![]() |
|
|
Metabolic Research Group, VA Medical Center and University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY
2To whom correspondence should be addressed.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
KEY WORDS:
| DIETARY FIBER AND CORONARY HEART DISEASE |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Since the report of Morris et al. (1977)
,
epidemiologists have reported a strong link between dietary fiber
intake and prevalence of CHD (Rimm et al. 1996
).
Vegetarian populations have higher fiber intakes than nonvegetarian
control populations (Beilin 1994
, Kritchevsky et al. 1984
) and experience better health and fewer premature
deaths (Anderson 1990
). All-cause mortality is
significantly lower for vegetarian than for age- and gender-matched
nonvegetarian individuals (Kahn et al. 1984
,
Lemon and Walden 1966
); this reduction is related, in
part, to a significant reduction in CHD mortality (Kristein et al. 1977
, Ruys and Hickie 1976
, Wynder 1959
). Although the health benefits associated with
vegetarian diets can be attributed, in part, to physical activity and
other healthy lifestyle practices, the increased dietary fiber intake
appears to make a significant contribution (Anderson 1990
, Rimm et al. 1996
).
Over the past 20 years, numerous studies have examined the
association between dietary fiber intake and risk for CHD.
Rather remarkably, all of these studies suggest that there is a
negative relationship when evaluating dietary fiber intake with CHD.
Seven studies (Burr and Sweetman 1982
, Hallfrisch et al. 1988
, Khaw and Barrett-Connor 1987
,
Kromhout et al. 1982
, Kushi et al. 1985
,
Liu et al. 1982
, Morris et al. 1977
)
noted the negative association specifically with dietary fiber; the
remainder used other markers of fiber intake such as legume intake,
salad intake, complex carbohydrate or vegetable protein intake.
Research findings may depend on the epidemiologic design, which can be
ecological, cohort, case-comparison or population-based.
Ecological studies are designed to assess the association between two
variables, comparing groups whose selection is based on a variable that
is not being studied, such as geographical location. Liu et al. (1982)
conducted a univariate analysis on data for both men and
women ages 3574 y from 20 economically advanced countries, collecting
data for the years 19651969. They found that fiber intake, estimated
from consumption of vegetables, fruits, grains and legumes, yielded a
significant inverse correlation with CHD mortality rates.
Cohort studies evaluate the association between a risk factor and the
incidence of a disease as compared among two or more groups. These
groups are determined on the basis of levels of exposure to a
particular variable. Morris et al. (1977)
published one
of the first cohort studies on the health implications of a high fiber
diet in cardiovascular disease. From 1956 to 1966, 7-d dietary surveys
were collected from 337 middle-aged men in London and Southeast
England. These men were reevaluated in 1976 to determine those who had
developed clinical coronary heart disease. From this information, it
was noted that dietary fiber from cereals was independently associated
with a lower rate of disease. In 1973, Burr and Sweetnam
(1982)
recruited 10,943 subjects to test the hypothesis that
risk of death from disease can be reduced by a high intake of fiber.
After 7 y, no significant associations were found with fiber.
However, a lower mortality from cerebrovascular disease was noted in
subjects who regularly consumed whole-meal bread. A 1960 study by
Kromhout (1982)
enlisted the help of 871 middle-aged
men in the Netherlands to evaluate risk indicators for CHD. After
10 y of follow-up, it was suggested that a diet of at least
37 g of dietary fiber per day may be protective against chronic
diseases such as CHD.
Case-comparison studies assess the association between a disease state
and risk factors, comparing diseased vs. nondiseased subjects. The risk
factor data are often collected either concurrently or retrospectively.
Khaw and Barrett-Connor (1987)
evaluated the
relationship between dietary fiber intake and 12-y mortality rates from
ischemic heart disease in a population-based cohort of 859 men and
women living in Southern California. They calculated that every 6 g increase in daily fiber consumption was associated with a 25%
reduction in ischemic heart disease mortality. Kushi and collaborators
(Kushi et al. 1985
) examined the relation between diet
and mortality from CHD in a prospective epidemiologic study of 1001
middle-aged men. Intakes of fiber, vegetable protein and starch
were lower in those individuals who died from coronary heart disease.
However, these observations were not significant after adjustment for
other risk factors. In 1992, Bolton-Smith et al.
(1992)
published results of a case-comparison study
in which 10,359 men and women ages 4059 who were patients of 260
general practitioners throughout Scotland were evaluated. Subjects were
divided into the categories of CHD-diagnosed, CHD-undiagnosed and
non-CHD. Food-frequency questionnaires were used to record dietary
habits. The results suggested that a high dietary fiber intake may be
cardioprotective in both males and females.
Population surveys assess the cross-sectional association between
two variables by comparing population groups. For example, one can
measure the prevalence, mean value or distribution of a particular
characteristic or disease in a population. Hallfrisch et al. (1988)
used 7-d diet records to estimate fiber intake for the
845 men participating in the Baltimore Mean Longitudinal Study of
Aging. On the basis of this information, the researchers determined
that a higher fiber consumption was associated with lower levels of
risk factors for coronary artery disease, including systolic and
diastolic blood pressure, triglycerides and fasting plasma glucose.
Recently, He et al. (1995)
studied 850 Chinese subjects
to evaluate the relationship of oats and buckwheat to cardiovascular
disease. Dietary intake of oats and buckwheat was determined via a
dietary questionnaire. Although oat intake was associated with a lower
body mass index (BMI), systolic and diastolic blood pressure and HDL
cholesterol, buckwheat intake was associated with lower serum
cholesterol, LDL cholesterol and a higher ratio of HDL to total
cholesterol.
