![]() |
|
|
The Procter & Gamble Company, Winton Hill Technical Center, Cincinnati, OH 45224 and * Hazleton-Wisconsin, Inc., Madison, WI 53707
Groups of weanling pigs (5 castrated males, 5 females per group) were fed purified diets containing the NRC's requirements for nutrients and 0, 1.1, 4.4 or 7.7% olestra for 12 wk. Graded concentrations of vitamins A, D2 and E were added at each olestra concentration. The primary purpose of the study was to establish relationships between dietary concentration of olestra and the amounts of vitamins A, D2 and E needed to restore tissue concentrations of these vitamins to control concentrations. A secondary purpose was to confirm that olestra does not affect the status of vitamin K or water-soluble nutrients. Liver concentrations of vitamins A, E and B12, iron and zinc and bone concentrations of ash, zinc, calcium and phosphorus, were measured in a group of pigs killed at the start of the study and in all pigs killed at wk 12. Growth, feed efficiency, hematology, clinical chemistry, blood concentrations of retinol,
-tocopherol, 25-hydroxyergocalciferol, 25-hydroxycholecalciferol, 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D, folate, iron, total iron-binding capacity, zinc and calcium and adipose concentration of vitamin E were measured at 4-wk intervals. Prothrombin time was measured weekly for the control and 7.7% olestra groups, monthly for others. Relationships derived from measured tissue concentrations of vitamins A and E showed that constant amounts of the vitamins were required per unit mass of olestra in the diet to restore tissue concentrations to control values. Such a relationship could not be determined for vitamin D because exposure of the pigs to UV light resulted in an apparent interaction between vitamin D2 and vitamin D3. Olestra did not affect growth, digestible feed efficiency, vitamin K status or the status of the water-soluble micronutrients, in agreement with other studies in the pig.
Olestra is a mixture of hexa-, hepta- and octaesters of sucrose formed from long-chain fatty acids derived from edible oils. Olestra (Olean, Procter & Gamble, Cincinnati, OH) has taste and cooking characteristics similar to those of traditional dietary fats and oils (Bernhardt 1988
, Kester 1993
) but is not absorbed (Mattson and Volpenhein 1972
, Miller et al. 1995
). Consequently, olestra contributes no energy to the diet and can serve as a zero-calorie replacement for conventional fats and oils. Olestra is approved for use in preparing savory snacks such as potato chips and crackers.
Because it is lipophilic and is not absorbed, olestra can interfere with the absorption of fat-soluble micronutrients such as the fat-soluble vitamins. This interference occurs because some portion of the fat-soluble vitamins in the gastrointestinal (GI)4 tract partitions into the olestra and therefore becomes unavailable to the micelle-mediated absorptive process (Jandacek 1982
). The extent to which olestra reduces the absorption of fat-soluble vitamins has been established in studies in the pig and in normal healthy human subjects (Cooper et al. 1997a
and 1997b, Schlagheck et al. 1997b
).
Animal and human studies have shown that olestra's effects on the absorption of fat-soluble vitamins can be offset by adding extra amounts of the vitamins to the diet. Mattson et al. (1979)
measured the liver vitamin A content of rats fed 15% olestra in a vitamin A-free casein-based diet supplemented with two concentrations of retinyl palmitate. After 3 d of consuming the diet, the rats were killed and the vitamin A content of the liver was measured. The total amounts of retinyl palmitate fed over the 3-d period were 0, 1230 and 2420 IU [0, 677 and 1331 RE (µg retinol equivalents), respectively]. The mean liver content of vitamin A for the three groups was <150 IU (<50 RE), 599 IU (180 RE) and 1143 IU (343 RE), respectively.
In another study, mice were fed 0, 2.5, 5 or 10% olestra for 2 y. The diets were supplemented with 2500 IU (1375 RE)/kg of vitamin A (retinyl palmitate), 750 IU (18.8 µg)/kg of vitamin D and 160-640 IU [107-429 mg
-tocopherol equivalents (
-TE)/kg of vitamin E] (Lafranconi et al. 1994
). Liver concentrations of vitamins A and E were measured periodically throughout the study; the serum concentration of total 25-hydroxyvitamin D [25(OH)D] was measured after 9 mo. The liver concentrations of vitamins A and E for the olestra-fed groups were comparable to control values. The serum 25(OH)D concentrations for the groups fed 2.5 or 5% olestra were comparable to control values; the concentrations for the group fed 10% olestra were 70 and 85% of control for males and females, respectively.
