![]() |
|
|
The Journal of Nutrition Vol. 129 No. 1 January 1999,
pp. 132-138
,
, and
* Department of Animal and Dairy Science, The University of Georgia, Athens, GA 30602,
Agricultural Research Station, Fort Valley State University, Fort Valley, GA, 31030, ** Department of Biological Agricultural Engineering, The University of Georgia, Athens, GA, USA 30602 and
Department of Biology, Fort Valley State University, Fort Valley, GA, USA 31030.
| |
ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Two experiments using 42 crossbred neonatal pigs to compare the effects of caprine and bovine milk on growth, apparent nutrient digestibility and body composition were conducted. At age 72 h, pigs were removed from their dams and randomly divided into two groups, housed separately in stainless steel metabolism cages and were fed a predetermined amount (300 mL/kg body weight) of pasteurized, nonfortified whole, caprine or bovine milk. Body composition was determined using dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA). In Experiment 1, 22 intact male pigs were used for a 31-d experimental period. There was no significant (P > 0.05) dietary effect on growth, apparent nutrient digestibility or body composition. Significant differences (P < 0.05), however, were observed in plasma of C 8:0, C 10:0 and C 12:0 concentrations. In Experiment 2, 20 pigs (10 intact males and 10 females) were used in a 2 × 2 factorial experiment for 52 d. Pigs fed caprine milk had higher (P < 0.05) plasma concentrations of C10:0 and C12:0 as well as Na, Mg and Zn than those fed bovine milk. At Day 52, pigs fed caprine milk had less body fat (P < 0.001) and higher (P < 0.06) bone mineral density than those fed bovine milk. Drymatter, N and total mineral intake of male pigs was higher (P < 0.05) than female pigs. Also, male pigs had higher (P < 0.05) plasma concentrations of C12:0 than females. This study demonstrates that the type of milk consumed can influence plasma concentrations of fatty acids, minerals and body composition in pigs.
KEY WORDS: pigs · caprine and bovine milk · growth · body composition
Studies have reported that 7-8% of human infants less than 3 mo of age are intolerant of bovine milk (Bock 1987 Information on the nutritive value of caprine milk for human infants, although sparse, dates back to 1925. There is disagreement among the researchers regarding the effectiveness of caprine milk. For example, studies utilizing rats suggest negative results (Lee et al. 1962 There is limited scientific evidence available on the importance of whole, nonfortified caprine milk in human nutrition. In addition, little is know about the effect of caprine milk on body composition. In view of the importance of milk in providing minerals and vitamins to developing infants, the present study was designed to compare growth performance, nutrient availability and body composition of neonatal pigs fed whole, nonfortified, pasturized caprine and bovine milk. The neonatal pig is being used increasingly as a model for the human infant in studies of nutrient digestibility and body composition (Borum 1993 Experiment 1.
The first experiment was designed to determine the effect of type of milk on growth performance, apparent nutrient digestibility and body composition of infant pigs (0-4 wk of age). Twenty-two intact male crossbred pigs (Yorkshire × Hampshire × Duroc) from 16 litters (average initial body weight 2.1 kg; age 72 h) were used for a 31-d experimental period. All pigs received colostrum from their dams and were injected intramuscularly with 2 mL of iron dextran, containing 100 g Fe/L. Pigs were housed in individual, stainless steel metabolism cages (58.8 × 60 × 62.5 cm; Lab products, Maywood, NJ) with slatted floors that were designed to separate urine and feces. The cages were in an environmentally controlled room with temperature maintained at ~28°C; relative humidity ranged from 35 to 45%, and artificial light was provided continuously. All pigs were vaccinated with Mycoplasma Hyopneumoniae Bacterin (Solvay Animal Health, Mendota Heights, MN) at Days 14 and 28.
Experiment 2.
The second experiment was designed to determine the effect of type of milk and sex on growth performance, apparent nutrient digestibility and body composition of infant (0-4 wk of age) and weanling (4-8 wk of age) pigs. Twenty pigs, 10 intact males and 10 females, (average initial body weight 2.3 kg; age 72 h) were used for a 52-d experimental period. Similar procedures as those described in Experiment 1 were used for animals and housing in Experiment 2. All animal care and experimental protocols were approved by The University of Georgia's Animal Care and Use Committee.