Although several clinical trials have established an inverse relation
between fiber intake and CHD, two studies (Neal and Balm 1990
, Rimm et al. 1996
) suggest that the
intake of cereal fiber has the strongest negative
association with CHD. This is somewhat surprising because cereal fiber,
in most regions of the world reported in these studies, comes largely
from wheat intake. Wheat bran does not decrease serum cholesterol and
LDL cholesterol concentrations as effectively as does oat bran or
psyllium, sources of soluble fiber. Perhaps the phytochemicals specific
to wheat bran (Slavin 1994
) may have
triglyceride-lowering effects and CHD protective effects by
mechanisms not related to LDL cholesterol reductions. The
triglyceride-lowering effects of wheat bran are discussed in the
next section.
Despite the fact that some unknowns exist about the precise mechanism mediating lipoprotein changes, substantial evidence supports the role of fiber. Ecological, cohort, case-comparison, population-based and most recently clinical trials support the inverse relationship between dietary fiber in the diet and ASCVD.
| LIPOPROTEIN EFFECTS OF DIETARY FIBER |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In addition to its favorable effects on fasting and postprandial serum lipoproteins, as detailed below, dietary fiber intake affects a number of other CHD risk factors. The effects of fiber intake on these factors such as hypertension, diabetes and obesity are summarized below.
Most soluble or viscous fibers have hypocholesterolemic effects
(Anderson et al. 1990
, Glore et al. 1994
). In general, these soluble fibers, such as psyllium, oat
bran, guar and pectin, decrease serum cholesterol and LDL cholesterol
concentrations without affecting serum triglycerides. Often,
consumption of these soluble fibers is accompanied by distinct
reductions in serum HDL cholesterol concentrations. For example, in
studies of the effects of dry beans on serum lipoprotein
concentrations, we noted that consumption of 100 g of dry beans
per day, without other changes in macronutrient consumption, was
accompanied by a 16.1% net reduction (bean change minus control
change) in serum LDL cholesterol concentrations and a 9.9% net
reduction in serum HDL cholesterol concentrations (Anderson 1995b
).
Animal models provide a suitable approach for comparing
lipid-lowering effects of dietary fibers under controlled
conditions. We have performed >30 such studies comparing 610 fibers
in each study with ~10 rats in each treatment (Anderson et al. 1994
, Anderson 1995a
). Table 1
provides information about the effects of different fibers on
serum lipids of rats after 3 wk of consuming purified diets providing
~67% carbohydrate, 15% protein, 6% fat, 6% dietary fiber, 1%
cholesterol, 0.2% cholic acid, vitamins and minerals (Anderson 1995a
). In this model, psyllium had the largest
cholesterol-lowering effect by decreasing serum cholesterol by 32%
and liver cholesterol by 52%. Oat gum and guar gum were slightly less
effective and decreased serum cholesterol by ~22%, compared with
values for cellulose-fed rats. Pectin has been reported to have a
wide range of effects, depending on molecular weight and degree of
methoxylation (Ebihara et al. 1979
, Jud and
Truswell 1982
), whereas oat bran and soy fiber produce modest
effects (Anderson et al. 1994
, Anderson 1995a
).
|
In humans, psyllium and guar gum appear to be the most effective
cholesterol-lowering soluble fibers (Anderson et al. 1990
). The hypocholesterolemic effects of psyllium
(Olson et al. 1997
), guar gum (Todd et al. 1990
) and oat bran (Ripsin et al. 1992
) are well
documented by meta-analyses. Our 1990 analysis of 23 human studies
described the effects of guar gum supplementation on serum cholesterol.
A median reduction of 11% (range, from +3% to -38%) was noted with
inclusion of guar gum in the diet. Significant reductions in serum
cholesterol levels were found in 20 of the 23 studies evaluating guar
gum supplementation (Anderson et al. 1990
). Similarly, a
1992 meta-analysis by Ripsin et al. (1992)
tested
the hypothesis that oat supplementation would lower serum cholesterol
levels. Ten clinical trials were evaluated, and a reduction of 5.9
mg/dL (-0.13 mmol/L) in total cholesterol was noted in subjects
consuming an oat supplement. However, the most significant reductions
were found in trials that used hypercholesterolemic subjects with
initially higher cholesterol levels.
Pectin also has significant hypocholesterolemic effects
(Anderson et al. 1990
), whereas soy fiber has a modest
effect in humans (Lo et al. 1986
). A summary of 19
clinical studies evaluating the effects of pectin supplementation on
serum cholesterol was included in our 1990 analysis. A median reduction
of 8% (range, -5 to -18%) in total cholesterol was noted in
subjects receiving pectin in their diet. A significant reduction in
total cholesterol was found in 13 of the 19 trials evaluated
(Anderson et al. 1990
). Other less widely studied and
used soluble fibers, such as locust bean gum (Zavarol et al. 1983
) and konjac mannan (Anderson et al. 1990
),
have modest hypocholesterolemic effects.
The effects of soluble fiber intake on specific lipoproteins is of
great importance. LDL cholesterol appears to be the most atherogenic
lipoprotein (Navab et al. 1996
), but HDL cholesterol has
an extremely important counterbalancing effect (Gowri 1997
). The atherogenicity of triglyceride-rich particles is
still debated, but postprandial hypertriglyceridemia probably
contributes to risk for CHD (Anderson et al. 1995b
). Because LDL particles carry ~65% of the
cholesterol in serum, changes in total serum cholesterol values largely
follow changes in serum LDL cholesterol concentrations. Soluble or
viscous fibers have specific effects on LDL cholesterol and exert only
minimal effects on other lipoprotein particles. In our
meta-analysis of eight studies conducted in a comparable manner,
administration of 10.4 g of psyllium daily for 8 wk to
hypercholesterolemic subjects consuming an American Heart Association
(AHA) Step I diet was accompanied by a net reduction (psyllium minus
placebo) of 6.7% in LDL cholesterol (P < 0.0001)
(Anderson, J. W., unpublished observations). Similarly, specific
effects on LDL cholesterol concentrations have also been noted in
subjects consuming oat bran (Ripsin et al. 1992
).
