![]() |
|
|
-Tocopherol Acetate Is a Better Vitamin E Source than all-rac-
-Tocopherol Succinate for Broilers1
Department of Animal Nutrition and Physiology, Danish Institute of Agricultural Sciences, Research Centre Foulum, DK-8830 Tjele, Denmark
2To whom correspondence should be addressed.
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-tocopherol was investigated in a feeding
experiment with broilers. The experiment was initiated with 96 12-d-old
male Cobb broilers and lasted for 4 wk. The two sources of vitamin E
were fed to eight groups of broilers at four different dietary levels
(50, 100, 150 and 200 mg/kg feed, including the naturally occurring
-tocopherol). A total collection of droppings for determination of
apparent tocopherol absorption were performed at two separate time
periods (d 2834 and d 3541). There were no differences among the
eight experimental groups with respect to animal performance or feed
intake. At all dietary levels, the apparent absorption coefficient for
all-rac-
-tocopherol succinate was significantly lower
than that of the acetate ester. The mean (± SD) apparent
absorption coefficient for all-rac-
-tocopherol
succinate was 58.0 ± 5.4 compared with 70.8 ± 5.6 for
all-rac-
-tocopherol acetate. Furthermore, the
apparent absorption coefficients for both esters was significantly
lower in the first collection period (d 2834) than in the second
collection period (d 3541). This difference in the apparent
absorption coefficient between the succinate and the acetate ester was
accompanied by significant differences in
-tocopherol concentrations
in plasma, breast muscle, liver and adipose tissue of the broilers,
which were lower in those fed the succinate ester. Based on a
comparison of plasma and tissue responses, the succinate ester was
utilized only 6976% as efficiently as the acetate ester. In vitro
studies showed a significantly higher capacity of pancreatic carboxyl
ester hydrolase to hydrolyze
-tocopherol acetate compared to
-tocopherol succinate. This difference in intestinal hydrolysis of
the two vitamin E sources may explain the observed differences in
biopotency.
KEY WORDS: bioavailability antioxidant apparent absorption pancreatic carboxyl ester hydrolase broilers
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Because of the role of tocopherols in the protection of biological
membranes against oxidative damage, supplementation of broiler diets
with commercially available vitamin E (
-tocopherol) is obligatory in
most feed formulations (Jakobsen et al. 1995
). The major
source of commercially available vitamin E is synthetic
all-rac-
-tocopherol esterified to acetate or to sodium
succinate to protect the phenolic group against oxidation. The acetate
ester is an oil at room temperature, whereas the succinate ester is a
solid powder; the latter is the most stable at room temperature.
The biological activities of all-rac-
-tocopherol,
all-rac-
-tocopherol acetate and
all-rac-
-tocopherol succinate, determined by the rat
fetal resorption assay, are considered equal on a molar basis
(Pryor 1997
). However, Hidiroglou et al. (1992)
demonstrated in an experiment with sheep a significantly lower
concentration of
-tocopherol in plasma after an oral dose of
D-
-tocopherol succinate compared to an oral dose of D-
-tocopherol
acetate. In a single oral dose experiment with humans, Cheeseman et al. (1995)
demonstrated a significantly higher initial concentration 6 and
7 h after administration of
-tocopherol originating from the
acetate ester compared to the succinate ester.
Prior to absorption in the small intestine both esters require
hydrolysis to the free alcohol in the intestinal lumen by pancreatic
carboxyl ester hydrolase
(CEL)3
(Muller et al. 1976
) at the concurrent presence of bile
salts (Gallo-Torres, 1970
).
In a feeding experiment with broilers, Combs (1978)
compared the
utilization of all-rac-
-tocopherol, the acetate ester
thereof and the water-soluble ester D-
-tocopherol
polyethylene glycol 1000 succinate (TPGS). He found an equal
utilization of all-rac-
-tocopherol and
all-rac-
-tocopherol acetate at dietary levels
~40 mg equivalents of all-rac-
-tocopherol/kg feed .