Free-living human subjects were given 18 g/d olestra with and without added d-
-tocopheryl acetate for 16 wk (Koonsvitsky et al. 1997
). Serum
-tocopherol concentration was reduced by 6%, relative to control, for the olestra group. The addition of 1.1 mg d-
-tocopheryl acetate/g olestra restored serum
-tocopherol concentration by about one third.
This study was undertaken to establish the relationship between the dietary concentration of olestra and the amount of vitamins A, D and E required to restore tissue concentrations of the vitamins to control concentrations, i.e., the restoration levels. It was of particular interest to determine whether the restoration level is a linear function of the dietary concentration of olestra. Another purpose of the study was to confirm that olestra does not affect vitamin K function, the status of water-soluble micronutrients or the absorption or utilization of macronutrients.
The study was conducted in the domestic pig. Previous studies have shown that the domestic pig is an appropriate model in which to evaluate the nutritional effects of olestra (Cooper et al. 1997c
, Daher et al. 1997
). The pig's GI anatomy and physiology are very similar to those of humans (Graham and Aman 1987
, Leary and Lecce 1976
), and its vitamin stores and nutritional indices respond to dietary changes (Miller and Ullrey 1987
). The dose-responsive effects of olestra on tissue concentrations of vitamins A and E and 25-hydroxyvitamin D2 have been established in the pig (Cooper et al. 1997c
).
|
Table 1. Treatment groups and target levels of vitamins A, D and E in diets fed to pigs for 12 wk1 |
). The high (HV) and low (LV) vitamin concentrations were chosen to provide tissue concentrations of the vitamins that evenly bracketed the concentration provided by the medium vitamin concentration, and to provide overlap in the range of vitamins added at each olestra concentration. The total dietary concentrations of vitamins A, D, and E are shown in Table 1, for each dietary concentration of olestra.
-tocopheryl acetate, and the extra vitamin D was added as ergocalciferol.
-c, Daher et al. 1997
). It was heated before being added to the diet, as described in Cooper et al. (1997b)
. The dietary concentrations tested, 1.1, 4.4 and 7.7%, were the low, medium and high dietary concentrations tested in a dose-response study in the pig (Cooper et al. 1997b
). The lowest concentration provided a daily intake at the start of the study (5-6 g/d) that is about twice the estimated mean human chronic intake of olestra from savory snacks, 3.1 g/d (Webb et al. 1997
). The highest dietary concentration, 7.7%, was the maximum concentration judged reasonable to test without potentially introducing nutritional deficiencies in the animals as a result of dilution of the diet with the nondigestible olestra (Borzelleca 1992
).
. The concentrations of other dietary nutrients and the homogeneity of the diets were confirmed by analysis. Because of a formulation error, the diets provided only about 6% of the NRC requirement for vitamin B12. The integrity of the study was unaffected by this lower-than-target concentration of the vitamin as discussed in a later section.
. These measured concentrations were used to calculate the extra amounts of vitamins A, D and E required to restore tissue concentrations of these vitamins to control concentrations for pigs fed olestra-containing diets.
where
C is the difference between individual and mean control tissue vitamin concentration, OA is the percentage of olestra in diet,
V is the amount of vitamin in the olestra-containing diet over and above the amount in the basal (control) diet, Bn are constants and error is the variability not explained by the model.
). The model assumed that there were no interactions among the vitamins.
|
Table 2. Average daily olestra consumption during wk 1, 6 and 12 by pigs fed olestra and graded levels of vitamins A, D, and E for 12 wk1 |
Table 3.
Cumulative energy consumption, cumulative weight gain and digestible feed efficiency for pigs fed olestra and graded levels of vitamins A, D and E for 12 wk1
) and similar to that observed for pigs fed a standard swine diet (Martin and Crenshaw 1989
).
) or in a 26-wk study in which pigs were fed up to 5.5% olestra (Cooper et al. 1997a
). Gastric ulcers are common in swine and are due to various etiologic factors (Reese et al. 1966
). Thus it is likely that the ulcer resulted from one or more of the processes that normally cause ulcers in swine.