Although psyllium and oat bran tend to decrease HDL cholesterol
concentrations slightly, these changes are not significant. Because HDL
cholesterol is an umbrella term for a variety of small lipoprotein
particles, namely, HDL2,
HDL3, as well as apolipoprotein (apo) A-I
(only) and apo A-I/A-II particles (Silverman and Pasternak 1993
), measurements of the total HDL cholesterol concentration
have serious limitations. Recent studies indicate that specific
interventions affect the antiatherogenic HDL particles
(HDL2 and apo A-I particles) selectively,
whereas other interventions tend to affect the neutral or atherogenic
HDL particles (apo A-I/A-II) (Silverman and Pasternak 1993
). Estrogens may increase concentrations of antiatherogenic
HDL particles, whereas alcohol may increase the less protective
particles (Silverman and Pasternak 1993
). The effects of
dietary fibers on the specific HDL subfractions are not well
delineated. In our meta-analysis (Anderson, J. W., unpublished
observations), we noted that psyllium supplementation slightly
increased the serum apo-A-I concentrations and significantly increasing
the apo-A-I/apo-B ratio. Further studies are required to understand the
specific effects of soluble fibers on HDL subfractions.
| MECHANISMS FOR HYPOCHOLESTEROLEMIC EFFECTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Soluble fibers such as psyllium and oat bran appear to exert their
principal effects on cholesterol metabolism through decreases in bile
acid absorption. These soluble fibers bind bile acids in the small
intestine, alter micelle formation and decrease their absorption in the
small intestine. Consequently, more bile acids are excreted with the
feces. Oat bran, for example, increases fecal bile acid loss more than
twofold and increases loss of deoxycholic acid (DCA) by 240%
(Marlett et al. 1994
). Psyllium also increases bile acid
excretion significantly and selectively increases the fractional
turnover of both chenodeoxycholic acid (CDCA) and cholic acid (CA)
(Everson et al. 1992
). Acting somewhat like
bile-acid binding resins, these soluble fibers deplete the bile
salt pool and divert cholesterol synthesis from lipoprotein precursors
to bile acid synthesis. Short-chain fatty acid (SCFA) effects on
the liver may hamper the ability of the liver to compensate for these
changes in cholesterol synthetic needs (Wright et al. 1990
).
Martlett et al. (1994)
evaluated nine normolipidemic
young men fed a control diet with or without oat bran for 2 mo. Serum
CA and CDCA were measured using radiolabeled carbon as a means to
monitor bile acid kinetics. Results of this study indicated that bile
acid excretion and concomitant increases in bile acid synthesis are
primary contributors to changes in cholesterol absorption. They found
that, when subjects consumed the oat bran diet, total daily fecal bile
acid excretion more than doubled, with a significant elevation in
secondary bile acid excretion as well. Although the total bile acid
pool was unchanged, the CA pool size decreased, whereas the DCA pool
doubled. This elevation in DCA is significant because DCA inhibits
primary bile acid synthesis by affecting hepatic cholesterol 7
-hydroxylase activity and by inhibiting ß-hydroxyl-ß-methyl
glutarate (HMG)-CoA reductase activity, the rate-limiting step in
cholesterol synthesis (Marlett et al. 1994
). In
addition, DCA serves as a more effective inhibitor of cholesterol
absorption than chenodeoxycholic acid (CDCA) in healthy humans
(Leiss et al. 1984
).
SCFA production in the colon, absorption into the portal vein and
effects on the liver appear to play a minor regulatory role in
attenuating hepatic cholesterol synthesis (Anderson 1995c
, Anderson and Chen 1979
, Wright et al. 1990
). After meals containing soluble fibers, serum acetate
levels increase, reflecting more delivery of SCFA to the liver. Our in
vitro data suggest that propionate specifically inhibits cholesterol
and fatty acid synthesis in the liver (Wright et al. 1990
). It seems likely that the combination of bile acid loss
and mild attenuation of hepatic cholesterol synthesis results in lower
serum cholesterol and LDL cholesterol concentrations. Although it could
be tested,, this hypothesis has not been examined carefully in humans.
Although fiber-rich foods are associated with significant
protection from CHD and viscous hydrolyzed fibers have
hypocholesterolemic effects, these effects may be minimized if purified
fibers are used. For example, guar gum has significant
cholesterol-lowering effects (Anderson et al. 1990
),
whereas hydrolyzed guar gum lacks this effect (Anderson et al. 1993
). Furthermore, although soy proteins rich in soy
isoflavones have significant hypocholesterolemic effects
(Anderson et al. 1995a
, Anthony et al. 1996
, Wagner et al. 1997
), purified isoflavone
supplements may lack this effect (Nestel et al. 1997
).
Thus, hydrolysis of fibers and isoflavones to extract them for use as
supplements may alter their physiologic effectiveness.