Above that level, the acetate ester was less efficiently utilized than
the free alcohol. TPGS was very poorly utilized at all experimental
levels. Therefore, Combs (1978)
concluded that the affinity of CEL in
the intestine of broilers is very low for TPGS relative to
all-rac-
-tocopherol acetate. Furthermore, the activity of
this esterase may approach saturation at dietary levels >3540 mg
all-rac-
-tocopherol equivalents/kg feed.
Because of the uncertainty regarding the utilization of different
-tocopherol esters, we compared the applicability of
all-rac-
-tocopherol acetate and
all-rac-
-tocopherol succinate as vitamin E sources in
fat-rich broiler feed fed to fast-growing broilers.
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A total of 96 1-day-old male broiler chickens (Cobb) were obtained from
the production plant of The Danish Institute of Agricultural
Sciences (Tjele, Denmark) and kept in a floor pen, where they
received a starter diet until 12 d of age. The starter diet
included a vitamin mixture providing 42 mg vitamin E as
all-rac-
-tocopherol acetate.
On d 12 the birds were weighed and housed two and two in separate
metabolism cages. Each pair of birds was randomly assigned to one of
eight experimental groups, which were repeated in six blocks. The
experiment was conducted over a period of 4 wk, and the chickens had
free access to feed and water. Body weight and feed intake were
registered weekly. The type of
-tocopherol provided was either
all-rac-
-tocopherol succinate or
all-rac-
-tocopherol acetate. The
-tocopherol
esters were supplied in a silica based matrix by Leo Pharmaceutical
Products, DK-2750 Ballerup, Denmark.
The composition of the starter diet as well as of the experimental
diets is shown in Table 1
. Diets contained, in addition to their natural content, increasing
amounts of
-tocopherol (20, 60, 100 and 140 mg/kg feed) added either
as
-tocopherol succinate (group S50, S100, S150 and S200) or as
-tocopherol acetate (group A50, A100, A150 and A200).
|
Determination of tocopherols.
The concentrations of tocopherols were analyzed by HPLC after
saponification and extraction into heptane as previously described
(Jensen et al. 1998
). Briefly, 1 g of a finely
ground feed sample or 2 g of homogenized droppings were suspended
in a mixture of 24.0 mL ethanol (960 mL/L), 9.0 mL methanol, 10.0 mL
ascorbic acid in water (200 g/L) and 7.0 mL KOH-water (500 g/L).
The mixture was saponified for 30 min at 80°C (boiling) in the dark
and cooled in cold water. Exactly 2 mL of the saponified mixture were
diluted with 0.50 mL water, after which tocopherols were quantitatively
extracted with two portions of 5.0 mL heptane. Determination of
tocopherols in blood plasma and tissues was performed by mixing 0.500
mL plasma, 150 mg liver or 400 mg muscle with 2.00 mL ethanol, 0.50 mL
methanol, 1.00 mL ascorbic acid solution, 0.30 mL KOH-water (500
g/L) and water to a final volume of 5.50 mL. After saponification (20
min at 70°C) and cooling, tocopherols were quantitatively extracted
with two portions of 5 mL heptane. Adipose tissue (100 mg) was
dissolved in 10 mL heptane and heated for 2 h in the dark at
70°C before injection into the HPLC.
The HPLC column used for the determination of tocopherols was a
4.0 x 125 mm Perkin Elmer HS-5-Silica column (Perkin-Elmer, Gmbh,
D-7770 Überlingen, Germany), and heptane modified with 2-propanol
(3.0 mL/L) and degassed with helium constituted the mobile phase.
Fluorescence detection was performed with an excitation wavelength of
290 nm and an emission wavelength of 327 nm. Identification and
quantification of the tocopherols were obtained by comparison of
retention time as well as peak areas with external standards. The
following extinction coefficients in ethanol were used:
-tocopherol,
E1cm1% = 71.0 at 294 nm and
-tocopherol,
E1cm1% = 92.8 at 298 nm (Merck D-6100 Darmstadt,
Germany).
Apparent absorption experiment.
At two separate time periods (d 2834 and d 3541), a total
collection of droppings was conducted from three of the blocks. The
coefficient for the apparent absorption of
-tocopherol was
calculated as
![]() |
Retention of
-tocopherol in blood plasma and tissues.