Diets.
All pigs were weighed and randomly allocated to receive either fresh, pasteurized, nonfortified, whole caprine or bovine milk. The nutrient composition of the milks are presented in Table 1. Caprine milk was obtained from Fort Valley State University Caprine Research Center, Fort Valley, GA. Bovine milk was obtained from The University of Georgia Dairy Research Farm, Athens, GA. Caprine and bovine milk were provided as one batch and frozen (
Robotic feeding system.
The robotic-based feeding system is a Foxy 200TM programmable fraction collector connected to a peristaltic pump and valve controller (ISCO, Lincoln, NE). A complete description, programming, and accuracy and precision for the feeding system is described in detail by Firotto et al. (1993) Feeding trial.
In each experiment for the first 24 h, the pigs were trained to drink milk from stainless steel food pans by hand-feeding them every 2 h ( 0800, 1000, 1200, 1400, 1600, 1800, 2000, and 2200 h) with no feeding between 2200 and 0800 the next morning. The robotic feeding system was used to feed the pigs beginning on Day 2. Pigs received their respective diets at a set level of 300 mL/kg body weight per day. The total daily allowance of milk was delivered over 22 feedings at 60 min intervals, and the remaining 2 h (0800-1000) were used to sanitize the feeding system. The first 7 d were used as an adjustment period to allow the pigs to adapt to diets and metabolism cages. Subsequently, the pigs were fed for a 31-d and 52-d experimental period in Experiment 1 and 2, respectively. Pigs were weighed every-other-day. The feeding system was adjusted according to the pig's individual weight to ensure that each pig received its desired individual weight-adjusted volume of milk. The peristaltic pump's output was varied to reflect the increasing volume of milk required based on the weight gain of the pigs.
Body composition.
Body composition was determined using dual energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA; QDR-1500/W, Hologic Inc., Walthman, MA). Individual scans were analyzed by using the Adult Whole Body Software (Version 7.01, Hologic Inc., Walthman, MA). The software used to calculate these estimates assumed that the lean body mass of the pig was 73.2% water, which is comparable to expected water content of body mass of pigs. The DXA scans were performed according to the procedures of Brunton et al. (1993) Sample collection
Plasma.
Blood (8 mL) was taken from each pig by jugular puncture and collected in heparinized tubes at 72 h of age in Experiments 1 and 2. On Days 7, 14, 21, 28, 35 and 42, blood was taken from each pig 1 h after a meal. Blood samples were taken between 0800 and 0900 h while the robotic feeding system was being sanitized. Blood was centrifuged at 2,500 × g for 20 min and the plasma was harvested and frozen ( Apparent nutrient digestibility.
Duplicate samples of caprine and bovine milk were collected before feeding and frozen ( Sample analysis
Plasma mineral concentration.
Duplicate plasma samples were analyzed for concentrations of Na, K, Zn, Mg and Fe (AOAC, 1990) using a flame atomic absorbance spectrophotometer (Scan 1, Model 150, Thermo Jarrell Ash Corporation, Franklin, MA). Comparison with the standard curve was used to determine the amount of each mineral present in each sample. Inorganic P concentration was determined with the method described by Sigma Chemical (1991).
Apparent nutrient digestibility.
Fecal samples were thawed, thoroughly mixed, and a 20% subsample was taken and dried at 55°C for 48 h, air-equilibrated for 24 h and ground in a Wiley Mill (Arthur A. Thomas, Philadelphia, PA) through a 1-mm screen. Milk was also thawed and mixed. One g of milk and 1 g feces were weighed out, dried at 100°C and analyzed for dry matter and ether extract (AOAC 1990). Duplicate samples of milk, feces and urine were analyzed for N and total minerals (AOAC, 1990). Gross energy was determined by adiabatic bomb calorimetry (Parr Instrument Co., Moline, IL). And Zn, Mg, Na and K content (AOAC, 1990) was determined by using a flame atomic absorbance spectrophotometer (Scan 1, Model 150, Thermo Jarrell Ash Corporation, Franklin, MA) following a nitric acid-perchloric acid wet ash. Comparison with the standard curve was used to determine the amount of each mineral present in each sample. Inorganic P concentration was determined with the method described by Sigma Chemical (1991).