| DIETARY FIBER EFFECTS ON NON-LIPOPROTEIN CHD RISK FACTORS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Controlled clinical trials have failed to provide persuasive evidence
that increased fiber intake is associated with a decrease in blood
pressure. However, epidemiologic studies support the hypothesis that
higher levels of dietary fiber intake are associated with lower levels
of systolic as well as diastolic blood pressure (Ascherio et al. 1992
, Joffres et al. 1987
, Witteman et al. 1989
). In addition, research with vegetarian subjects, who
have higher intakes of dietary fiber than control subjects, has found
that the vegetarians have lower blood pressures than their matched
controls (Sacks et al. 1975
). Median reductions of 3.5
mm Hg in systolic and 2.2 mm Hg in diastolic blood pressure were noted
in three controlled studies using vegetarian diets (Wright et al. 1979
). Similarly, Appel et al. (1997)
reported that a diet that is rich in fruits, vegetables and low fat
dairy foods can substantially lower blood pressure. The DASH
Collaborative Research Group enrolled 459 adult subjects with systolic
blood pressures <160 mm Hg and diastolic blood pressures between 80
and 95 mm Hg. After 3 wk of consuming a control diet, subjects were
randomly allocated to a diet rich in fruits and vegetables, a
combination diet rich in fruits, vegetables and low fat dairy foods, or
a control diet for 8 wk. At the end of treatment, systolic and
diastolic blood pressure had dropped 5.5 and 3.0 mm Hg more,
respectively, with consumption of the combination diet and were 2.8 and
1.1 mm Hg higher, respectively, with the fruit and vegetable diet
compared with the control diet. This reduction in blood pressure was
most significant in subjects with an initial systolic blood pressure
140 mm Hg, diastolic blood pressure
90 mm Hg or both.
Unfortunately, a vast array of clinical trials has produced conflicting results, making it difficult to form concrete recommendations concerning use of dietary fiber as a means to lower blood pressure. Although it appears that a negative correlation exists, further research is required to understand the variation in blood pressure response seen across human trials.
Obesity.
Obesity has been found to be an independent risk factor for coronary
heart disease (Manson et al. 1995
, Solomon and Manson 1997
). Research supports the role that dietary fiber
plays in controlling obesity by offering a prolonged feeling of
satiety. A study of 50 male college students was designed to determine
the effects of a high fiber diet on subsequent food intake. It was
determined that adding 5.2 g of crude fiber to a meal
significantly reduced food intake. In addition, those subjects
receiving the high fiber meal felt significantly fuller than did the
lower fiber subjects immediately after eating (Porikos and Hagamen 1986
). A similar controlled study by Rigaud et al. (1987)
enlisted the help of 20 healthy young volunteers who
received either a high fiber supplement (7.3 g fiber per day) or
placebo (0.6 g fiber per day). Visual analog scales were used to
evaluate feelings of hunger immediately after each of three main meals.
Mean hunger ratings were significantly greater during the control
period compared with during fiber treatment. Rytigg et al.
(1989)
conducted a 52-wk controlled study to determine the
effects of a dietary fiber supplement on weight maintenance and
reduction in 90 female subjects with uncomplicated excess weight of
110130% of ideal body weight. It was noted that hunger feeling in
the fiber group decreased significantly at all three meals compared
with placebo.
These three studies offer support to the suggestion that a diet rich in
fiber can help control appetite by increasing satiety. With the new
United States health standards, which indicate that a BMI > 25
increases CHD risk (NHLBI Communications 1998
), it is
prudent to reduce weight, especially in the Western world where
waistlines continue to expand.
Diabetes and hyperinsulinemia.
An estimated 7080 million persons in the United States have insulin
resistance. Insulin resistance is an important risk factor in
the development and progression of hypertension, dyslipidemia, obesity,
diabetes (Ferrannini et al. 1987
, Lillioja et al. 1993
, Reaven 1988
) and possibly CHD
(Pyorala 1997
, Stout 1990
). A diet rich
in fiber has been shown to improve insulin sensitivity (Anderson et al. 1991
, Fukagawa et al. 1990
) and
lower serum insulin concentrations (Wolever and Jenkins 1986
).
A controlled, random allocation, crossover, metabolic study
(Anderson et al. 1991
) allocated 10 subjects with
insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) to a low carbohydrate,
low fiber (LCLF) or a high carbohydrate, high fiber (HCHF) diet for
28 d at a time. The HCHF diet provided 35 g dietary
fiber/1000 kcal in the form of whole-grain or bran cereals, dried
beans, vegetables and fruit. Compared with the LCLF diet, the HCHF diet
reduced basal insulin requirements and increased carbohydrate disposed
of per unit insulin. This study indicated that Type 1 diabetic subjects
were more sensitive to insulin when consuming a high carbohydrate, high
fiber diet than when consuming a low carbohydrate, low fiber, high fat
diet. High carbohydrate, high fiber, low fat diets have also been
recommended for patients with Type 2 diabetes. A diet of 6365% of
energy from carbohydrates, 1012% of energy from fat and 45 g/d of
fiber for 2 wk was found to offer a significant benefit in metabolic
control in volunteers with noninsulin-dependent diabetes mellitus
(NIDDM). A similar improvement was not seen in a complementary high
carbohydrate, low fat diet that was low in fiber (20 g/d)
(O'Dea et al. 1989
).
Fukagawa et al. (1990)
studied 12 healthy individuals to
examine the effects of a HCHF diet. The HCHF diet provided
68% of energy as carbohydrates and 33 g/1000 kcal of dietary fiber
compared with 43% of energy as carbohydrates and 7g/1000 kcal of
dietary fiber for the control diet. The HCHF diet was followed for
2128 d. The HCHF diet lowered fasting serum glucose levels from 5.3
± 0.2 to 5.1 ± 0.1 mmol/L (P < 0.01) and
insulin from 66.0 ± 7.9 to 49.5 ± 5.7 pmol/L (P
< 0.01). In addition, glucose disposal rates increased from 18.87
± 1.66 µmol/(kg·min) in those consuming the
control diet compared with 23.87 ± 2.78
µmol/(kg·min) (P < 0.02) for those
provided the HCHF diet. From these results, the authors concluded that
a HCHF diet may improve carbohydrate metabolism by enhancing peripheral
sensitivity to insulin in healthy adults.