At the end of experiment all birds were slaughtered. Blood plasma and samples of liver, breast muscle (Musculus pectoralis superficialis) and abdominal fat were collected and stored at -80°C until analysis. The intestines of six broilers from groups S150 and A150 were removed. The small intestine was divided into jejunum and ileum, corresponding to segments cranial and caudal to the Meckels diverticulum. The content was emptied and frozen at -20°C for later analysis of digestive enzymes and tocopherol content.
Enzyme activities.
Digesta were diluted in three volumes of an isotonic saline (9
g/L) and homogenized (20,000 rpm, 2 min, 0°C; Ultra Turrax,
IKA-Labortechnik, Staufen, Germany). The samples were centrifuged
(12,800 x g, 4°C, 20 min), the supernatant was
collected for analysis and the pellet was dissolved in the same volume
of an isotonic saline solution and centrifugation was repeated. The
activities of trypsin, chymotrypsin, amylase, lipase and carboxylester
hydrolase were determined in both supernatants, according to procedures
described previously (Jensen et al. 1997
). Benzoyl DL
arginine p-nitroanilide (Sigma B 4875, Sigma, St. Louis, MS) and
succinyl ala-ala-pro-phe p-nitroanilide (Sigma, S 7388) were
used as substrates for the determination of trypsin and chymotrypsin
activity, respectively. Amylase activity was measured using the
Phadebas® amylase reagent (Pharmacia Diagnostics, Uppsala,
Sweden). The activity of lipase was determined by a titremetric method,
in which the hydrolysis of tributyrin by lipase in the presence of bile
salts was followed. Carboxylester hydrolase activity was determined
using p-nitrophenylacetate (Sigma N 8130) as a substrate.
One unit of enzyme activity was defined as the hydrolysis of 1 µmol of substrate in 1 min. The results of enzyme activities per gram digesta are given as the sum of the mean values from both supernatants.
In vitro hydrolysis of
-tocopherol esters by pancreatic CEL.
Pancreatic juice was obtained from pigs that were surgically fitted
with a catheter in the pancreatic duct for continuous collection of
pure pancreatic juice (Jensen et al. 1997
). The
pancreatic juice was diluted to an CEL activity of 100 U/L with
isotonic saline. The in vitro hydrolysis of
-tocopherol
succinate and
-tocopherol acetate was performed in a reagent
solution containing 5 mmol/L sodium acetate, 6 mmol/L sodium cholate
and 0.3 mol/L Tris/HCl buffer, pH 7.4. The amounts of
-tocopherol succinate and
-tocopherol acetate varied in
the range of 0.526 µmol/L. To this solution 0.2 mL diluted
pancreatic juice was added, and the final volume was adjusted to 2.0
mL. The enzymatic hydrolysis was allowed to take place for 20 min at
37°C, while the samples were frequently shaken. The reaction was
stopped by adding 1.5 mL ethanol and
-tocopherol was
extracted with 5 mL heptane before analysis by HPLC.
Statistical analysis.
Values in the text are means ± SD; n
= 6, for apparent absorption and enzyme activities experiment;
n = 12, for plasma and tissue samples. Statistical
analysis of the observed results was performed by a three-way ANOVA
using the General Linear Models procedure of SAS®
(SAS institute 1988
):
![]() |
Where Yijk is the dependent variable, µ
is the overall mean,
i is the systemic effect
of treatment (
-tocopherol acetate or succinate), ß is the effect
of
-tocopherol concentration in the feed,
(
ß)ij is the interaction between type and
concentration of tocopherols,
k is the effect
of block, and
ijk is the random error. In
cases in which the overall effect was significant (P < 0.05), means were compared pair-wise by Fisher's least significant
difference procedure.