Milk and plasma fatty acids.
Duplicate plasma and milk samples were analyzed for fatty acids after lipid extraction (Erickson and Dunkley 1964 Statistical Analysis.
In Experiments 1 and 2, data were analyzed as a completely randomized design using the general linear model procedures of SAS (1990) with the individual pig serving as the experimental unit. Results are reported as least-squares means ± pooled SEM. In Experiment 2, dietary treatments were arranged in a 2 × 2 factorial of caprine or bovine milk and male or female. Data from the factorial arrangement of treatments were analyzed as a randomized design. The model included diet and sex and the interaction between diet and sex. Individual pigs served as the experimental unit. Significant level was set as P < 0.05, unless indicated otherwise.
Experiment 1.
There were no significant differences in final body weights of pigs fed caprine and bovine milk (6.5 ± 0.7 vs. 6.6 ± 0.8 kg). Both groups of pigs gained at a rate of 140 g daily, resulting in over a 200 % increase in body weight during the first month of life. Also, there were no significant differences in feed intake (27.3 ± 3.8 vs. 28.9 ± 2.6 kg), gain/feed ratio (0.17 ± 0.1 vs. 0.16 ± 0.4 kg/kg), apparent digestibility of dry matter (99.6 ± 0.7 vs. 99.7 ± 0.2%), total minerals (92.4 ± 0.2 vs 91.2 ± 0.3%), energy retention (94.3 ± 1.3 vs. 94.6 ± 0.1%), or N retention (57.5 ± 2.5 vs. 53.0 ± 3.7%). No significant differences due to milk type were observed in body composition in regard to fat (3.9 ± 0.6 vs 3.5 ± 0.3 g/100 g) fat mass (150.5 ± 29.2 vs 138.3 ± 23.9 g) lean mass (3814.6 ± 124 vs 3803.4 ± 129 g), bone mineral content (45.2 ± 2.2 vs 46.6 ± 2.7 g) and bone mineral density (0.51 ± 0.2 vs 0.5 ± 0.1 g/cm2) in pigs fed caprine milk and bovine milk, respectively.
Experiment 2.
There was no significant diet X sex interaction observed for body weight or feed efficiency. Final body weight at Day 49 tended to be lower (P < 0.08) in pigs fed caprine milk compared to those fed bovine milk (Table 2). Both groups of pigs more than tripled their body weight with an average daily growth rate of 137 and 162 g for pigs fed caprine and bovine milk, respectively. The type of milk or sex, however, did not affect feed intake or the gain/feed ratio. Significant diet X sex interaction was not observed for intake or digestibility of nutrients at Days 28 and 42. The intake of dry matter, total minerals, N and energy (Table 3) were unaffected by the type of milk. Also, the type of milk did not affect the digestibility of dry matter and ash or the retention of energy and N at Days 28 or 42. There was a significant sex effect at Days 28 and 42 (Table 3). Dry matter intake of male pigs was higher (P < 0.05) than those of female pigs at Days 28 and 42. Also, at Day 42, N and energy intake were higher (P < 0.05) in male pigs than in female pigs. There was no significant sex effect on digestibility of dry matter and total minerals or the retention of energy and N on Days 28 or 42.
The nutrient composition of caprine and bovine milk reported in this study is in agreement with what has been reported in previous studies by Haeinlein and Caccesse (1984) and Juarez and Ramos (1986). Further, according to Edelsten (1988)
![]()
INTRODUCTION
Abstract
Introduction
Methods
Results
Discussion
References
, Gerrard et al. 1973
, Host et al. 1988
). Identifying a milk substitute for human infants who are intolerant of bovine and or soy milk is essential when human milk is unavailable. Because of the popular belief that it elicits fewer allergic symptoms, often associated with eczema, asthma, digestive disorders and neurotic indigestion, caprine milk may be fed to infants (Babayan 1981
). Research investigations comparing the gross composition of caprine and bovine milk show similarities as well as differences in proteins, lipids, enzymes and minerals (Jennes 1980, Juarez 1986). For example, it was reported that fat globules in caprine milk are smaller than those in bovine milk (Le Mens 1985
, Morand-Fehr and Flamant 1983
). Caprine milk fat has ~35% short- and medium-chain fatty acids compared to 17% for bovine milk fat (Haenlein 1992
).