Results of these controlled research trials have been supported by a
cohort study of 65,713 women, ages 4065 y, involved in the
Longitudinal Nurse's Health study. Participants completed a dietary
questionnaire in 1986 at which time subjects were free from diagnosis
of cardiovascular disease, cancer or diabetes. After 6 y of
follow-up, 915 cases of NIDDM had been documented. It was
determined that cereal fiber intake was inversely associated with risk
of diabetes when comparing extreme quintiles. From this observation,
the authors suggested that grains should be consumed in a minimally
refined form to reduce the incidence of diabetes (Salmeron et al. 1997b
). Similar results for disease risk were also seen in
adult males (Salmeron et al. 1997a
). Thus, dietary fiber
intake appears to decrease the risk for developing Type 2 diabetes.
Clotting factors.
Although difficult to delineate from other dietary factors in a high
fiber diet, it appears that dietary fiber intake may affect blood
coagulation factors. Marchmann and collaborators (Marchmann et al. 1994
) conducted a dietary intervention study of healthy
middle-aged Danish men and women during which they received either
a traditional high fat diet or a diet that was low fat, and high fiber
(LFHF). The LFHF diet significantly decreased plasma factor VII
coagulant activity and increased plasma fibrinolytic activity. This
reduction in plasma factor VII may be physiologically important because
an 8% reduction in factor VIIc might reduce the risk for CHD by
1520% over 5 y.
| NON-FIBER PLANT COMPOUNDS AND CHD RISK |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-linolenic
acid, a plant (n-3) precursor of longer-chain (n-3) "fish
oils," and this subject has been reviewed elsewhere (de Lorgeril et al. 1994Phytochemicals.
Phytochemicals are biologically active plant compounds that are
"semi-essential" but are not classified currently as vitamins or
minerals (Kuhnau 1976
). Howard and Kritchevsky (1997)
reviewed the knowledge relating CHD risk to three
classes of phytochemicals, i.e., plant sterols, flavonoids and plant
sulfur compounds. Each will be briefly reviewed below for their
potential role with respect to risk for CHD.
Plant foods contain a number of sterols that differ from cholesterol by
small differences in their side chains. The most prominent ones are
sitosterol, stigmasterol and campesterol; the total amount of plant
sterols in the Western diet approaches the amount of dietary
cholesterol (Howard and Kritchevsky 1997
). These plant
sterols are poorly absorbed and appear to decrease cholesterol
absorption (Mattson et al. 1982
). By this mechanism,
plant sterol intake may decrease serum cholesterol concentrations by as
much as 10%. A recent clinical study of hypercholesterolemic
individuals suggests that the daily intake of 1.92.6 g of sitosterol
in a margarine preparation over a 1-y period was associated with a
10.2% reduction in serum cholesterol concentrations (Miettinen et al. 1995
). From the amounts of plant sterols required to
significantly decrease serum cholesterol concentrations, it seems
unlikely that the amounts of these sterols consumed by average
individuals would affect serum cholesterol concentrations (Denke
et al. 1994
).
The plant flavonoids are a variety of chemical compounds that are
derivatives of 2-phenyl-1-benzopyran-4-one; they occur naturally in
vegetables, fruits, tea and wine (Hertog et al. 1993
,
Howard and Kritchevsky 1997
). Major sources of
flavonoids in the diet are tea, red wine, onions and apples
(Hertog et al. 1993
). Several epidemiologic studies
indicate that higher flavonoid intakes are associated with lower rates
of CHD (Hertog et al. 1993 and 1995
, Knekt et al. 1996
). These flavonoids appear to decrease risk for CHD by
several different mechanisms. Soy proteins, rich in isoflavones, have
significant hypocholesterolemic effects (Anderson et al. 1995d
). Intakes of soy protein (Anderson et al. 1995d
) or green tea (Simons et al. 1995
),
probably acting through their flavonoids, have a tendency to increase
serum HDL cholesterol concentrations. Catechins, soy isoflavones and
phenolic substances from red wine have important antioxidant properties
and apparently are transported by LDL so that they protect against in
vitro oxidation of LDL (Anderson et al. 1998
,
Frankel et al. 1993
, Simons et al. 1995
).
Soy isoflavones and other flavonoids also appear to decrease platelet
aggregation (Wilcox and Blumenthal 1995
) and blood
clotting, thereby decreasing the tendency to thrombosis
(Gryglewski et al. 1987
). Although soy isoflavones are
not well quantified in humans (Nestel et al. 1997
),
studies in monkeys (Honore et al. 1997
) suggest that
they exert favorable effects on blood vessel dilatation similar to the
effects of estrogens; thus, flavonoids may decrease risk of CHD through
protective effects on blood vessels.
Sulfur-containing plant foods such as garlic also have
hypocholesterolemic effects and decrease the tendency to form arterial
thromboses. The allium family of vegetables, which includes onions,
garlic and leeks, provides a variety of sulfur compounds that have been
used for medicinal purposes for millennia (Howard and Kritchevsky 1997
). Although two recent meta-analyses
(Silagy and Neil 1994
, Warshsky et al. 1993
) report significant hypocholesterolemic effects of garlic
intake, a recent well-controlled clinical trial (Simons et al. 1995
) failed to detect a significant effect. Further
clinical studies are required to demonstrate more clearly the effect of
garlic or garlic powder intake on serum lipoproteins, platelet
aggregation, coagulation time and blood pressure (Howard and Kritchevsky 1997
).
Antioxidants.