Table 4.
Serum 25-hydroxycholecalciferol [25(OH)D3], serum total
25-hydroxyvitamin D [25(OH)D] and serum 1,25 dihydroxyvitamin D [1,25(OH)2D] concentrations for pigs fed olestra and graded levels of vitamin A, D and E for 12 wk1
Table 5.
Plasma prothrombin time (PT) for pigs fed olestra and graded levels of vitamins A, D and E for 12 wk1
Table 6.
Plasma folate concentration for pigs fed olestra and graded levels of vitamins A, D and E for 12 wk1
Table 7.
Liver vitamin B12 concentration for pigs fed olestra and graded levels of vitamins A, D and E for 12 wk1
Table 8.
Liver iron concentration, serum total iron-binding capacity (TIBC) and serum total iron concentration for pigs fed olestra and graded levels of vitamins A, D and E for 12 wk1
Table 9.
Liver, bone and serum zinc concentrations for pigs fed olestra and graded levels of vitamins A, D and E for 12 wk1
Table 10.
Amounts of ash, calcium and phosphorus in bone of pigs fed olestra and graded levels of vitamins A, D and E for 12 wk1
Table 11.
Serum calcium and inorganic phosphorus concentrations for pigs fed olestra and graded levels of vitamins
A, D and E for 12 wk1
Fig. 1.
Mean (±SD, n = 10) liver vitamin A concentrations for pigs fed 1.1, 4.4 or 7.7% olestra with graded levels for vitamins A, D and E for 12 wk. The horizontal dotted line represents the concentration for the control group. Values for each olestra level indicated by different letters are significantly different (P < 0.05).
[View Larger Version of this Image (20K GIF file)]
where
LA is the difference between the vitamin A liver concentration for a pig fed olestra with added vitamin A and the mean vitamin A liver concentration for the control group, OA is the dietary concentration of olestra (wt/wt%), and VA is the dietary concentration of vitamin A (IU/kg diet), i.e., the restoration level. The response surface produced by this equation showed that the relationship was essentially linear for the range of dietary olestra concentrations tested. To derive an expression describing the relationship between the restoration level of vitamin A (VA) and the dietary concentration of olestra (OA), this equation was solved for the three dietary concentrations of olestra tested, 1.1, 4.4 and 7.7%, by setting
LA equal to 0 and inserting the dietary concentration of olestra. Then a linear regression was performed on the three resulting values of VA , using a zero-intercept model. Figure 2 shows the linear relationship between VA , expressed as RE/kg diet and the dietary concentration of olestra, along with the specific restoration levels obtained from solution of the above equation for 1.1, 4.4 and 7.7% olestra. The equation for the relationship is as follows:
where RLA is the amount of vitamin A, expressed as RE/kg of diet, required to restore liver vitamin A concentration to the control concentration and OA is the dietary concentration of olestra, expressed as (wt/wt)% in the diet.
Fig. 2.
Relationship between the dietary level of olestra and the amount of vitamin A that must be added to the diet to restore liver vitamin A concentration to control level. The three points are the restoration levels calculated for the three levels of olestra tested. The line represents the equation RLA = 581(OA), obtained by linear regression of the points using a zero-intercept model, where RLA is the amount of vitamin A in IU/kg diet required to restore liver vitamin A concentration to control level and OA is the percentage of olestra in the diet.
[View Larger Version of this Image (13K GIF file)]
). This relationship was not true for many of the groups (Table C in the Appendix); therefore the serum data were not used to calculate a restoration level of vitamin A.
Fig. 3.
Mean (±SD, n = 10) liver vitamin E concentrations for pigs fed 1.1, 4.4 or 7.7% olestra with graded levels of vitamins A, D and E for 12 wk. The horizontal dotted line represents the concentration for the control group. Values for each olestra level indicated by different letters are significantly different (P < 0.05).
[View Larger Version of this Image (19K GIF file)]
where
LE is the difference between the liver concentration of vitamin E for a pig fed olestra with added vitamin E and the mean vitamin E liver concentration for the control group, OA is the dietary concentration of olestra (wt/wt%), and VE is the dietary concentration of vitamin E (
-TE/kg diet), i.e., the restoration level. As with vitamin A, the response surface produced by the above equation showed that the relationship is essentially linear over the range of olestra intakes tested.
where RLLE is expressed in
-TE/kg diet and OA is expressed as a percentage in the diet (wt/wt).