, Shurpalekar et al. 1964
), whereas studies on humans report both positive (Mack 1953
) and negative results (Daniels and Sterns 1925). Most of these studies did not adjust for the effects of the subject's age, sex or weight and in many instances sample size was not adequate. Results from more recent studies with malnourished children (Razafindrakoto et al. 1994
) and with pigs (Fevrier et al. 1993) revealed no significant differences in growth rate and nutrient digestibility when caprine milk was compared to bovine milk.
, Moughan et al. 1990, Shulman, 1993
).
![]()
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Abstract
Introduction
Methods
Results
Discussion
References
20°C) separately in 5 L containers. Each container of milk was thawed in a cold water bath before use.
View this table:
Table 1.
Comparative nutrient composition of caprine and bovine milk
. Robotic action was performed by the fraction collector and dispensed caprine or bovine milk via polypropylene collection funnels to each pig. The milk was stored in refrigerated acrylic reservoirs (Jet Spray Corporation, Boston, MA) and maintained at 4 ± 1°C. The refrigerated acrylic reservoirs were modified to stir the milk at predetermined intervals (10 times per hour), utilizing output signals from the fraction collector to relay switches on the valve controller. In Experiment 1, the milk was pumped from the reservoirs through a heating system and warmed to 35 ± 2°C before being dispensed to the pigs. The heating system consisted of electric heat elements spiraled around a coil of glass tubing and was controlled by an electronic voltage regulator with a visible intensity indicator for continuous monitoring. However, it was noted that the heating element caused the milk to coagulate after 8 h in the glass tubing. Subsequently, the glass tubing was monitored and flushed with distilled water at 8 h intervals to remove any coagulated milk. For Experiment 2, the heating element was not used and the milk was dispensed to the pigs at 4 ± 1°C.
. The technique is based on the relative tissue absorbance of X-radiation at two energy levels and is very stable (Lang et al. 1991, Sartoris and Resnick 1990). The DXA system estimates bone mineral content (BMC) and bone mineral density (BMD). This estimate is made by comparing the energy levels passed through the pig with the energy levels passed through calibrated samples of bone, soft tissue and air. Quality control for DXA measures was verified by scanning a Hologic calibration phantom of known mineral content before testing (Kirchner et al. 1995). Using the tissue calibration bar, energy levels were determined for equivalent lean and fat tissues. With this calibration, the fat mass, lean mass and percent fat were estimated.
20°C) for subsequent analysis.
20°C) until analyzed. For each experiment, 5-d energy and nitrogen balance trials were conducted (Day 23 to 28 in Experiment 1, and Day 23 to 28 and 37 to 42 in Experiment 2). Total feces was collected twice daily, weighed, and frozen (
20°C). Total urine was collected twice daily in 1-L vessels containing 10 mL of 6 mol HCl/L. A 10% aliquot of the total urine volume was taken and frozen (
20°C) until analyzed.
) and methylation (Mason and Waller 1964
). Fatty acid methyl esters were separated and quantified using a gas chromatograph (Model 5890A equipped with autosampler, flame-ionization dector, and Model 339A integrator; Hewlett Packard, Avondale, PA) fitted with a narrow-base capillary column (Megabore DB225, J&W Scientific, Folsom, CA).
![]()
RESULTS
Abstract
Introduction
Methods
Results
Discussion
References
View this table:
Table 2.
Growth performance and feeding efficiency of male and female pigs fed caprine bovine milk (Experiment 2)1
View this table:
Table 3.
Apparent nutrient and energy availability at days 28 and 42 in male and female pigs fed caprine or bovine milk (Experiment 2)1
View this table:
Table 4.
Concentrations of plasma fatty acids at days 28 and 42 in male and female pigs fed caprine or bovine milk (Experiment 2)1
View this table:
Table 5.
Plasma Na, Mg, K, P, Zn and Fe concentrations in male and female pigs fed caprine or bovine milk (Experiment 2)1
View this table:
Table 6.