The LDL-oxidation hypothesis for atherosclerosis, as outlined
above, supports the potential protective role of antioxidant-rich
foods and supplements. Briefly, considerable experimental and clinical
data suggest that oxidative modification of LDL contributes to the
initiation of the plaque formation in the subendothelial space of blood
vessels (Navab et al. 1996
). Vitamin E, the major
antioxidant transported in the LDL particle, has the potential to
reduce oxidative modification of LDL through its potent
chain-breaking antioxidant action (Dieber-Rotheneder et al. 1992
). Indeed, early epidemiologic and observational studies
(Gey 1991
, Kardinaal et al 1993
,
Regnstom et al. 1996
, Riemersma et al. 1991
) support the hypothesis that a generous intake of vitamin
E is associated with a reduced risk for CHD. Three large epidemiologic
cohort studies (Knekt et al. 1996
, Rimm et al. 1993
, Stampfer et al. 1993
) all reported
significant reductions in risk for CHD events with reductions ranging
from 31 to 65% (Jha et al. 1995
). The recent report of
Kushi et al. (1996)
noted that CHD risk is 62% lower in
women with the greatest vitamin E intake. Many clinical studies
(Abbey et al. 1993
, Dieber-Rotheneder et al. 1992
, Fuller et al. 1996
, Jialal et al. 1995
, Princen et al. 1992
, Reaven et al. 1995
) document the association of vitamin E supplementation
with a significant reduction in the in vitro oxidation of LDL. As
Jha et al. (1995)
summarized, the earlier prospective
clinical trials did not report significant benefits for vitamin E
supplementation. The Cambridge Heart Antioxidant Study (CHAOS)
(Stephens et al. 1996
) was a double-blind
placebo-controlled study that randomized 2002 patients with
angiographically proven CHD. Half of the patients received either 400
or 800 IU vitamin E; the remainder received placebo.
Vitamin E intake was associated with a significant 47% reduction in
CHD events (Stephens et al. 1996
). Because of the
conflicting results of these earlier trials, definitive conclusions
must be delayed until additional trials are completed (Prince et al. 1991
).
ß-Carotene is also an antioxidant vitamin that is transported in LDL
and has a potential to decrease LDL oxidation (Esterbauer et al. 1991
). Epidemiologic studies suggest that there is an inverse
relationship between ß-carotene intake and CHD risk (Gey et al. 1993
, Jha et al. 1995
, Kardinaal et al. 1993
, Morris et al. 1977
). Although
ß-carotene supplementation does not significantly alter in vitro
oxidation of LDL (Gaziano et al. 1995
, Princen et al. 1992
), several clinical trials have examined the effects of
ß-carotene on risk for CHD. Three major randomized trials
(Hennekens et al. 1996
, Omenn et al. 1996
, The Alpha-Tocopherol BC 1994
) reported
no significant alterations in CHD mortality associated with
ß-carotene supplementation. Because of the concerns about increased
risk for lung cancer among smokers receiving ß-carotene (Omenn et al. 1996
, The Alpha-Tocopherol BC 1994
),
enthusiasm for this supplement has waned (Hennekens et al. 1996
).
Vitamin C is also a potent antioxidant vitamin that is water soluble.
Although not transported in the LDL particle, vitamin C protects LDL
from in vitro oxidation (Frei 1991
, Jialal et al. 1990
). Vitamin C has the capacity to preserve vitamin E in the
plasma and also repair oxidative damage inflicted on vitamin E
(Esterbauer and Ramos 1995
). Earlier studies
(Enstrom et al. 1992
, Gey et al. 1993
)
suggested an inverse relationship between vitamin C intake and CHD
risk, whereas large prospective observational studies have not been
consistent (Jha et al. 1995
). Three randomized trials
have also yielded conflicting results (Jha et al. 1995
).
Thus, the independent effects of vitamin C intake on risk for CHD are
unclear.
Although most attention has focused on antioxidants and decreased
oxidation of LDL, various antioxidants have other
vascular-protective effects. Prince et al. (1991)
summarize the following effects of antioxidants that are unrelated to
LDL oxidation: preservation of endothelial-derived nitric oxide
action; inhibition of leukocyte adhesion; reduction of cellular
oxidation damage; and inhibition of plalelet activation and smooth
muscle proliferation.
The available data suggest strongly that vitamin E intake is associated with a protection from CHD. ß-Carotene and vitamin C may also have protective effects. Further clinical trials are required to assess the clinical importance of these observations. Currently, at least eight prospective trials examining the effects of antioxidant vitamin supplementation on cardiovascular disease are in progress. These studies, individually or in aggregate, should have the numerical strength to provide more definitive answers to current questions regarding the relationship of antioxidant vitamin intake and CHD.
| FERMENTATION OF DIETARY FIBER |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Acetate, propionate and butyrate are the principal SCFA produced in the
human colon (Pomare et al. 1985
). Simplistically,
acetate traverses the liver and enters the peripheral circulation
(Bridges et al. 1992
). Propionate is extracted by the
liver and affects lipid metabolism (Bridges et al. 1992
). Butyrate appears to have health-promoting effects
for colonocytes and only a portion of butyrate leaves the colon for
extraction by the liver (Pomare et al. 1985
).
Table 2
outlines SCFA production from different dietary fiber sources and
supplies information on the ratio of the individual SCFA acetate,
propionate and butyrate produced.
|
MacZulak et al. (1993)
used an animal model to study the
effect of diets high in fiber on fecal microorganism output and
microbial fermentation products. In these studies, the male Wistar rats
were divided into groups of five and fed high fiber and fiber-free
diets in varying order for a 3- to 4-wk period. The high fiber diet
contained 40% soy cake, 20% crude potato starch, 19% wheat bran and
5% each of apple pectin and carob gum. The fiber-free diet
contained 24% soy protein and 65% wheat starch. It was determined
that total anaerobe fecal concentration was 70 times higher in the
feces after consumption of the high fiber diet compared with that of
the fiber-free diet. It appears that the high fiber diet provides
substrates necessary for microbial fermentation and growth in the
cecum. In addition, the high fiber diet influenced the proportion of
organic acid products such that the acetate/proptionate/butyrate ratio
was 69:21:10 with consumption of the high fiber diet vs. 92:7:1 with
the fiber-free diet. These results represent an elevation in
propionate and butyrate production when subjects consume a diet rich in
fiber sources.