Fig. 4.
Relationship between the dietary level of olestra and the amount of vitamin E that must be added to the diet to restore liver vitamin E concentration to the control level. The three points are the restoration levels calculated for the three levels of olestra tested. The line represents the equation RLLE = 14.0(OA), obtained by linear regression of the points using a zero-intercept model, where RLLE is the amount of vitamin E in milligrams d-
-tocopherol acetate per kilogram of diet required to restore liver vitamin A concentration to control level and OA is the percentage of olestra in the diet.
[View Larger Version of this Image (12K GIF file)]
Fig. 5.
Mean (±SD, n = 10) serum vitamin E concentration for pigs fed 1.1, 4.4 or 7.7% olestra with graded levels of vitamins A, D and E for 12 wk. The horizontal dotted line represents the concentration for the control group. Values for each olestra level indicated by different letters are significantly different (P < 0.05).
[View Larger Version of this Image (18K GIF file)]
SE is the difference between the serum vitamin E concentration in a pig fed olestra for 12 wk and the mean serum vitamin E concentration for the control group. OA and VE are as defined above. Like the relationship derived from the liver vitamin E data, this relationship is essentially linear over the range of dietary concentrations of olestra tested.
where the restoration level, RLSE , is expressed as
-TE/kg diet and OA is expressed as a percentage in the diet (wt/wt). This equation agrees closely with that derived from the liver vitamin E concentration.
Fig. 6.
Relationship between the dietary level of olestra and the amount of vitamin E that must be added to the diet to restore serum vitamin E concentration to control level. The three points are the restoration levels calculated for the three levels of olestra tested. The line represents the equation RLSE = 14.0(OA), obtained by linear regression of the points using a zero-intercept model, where RLSE is the amount of vitamin E in milligrams d-
-tocopherol acetate per kilogram of diet required to restore serum vitamin A concentration to control level and OA is the percentage of oletra in the diet.
[View Larger Version of this Image (11K GIF file)]
Fig. 7.
Mean (±SD, n = 10) serum ergocalciferol concentrations for pigs fed 1.1, 4.4 or 7.7% olestra with graded levels of vitamins A, D and E for 12 wk. The horizontal dotted line represents the concentration for the control group. Values for each olestra level indicated by different letters are significantly different (P < 0.05).
[View Larger Version of this Image (18K GIF file)]
). In that study, serum 25(OH)D2 concentration increased and serum 25-hydroxycholecalciferol [25(OH)D3] concentration decreased when the dietary concentration of olestra was increased above 3.3%. Similar changes occurred in this study. Because of this interaction, a relationship describing the dependence of the restoration level on the dietary concentration of olestra was not developed for vitamin D.
The large daily amounts of olestra fed in this study were well tolerated by the pigs. During wk 1 of the study, pigs in the 1.1% olestra groups ate about twice the estimated mean human chronic intake of olestra from savory snacks, 3.1 g/d (Webb et al. 1997
). Pigs in the 7.7% groups ate almost seven times the 90th-percentile chronic intake, 6.9 g/d. By the end of the study, the pigs were consuming from ~20 to ~160 g/d of olestra, 6-52 times the mean human chronic intake. No antemortem observations or changes in clinical chemistry or hematology measures indicated an adverse effect of olestra on the pigs' general health.
). No differences were seen among the groups in digestible feed efficiency, an indication that olestra does not affect the absorption and utilization of macronutrients. This finding is consistent with observations in other pig studies (Cooper et al. 1997a
and 1997b).
and 1997b). This behavior is consistent with the fact that liver stores of vitamin E are mobilized rapidly when vitamin E intake is reduced; they become depleted in parallel with the circulating pool (Bieri 1972
, Bunnell et al. 1975
, Horwitt et al. 1956
). In this study, liver and serum concentrations of vitamin E responded in a parallel manner to addition of vitamin E to the olestra-containing diets. These observations indicate that serum vitamin E concentration is a reliable measure of vitamin E status and can be reliably used to monitor vitamin E status in humans.