The results obtained from the two intestinal segments were
analyzed by a paired t-test. The results determined in the in vitro
hydrolysis experiment with pancreatic CEL was analyzed by linear
regression of the substrate concentration ([s],
µmol/L
-tocopherol ester) against the substrate concentration
divided with the amount of
-tocopherol liberated (nmol/h) (Hanes
plot). According to the Michaelis-Menten equation [V = Vmax x [s]/(KM +
[s])] a Hanes plot is a straight line. KM
(µmol/L substrate) was calculated as the intercept divided with
the slope, and Vmax (nmol/h of reaction product liberated)
was calculated as the reciprocal slope.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Because of the presence of natural RRR-
-tocopherol in the feed, all
experimental diets had a higher
-tocopherol concentration than
expected, but the four corresponding succinate and acetate diets had
the same analyzed
-tocopherol concentrations (Table 1)
. In addition,
each diet contained 66 mg
-tocopherol/kg and 19 mg
-tocopherol/kg
of natural origin.
Animal performance.
The chickens performed well throughout the experiment. However, one chicken from group A200 died 2 d before slaughter (40 d old). The post mortem findings were ascites, enlargement of the heart and accumulation of fluid in the pericardium.
No significant difference in growth performance and feed conversion efficiency were found among the experimental groups. The mean body weight at 42 d of age was 2452 ± 67g. The feed conversion during the 4 wk experiment was 0.62 ± 0.02 g gain/g feed consumed.
Apparent absorption of tocopherols.
-Tocopherol originating from all-rac-
-tocopherol succinate had,
at all inclusion levels, a significantly lower apparent absorption
coefficient than
-tocopherol from all-rac-
-tocopherol acetate
(Table 2
) (P < 0.001). Thus the overall mean apparent
absorption coefficient for
-tocopherol from the succinate groups was
58.0 compared to 70.8 for the groups fed the acetate ester of
all-rac-
-tocopherol. The apparent absorption coefficients were not
influenced by the diet
-tocopherol concentration (P
> 0.8).
|
-tocopherol following
intake of both
-tocopherol esters were significantly lower in the
first period, 55.6 and 67.4 for the succinate and the acetate ester,
respectively, compared to the second period, where the apparent
absorption coefficients were 60.3 and 74.1 respectively, (P
< 0.001). The overall mean apparent absorption coefficients for
-tocopherol were 85.1 for the succinate groups and 87.1 for the
acetate groups (P = 0.029). As with
-tocopherol, the
apparent absorption coefficients for
-tocopherol were unaffected by
diet concentration of
-tocopherol (P > 0.7). Digestive enzymes and tocopherols in the small intestine.
None of the digestive enzyme activities were affected by the dietary
treatment; therefore, the results from the broilers analyzed were
pooled. However, the enzyme activities in jejunum contents were
significantly lower than in ileal contents. (Table 3
). The activities of the proteolytic enzymes in the ileum contents
were only 50% of the activities in the jejunum contents, and the
activity of pancreatic CEL and lipase was only 10% of the activities
in the jejunum contents. The activity of amylase in the ileum contents
was only 27% of the activity in the jejunum content.
|
-tocopherol concentration did not
differ between jejunum and ileal contents (P = 0.90),
whereas the broilers fed the S150 diet showed a significantly higher
concentration of
-tocopherol in the ileal contents, compared to the
jejunum contents (P = 0.043) (Table 3)
In vitro hydrolysis of
-tocopherol esters by pancreatic
CEL.
The in vitro hydrolysis experiment with
-tocopherol succinate and
-tocopherol acetate was performed with
-tocopherol ester
concentrations comparable to the expected digesta concentrations. The
capacity of porcine pancreatic CEL to hydrolyze
-tocopherol
succinate was only 1.5% of the corresponding capacity to hydrolyze
-tocopherol acetate (Fig. 1
).
|
-tocopherol in plasma and tissue.
At all supplementation levels the concentration of
-tocopherol was
lower in plasma and tissues from chickens supplemented with
all-rac-
-tocopherol succinate (P = 0.001,
Table 4
). These differences were small at the low supplementation level
(S50 and A50), but were more pronounced at higher dietary
concentrations of all-rac-
-tocopherol, as indicated by
significant dose effects (P < 0.001).