Sunvold et al. (1995)
studied the in vitro fermentation
characteristics of several fiber sources including cellulose, beet
pulp, citrus pulp and citrus pectin. The fiber substrates were
incubated for 6, 12, 24 and 48 h with human feces. Total SCFA
production was greatest with citrus pectin, followed by citrus pulp,
beet pulp and cellulose. The acetate/propionate/butyrate ratios after
48 h were 55:27:18 for the beet pulp, 60:22:18 for the citrus pulp
and 57:21.5:21.5 for the citrus pectin. These results indicate that the
source of dietary fiber does influence substrate fermentability by gut
microflora in humans. In a similar trial, Wang and collaborators
(Wang and Gibson 1993
) studied the effects of the in
vitro fermentation of inulin and oligofructose by bacteria growing in
the human large intestine. Fermentation products were found from
slurries of mixed human fecal bacteria. The acetate/propionate/butyrate
ratio for inulin was 72:19:8 and for oligofructose was 78:14:8.
| BIFIDOGENIC EFFECTS OF DIETARY FIBER |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In animals models, certain soluble fibers such as guar gum (a galactomannan polymer) significantly increase the bifidobacteria counts in the colon. It is possible that galactose, like fructose, selectively stimulates the growth of certain bifidobacteria species in the colon.
Okubo et al. (1994)
examined the effects of
intake of partially hydrolyzed guar gum (PHGG) on bacterial counts of
feces from volunteer subjects fed control diets and diets containing
PHGG. After a 2-wk control period, nine subjects consumed 7 g of
PHGG in a beverage three times daily (21 g/d). The percentage of
bifidobacteria in the feces increased from 14.7 to 31.7%
after 1 wk and was 24.8% after 2 wk. Two weeks after discontinuing
intake of PHGG, the bifidobacteria count of the fecal
samples returned to pretreatment values. The bifidobacteria
counts were significantly higher during wk 3 and 4 of PHGG ingestion
than values at baseline or after cessation of PHGG intake. Of interest,
lactobacillus counts also increased significantly with PHGG
consumption, but significant changes were not observed in the
concentrations of any other microflora.
| CONCLUSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In addition to its effects on lipoproteins, dietary fiber also has a positive influence on blood pressure, obesity, insulin resistance and clotting factors, which are all independent risk factors for CHD. When evaluating the role of dietary fiber in ASCVD risk, one must also consider the non-fiber components of plant foods, including phytochemicals, antioxidant vitamins and certain (n-3) fatty acids. Available data strongly suggest that vitamin E intake is associated with a protection from CHD, and ß-carotene and vitamin C may also have protective effects.
Like oligosaccharides, soluble fibers are almost completely fermented in the colon to SCFA, methane, carbon dioxide and hydrogen. The SCFA ratios of acetate/propionate/butyrate vary and are influenced by substrate availability to the bacterial flora of the colon. It is also of interest that dietary fiber, like oligofructoses and inulin, has the potential to increase the bifidobacteria counts of the colon. This elevation in bifidobacteria offers health benefits independent of those normally attributed to fiber-rich foods. Inclusion of dietary fiber in the diet offers benefits not only to the heart, but also to overall health.
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
3 Abbreviations used: AHA, American Heart
Association; apo, apolipoprotein; ASCVD, atherosclerotic cardiovascular
disease; BMI, body mass index; CA, cholic acid; CDCA, chenodeoxycholic
acid; CHD, coronary heart disease; DCA, deoxycholic acid; HCFC, high
carbohydrate, high fiber; HMG, ß-hydroxyl-ß-methyl glutarate; IDDM,
insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus; LCLF, low carbohydrate, low
fiber; LFHF, low fat, high fiber; NIDDM, noninsulin-dependent
diabetes mellitus; PHGG, partially hydrolyzed guar gum. ![]()
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1.
Abbey M., Nestel P. J., Baghurst P. A. Antioxidant vitamins and low-density-lipoprotein oxidation. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 1993;58:525-532
2.
Anderson J. W. Dietary fiber and human health. Hortic. Sci. 1990;25:1488-1495
3. Anderson J. W. Dietary fibre, complex carbohydrate and coronary heart disease. Can. J. Cardiol. 1995;11:55G-62G
4. Anderson J. W. Cholesterol-lowering effects of soluble fiber in humans. Kritchevsky D. Bonfield C. eds. Dietary Fiber in Health and Disease 1995:126-145 Eagan Press St. Paul, MN
5. Anderson J. W. Short chain fatty acids and lipid metabolism: human studies. Cummings J. H. Rombeau J. L. Sakata T. eds. Physiological and Clinical Aspects of Short Chain Fatty Acids 1995:509-523 Cambridge University Press New York, NY.
6.
Anderson J. W., Chen W. L. Plant fiber: carbohydrate and lipid metabolism. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 1979;32:346-363
7. Anderson J. W., Deakins D. A., Floore T. L., Smith B. M., Whitis S. E. Dietary fiber and coronary heart disease. Crit. Rev. Food Sci. Nutr. 1990;29:95-147[Medline]
8. Anderson J. W., Diwadkar V. A., Bridges S. R. Intake of different antioxidants have different effects on the oxidation of very-low and low-density lipoproteins from rats. Proc. Soc. Exp. Biol. Med. 1998;218:376-381[Abstract]
9.
Anderson J. W., Johnstone B. M., Cook-Newell M. E. Meta-analysis of effects of soy protein intake on serum lipids in humans. N. Engl. J. Med. 1995;333:276-282
10. Anderson J. W., Johnstone B. M., Cook-Newell M. E. Meta-analysis of the effects of soy protein intake on serum lipids. NEJM 1995;333:276-282
11. Anderson J. W., Jones A. E., Riddell-Mason S. Ten different dietary fibers have significantly different effects on serum and liver lipids of cholesterol-fed rats. J. Nutr. 1994;124:78-83
12. Anderson J. W., Spencer D. O., Riddell-Mason S., Floore T. L., Dillon D. W., Oeltgen P. R. Postprandial serum glucose, insulin, and lipoprotein responses to high- and low-fiber diets. Metabolism 1995;44:848-854[Medline]
13.