, Machlin et al. 1979
). Because of the large size and the slower response of the adipose vitamin E pool to changes in vitamin E intake, it might be hypothesized that adipose stores of the vitamin would buffer changes in other tissue stores. The changes in liver, serum and adipose concentrations of vitamin E observed in this and other studies in the pig do not support that hypothesis (Cooper et al. 1997a
and 1997b).
) and in pigs not exposed to ultraviolet light (Cooper et al. 1997a
). The serum concentrations of 25(OH)D2 for the groups fed 1.1% olestra and graded concentrations of ergocalciferol in this study showed that serum concentration of 25(OH)D2 could be restored. Although it was not possible to develop a relationship between the serum 25(OH)D2 concentration and the dietary concentrations of ergocalciferol and olestra, as was done for vitamins A and E, the similarities in the responses of tissue concentrations of all of the vitamins to dietary concentrations of the vitamins and olestra suggest that a similar relationship exists between vitamin D restoration concentration and dietary olestra concentration.
). No such interaction was observed in humans (Schlagheck et al. 1997a
and 1997b) or in pigs fed up to 5.5% olestra for 26 wk without being exposed to ultraviolet light (Cooper et al. 1997a
). A restoration level for vitamin D, 0.07 µg ergocalciferol/g olestra, was determined from the human data (Schlagheck et al. 1997a
).
-hydroxylase and 2 ) the interference with the reabsorption of vitamin D3 and 25(OH)D3 secreted in the bile. Vitamin D3 is the preferred substrate for 25-
-hydroxylase in pigs (Horst et al. 1982
); therefore a decrease in the availability of vitamin D3 would be expected to lead to an increase in serum 25(OH)D2 . Both vitamin D3 and 25(OH)D3 are secreted in the bile and some fraction of each is reabsorbed (Arnuad et al. 1975, Avioli et al. 1967
).
). It is postulated that this decline results from an interference with the enterohepatic circulation of the metabolite, which occurs when the metabolite binds to the fiber. Reductions in vitamin D status have also been seen in patients with malabsorption syndromes that involve interference with the reabsorption of biliary-derived substances (Batchelor et al. 1982
, Compston et al. 1982
).
). In that study, the contribution to total vitamin D status coming from the diet was ~10-15%, a contribution typical of individuals living in northern latitudes in winter (Jones 1978
, Jones et al. 1991
). Olestra also did not affect overall vitamin D status in subjects consuming 20 g/d olestra along with a 20-µg daily capsule of ergocalciferol for 6 wk (Jones et al. 1991
) or in subjects consuming up to 32 g/d olestra for 8 wk (Schlagheck et al. 1997b
).
). The same effect has been seen in other pig studies (Cooper et al. 1997a
and 1997b).
and 1997b) and studies in humans (Koonsvitsky et al. 1997
, Schlagheck et al. 1997a
and 1997b).
The authors thank V. A. Spendel and D. H. Tallmadge for analytical support and L. J. Bishop, J. Matiunas, S. J. Middleton and K. D. Lawson for assistance in preparing the manuscript.
-TE, mg
-tocopherol equivalents; GI, gastrointestinal; HV, high vitamin; LV, low vitamin; MV, medium vitamin; OA, percentage olestra; 1,25(OH)2D, 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D; 25(OH)D, total 25-hydroxyvitamin D; 25(OH)D2 , 25-hydroxyergocalciferol; 25(OH)D3 , 25-hydroxycholecalciferol; PT, prothrombin time; RE, µg retinol equivalents; TIBC, total iron-binding capacity.
DIETARY VITAMINS AND OLESTRA: APPENDIX
|
|
![]() |
|
|
![]() |
|
|
![]() |
|
|
![]() |
|
|
![]() |
|
|
![]() |
|
|
![]() |
|
|
![]() |
|
|
![]() |
a non-caloric fat replacement.
Food Tech. Intl.-Europe
1988;
1988:176-178
-tocopherol depletion and repletion.
Ann. N.Y. Acad. Sci.
1972;
203:181-191 [Medline][Medline]
-tocopherol and carotenoids but not vitamin D or vitamin K status in free-living subjects.
J. Nutr.
1997;
127:1636S-1645S
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||