Growth and body composition in male and female pigs fed caprine or bovine milk at d 52 (Experiments 2)1,2
![]()
DISCUSSION
Abstract
Introduction
Methods
Results
Discussion
References
and Haenlein (1992)
, the various components of caprine milk fat and fatty acids differ from bovine milk in both chain length and degree of saturation. Compared to bovine milk, caprine milk is higher in the content of short-chain fatty acids (6:0, C 8:0 and C 10:0) because of the high percentage of C 10:0 (Dils 1986
, Edelsten 1988
, Juarez 1986). In addition, caprine milk in general is higher in the minerals calcium, phosphorus, potassium and chlorine than bovine milk (Morand-Fehr and Flamant 1983
).
). Findings from this study, however, can not be generalized because Razafindrakoto et al.'s (1994) investigation used powdered caprine and bovine milk for 15 d to rehabilitate undernourished children.
). There was evidence of a greater concentration of circulating plasma levels of C18:2 in pigs fed caprine milk observed in the present study. In one digestibility study, Février et al. (1993)
reported that caprine milk fatty acids, especially C18:2, tended to be better absorbed than the bovine milk fatty acids when fed to pigs. Variations in circulating plasma levels of fatty acid from caprine milk in male and female pigs has not been reported in previous studies. Results presented here imply that male pigs had a greater plasma concentration of C 12:0 and C 18:2 than female pigs, whereas female pigs had higher plasma levels of C 18:1. The extent to which circulating plasma levels of fatty acids noted in this study would be observed in human infants has not been reported. It has been speculated, however, that the fat globules in caprine milk may facilitate greater digestion and absorption than bovine milk. In caprine milk, fat globules are smaller, do not cluster and have greater surface area than those of bovine milk (Jenness and Parkash 1971
).
). Results from Experiment 2 showed that circulating plasma levels of Na, K and P were higher in caprine milk-fed pigs than in those fed bovine milk. In addition, Park et al. (1986)
fed dehydrated caprine and bovine milk to anemic rats and reported that bioavailability of Fe from caprine milk was higher than Fe from bovine milk. In the present study, pigs fed caprine milk had higher plasma concentration of Fe at Day 28 compared to those fed bovine milk. These findings suggest that caprine milk-fed pigs may have had more Fe available for hemoglobin and oxygen transport to cells. Further studies are necessary to determine the basis for higher plasma concentrations in pigs fed caprine milk compared to those fed bovine milk. In addition, there is a need to compare the plasma mineral concentrations of human infants fed caprine and bovine milk to those observed in the pigs in this study.
, Senior 1968
). According to Bach and Babayan (1982)
short- and medium-chain fatty acid are digested, absorbed, and transported easily and rapidly; have a very low tendency to deposit as body fat; and are a source of abundant and rapidly available energy. In addition, Hashim and Tantibhedyangkul (1987)
reported that long chain triglyceride-fed rats were significantly heavier, with larger epididymal and subcutaneous fat pads, and larger number and size of adipocytes than the medium-chain triglyceride-fed rats. The effects of feeding infants a diet containing short- and medium-chain triglycerides early in life may influence body composition later in life by reducing obesity. For example, Hashim and Tantibhedyangkul (1987)
concluded that the type of fat in the diet fed early in life can influence the development of adipose tissue.
| |
FOOTNOTES |
|---|
Manuscript received 22 April 1998. Initial reviews completed 30 June 1998. Revision accepted 17 September 1998.
| |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
The authors gratefully express appreciation to the Agricultural Research Station at the Ft. Valley State University for supplying the caprine milk used in these studies and to Schauston Miller for pasteurizing and delivering the milk. We also thank Laura Holmes and Tommy Bass, Department of Animal Science, University of Georgia for technical assistance in the analytical and animal feeding phases of the experiments.
| |
LITERATURE CITED |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
S. M. Rutherfurd, A. J. Darragh, W. H. Hendriks, C. G. Prosser, and D. Lowry Mineral Retention in Three-Week-Old Piglets Fed Goat and Cow Milk Infant Formulas J Dairy Sci, December 1, 2006; 89(12): 4520 - 4526. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||