Anderson J. W., Zeigler J. A., Deakins D. A., Floore T. L., Dillon D. W., Wood C. L., Oeltgen P. R., Whitley R. J. Metabolic effects of high-carbohydrate, high-fiber diets for insulin-dependent diabetic individuals. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 1991;54:936-943
14. Anderson S. A., Fisher K. D., Talbott J. M. Evaluation of the health aspects of using partially hydrolyzed guar gum as a food ingredient 1993 Life Sciences Research Office, Federation of American Societies for Experimental Biology Bethesda, MD
15. Anthony M. S., Clarkson T. B., Hughes C. L., Jr, Morgan T. M., Burke G. L. Soy isoflavones improve cardiovascular risk factors without affecting the reproductive system of peripubertal rhesus monkeys. J. Nutr. 1996;126:43-50
16.
Appel L. J., Moore T. J., Obarzanek E., Vollmer W. M., Svetkey L. P., Sacks F. M., Bray G. A., Vogt T. M., Cutler J. A., Windhauser M. M., Lin P. H., Karanja N. A clinical trial of the effects of dietary patterns on blood pressure. N. Engl. J. Med. 1997;336:1117-1124
17.
Ascherio A., Rimm E. B., Giovannucci E. L., Colditz G. A., Rosner B., Willett W. C., Sacks F., Stampfer M. J. A prospective study of nutritional factors and hypertension among US men. Circulation 1992;86:1475-1484
18.
Beilin L. J. Vegetarian and other complex diets, fats, fiber, and hypertension. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 1994;59:1130S-1135S
19. Bolton-Smith C., Woodward M., Tunstall-Pedoe H. The Scottish Heart Health Study. Dietary intake by food frequency questionnaire and odds ratio for coronary heart disease risk. II. The antioxidant vitamins and fibre. Eur. J. Clin. Nutr. 1991;46:85-93
20.
Bridges S. R., Anderson J. W., Deakins D. A., Wood C. A. Oat bran increases serum acetate of hypercholesterolemic men. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 1992;56:455-459
21.
Burr M. L., Sweetman P. M. Vegetarianism, dietary fiber, and mortality. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 1982;36:873-877
22. de Lorgeril M., Renaud S., Mamelle N., Salen P., Martin J.-L., Monjaud I., Guidollet J., Touboul P., Delaye J. Mediterranean alpha-linolenic acid-rich diet in secondary prevention of coronary heart disease. Lancet 1994;343:1454-1459[Medline]
23.
Denke M. A. Lack of efficacy of low-dose sitostanol therapy as an adjunct to a cholesterol-lowering diet in men with moderate hypercholesterolemia. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 1994;61:392-396
24. Dieber-Rotheneder M., Puhl H., Waeg G., Striegl G., Esterbauer H. Effect of oral supplementation with D-alpha-tocopherol on the vitamin E content of human low density lipoproteins and resistance to oxidation. J. Lipid Res. 1992;32:1325-1332[Abstract]
25. Ebihara K., Kiriyama S., Manabe M. Cholesterol-lowering activity of various natural pectins and synthetic pectin-derivatives with different physico-chemical properties. Nutr. Rep. Int. 1979;20:519-526
26. Enstrom J. E., Kanim L. E., Klein MA Vitamin C intake and a sample of the United States population. Am. J. Epidemiol. 1992;3:194-202
27. Esterbauer H., Puhl H., Dieber-Rotheneder M., Waeg G., Rabl H. Effect of antioxidants on oxidative modification of LDL. Ann. Med. 1991;23:573-581[Medline]
28. Esterbauer H., Ramos P. Chemistry and pathophysiology of oxidation of LDL. Rev. Physiol. Biochem. Pharmacol. 1995;127:31-64
29. Everson G. T., Daggy B. P., McKinley C., Story J. A. Effects of psyllium hydrophilic mucilloid on LDL-cholesterol and bile acid synthesis in hypercholesterolemic men. J. Lipid Res. 1992;33:1183-1192[Abstract]
30. Ferrannini E., Buzzigoli G., Bonadonna R. Insulin resistance in essential hypertension. N. Engl. J. Med. 1987;317:350-357[Abstract]
31. Frankel E. N., Kanner J., German J. B., Parks E., Kinsella J. E. Inhibition of oxidation of human low-density lipoprotein by phenolic substances in red wine. Lancet 1993;341:454-457[Medline]
32. Frei B. Ascorbic acid protects lipids in human plasma and low-density lipoprotein against oxidative damage. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 1991;54:1113S-1118S[Medline]
33.
Fukagawa N. K., Anderson J. W., Hageman G., Young V. R., Minake R.K.L. High-carbohydrate, high-fiber diets increase peripheral insulin sensitivity in healthy young and old adults. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 1990;52:524-528
34.
Fuller C. J., Chandalia M., Garg A., Grundy S. M., Jialal I. RRR-
-Tocopheryl acetate supplementation at pharmacologic doses decreases low-density-lipoprotein oxidation susceptibility but not protein glycation in patients with diabetes mellitus. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 1996;63:753-759
35. Gaziano J. M., Hatta A., Flynn M., Johnson E. J., Krinsky N. I., Ridker P. M., Hennekens C. H., Frei B. Supplementation with B-carotene in vivo and in vitro does not inhibit low density lipoprotein oxidation. Atherosclerosis 1995;112:187-195[Medline]
36.
Gey K. F. Inverse correlation between plasma vitamin E and mortality from ischemic heart disease in cross-cultural epidemiology. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 1991;53:326S-334S