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-tocopherol esters. The observed ratio between the
utilization of the acetate and succinate ester of
all-rac-
-tocopherol was comparable with that in humans
(Cheeseman et al. (1995
The lower apparent absorption coefficient and the lower plasma
and tissue
-tocopherol response of broilers to the succinate ester,
compared to the acetate ester observed in vivo, is likely caused by a
lower affinity of the less hydrophobic
all-rac-
-tocopherol succinate to intestinal hydrolysis by
pancreatic CEL as shown in the in vitro experiment. The inhibiting
effect of the succinate ester on the apparent absorption of
-tocopherol could be due to a disturbance of the surfaces of the
emulsified lipid particles or the mixed bile salt, phospholipid,
cholesterol, free fatty acid and monoglyceride-containing micelles
by the greater hydrophility of all-rac-
-tocopherol
succinate. The tocopherols, and perhaps also other fat-soluble
compounds, may be less available for absorption because of the physical
and chemical conditions of these emulsified lipid particles and mixed
micelles are of great importance both for enzymatic hydrolysis of lipid
molecules and their subsequent absorption (Ullrey 1972
).
Pancreatic CEL and lipase showed the most pronounced decrease from
jejunum to ileum in activity of the analyzed digestive enzymes. Thus,
it is evident that the time available for enzymatic hydrolysis by this
esterase may be limiting because the transit time of digesta in the
small intestine is very short (van der Klis and Van Voorst, 1993
).
The concentration of
-tocopherol in blood plasma, liver and
abdominal fat indicated that, as a vitamin E source, the succinate
ester was 6971% as available as the acetate ester. In the breast
muscle this relative efficiency was 76%, whereas the apparent
absorption experiment showed a relative efficiency of 82%. The fact
that the apparent absorption experiment showed a higher utilization of
the succinate ester relative to the acetate ester than did the plasma
and tissue responses may be due to a higher intestinal degradation of
the succinate ester than of the acetate ester, whereby the apparent
absorption coefficients are overestimated.
At the lowest dietary inclusion level, the difference in
utilization was more or less masked by the concurrent occurrence of
natural RRR-
-tocopherol from the basal feed.
The observed increase in apparent absorption of tocopherols from the
first to the second period is most likely an age effect, as shown in
earlier experiments (Engberg et al. 1996
, Liu et al. 1995
). These experiments also revealed that oxidized lipids
in the diet (Engberg et al. 1996
) as well as dietary
fibers (Liu et al. 1995
) had negative influences on the
apparent absorption of tocopherols.
In conclusion, the present experiment showed significantly higher
utilization of all-rac-
-tocopherol acetate than
all-rac-
-tocopherol succinate in broilers because of a
low affinity of pancreatic CEL towards hydrolysis of the succinate
ester in combination with a low activity of pancreatic CEL and a short
transit time of digesta in the small intestine.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| FOOTNOTES |
|---|
3 Abbreviations used: A50, 50 mg
-tocopherol
acetate; A100, 100 mg
-tocopherol acetate; A150, 150 mg
-tocopherol acetate; A200, 200 mg
-tocopherol acetate; CEL,
pancreatic carboxyl ester hydrolase (EC 3.1.1.1); S50, 50 mg
-tocopherol succinate; S100, 100 mg
-tocopherol succinate; S150,
150 mg
-tocopherol succinate; S200, 200 mg
-tocopherol succinate;
TPGS, D-
-tocopherol polyethylene glycol 1000 succinate. ![]()
Manuscript received December 2, 1998. Initial review completed December 30, 1998. Revision accepted March 25, 1999.
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
1.
Cheeseman K. H., Holley A. E., Kelly F. J., Wasil M., Hughes L., Burton G. Biokinetics in humans of RRR-
-tocopherol: The free phenol, acetate ester and succinate ester forms of vitamin E. Free Rad. Biol. Med. 1995;19:591-598[Medline]
2. Combs G. F. Jr Studies on the utilization of vitamin E alcohol and esters by the chick. Poult. Sci. 1978;57:223-229[Medline]
3. Engberg R. M., Lauridsen C., Jensen S. K., Jakobsen K. Inclusion of oxidized vegetable oil in broiler diets. 1. The influence on nutrient digestibility and on the antioxidative status of broilers in vivo. Poult. Sci. 1996;75:1003-1011[Medline]
4. Gallo-Torres H. E. Obligatory role of bile for the intestinal absorption of vitamin E. Lipids 1970;5:379-384[Medline]
5. Harwitt M. K. The promotion of vitamin E. J. Nutr. 1986;116:1371-1377
6. Hidiroglou N., McDowell L. R., Papas A. M., Antapli M., Wilkinson N. S. Bioavailability of vitamin E compounds in Lambs. J. Anim. Sci. 1992;70:2556-2561[Abstract]
7.
