobayashi T., Nagatsu A., Sakakibara J., Okuyama H. Unusual effects of some vegetable oils on the survival time of stroke-prone spontaneously hypertensive rats. Lipids 1997;32:745-751[Medline]
16.
Innis S. M., Dyer R. A. Dietary canola oil alters hematological induces and blood lipids in neonatal piglets fed formula. J. Nutr. 1999;129:1261-1268
17.
Iribarren C., Jacobs D. R., Sadler M., Claxton A. J., Sidney S. Low total serum cholesterol and intracerebral haemorrhagic stroke: is the association confined to elderly men?. Stroke 1996;27:1993-1998
18. Iribarren C., Reed D. M., Burchfiel C. M., Dwyer J. H. Serum total cholesterol and mortality: confounding and risk mo