Jakobsen K., Engberg R. M., Andersen J. O., Jensen S. K., Sørensen P., Henckel P., Bertelsen G., Skibsted L. H., Jensen C. Supplementation of Broiler diets all-race-
- or a mixture of natural source RRR-
-,
-,
- Tocopheryl Acetate: 1. Effect on Vitamin E Status of Broilers in vivo and at Slaughter. Poult. Sci. 1995;74:1984-1994[Medline]
8. Jensen M. S., Gabert V. M., Jørgensen H., Engberg R. M. Collection of pancreatic juice from growing pigs. A comparative study of the pouch and the catheter method. Int. J. Pancreatol. 1997;21:173-184[Medline]
9. Jensen S. K., Jensen C., Jakobsen K., Engberg R. M., Andersen J. O., Lauridsen C., Sørensen P., Henckel P., Skibsted L. H., Bertelsen G. Supplementation of broiler diets with retinol acetate, ß-carotene or canthaxanthin: Effect on vitamin and oxidative status of broilers in vivo and meat stability. Acta Agric. Scand. Sect. A Anim. Sci. 1998;48:28-37
10. Liu Y. G., Jensen S. K., Eggum B. O. The influence of seed size on digestibility and growth performance of broiler chickens fed full-fat rapeseed. J. Sci. Food Agric. 1995;67:135-140
11. Muller D.P.R., Manning J. A., Mathias P. M., Harries J. T. Int. J. Vit. Nutr. Res. 1976;46:207-210
12. Pryor, W. A. (1997) Vitamin E and carotenoid Abstracts 1996. VERIS. La Granye, IL.
13. SAS Institute SAS User's Guide: Statistics 1988 SAS Institute Inc Cary, NC.
14. Ullrey D. E. Biological availability of fat-soluble vitamins: Vitamin A and carotene. J. Anim. Sci. 1972;35:648-657
15. Van der Klis J. D., Van Voorst A. The effect of carboxy methyl cellulose (a soluble polysaccharide) on the rate of marker excretion from the gastrointestinal tract of broilers. Poult. Sci. 1993;72:503-512
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
C. Villaverde, M. D. Baucells, E. G. Manzanilla, and A. C. Barroeta High Levels of Dietary Unsaturated Fat Decrease {alpha}-Tocopherol Content of Whole Body, Liver, and Plasma of Chickens Without Variations in Intestinal Apparent Absorption Poult. Sci., March 1, 2008; 87(3): 497 - 505. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. R. Bjornvad, M. Schmidt, Y. M. Petersen, S. K. Jensen, H. Offenberg, J. Elnif, and P. T. Sangild Preterm birth makes the immature intestine sensitive to feeding-induced intestinal atrophy Am J Physiol Regulatory Integrative Comp Physiol, October 1, 2005; 289(4): R1212 - R1222. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. A. Lauver, S. F. Lockwood, and B. R. Lucchesi Disodium Disuccinate Astaxanthin (Cardax) Attenuates Complement Activation and Reduces Myocardial Injury following Ischemia/Reperfusion J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther., August 1, 2005; 314(2): 686 - 692. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. Lauridsen and S. K. Jensen Influence of supplementation of all-rac-{alpha}-tocopheryl acetate preweaning and vitamin C postweaning on {alpha}-tocopherol and immune responses of piglets J Anim Sci, June 1, 2005; 83(6): 1274 - 1286. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Knarreborg, C. Lauridsen, R. M. Engberg, and S. K. Jensen Dietary Antibiotic Growth Promoters Enhance the Bioavailability of {alpha}-Tocopheryl Acetate in Broilers by Altering Lipid Absorption J. Nutr., June 1, 2004; 134(6): 1487 - 1492. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||