Some Factors Affecting the Connective Tissue Content of Beef Muscle
H. H. Mitchell,
T. S. Hamilton and
W. T. Haines
(From the Division of Animal Nutrition, Department of Animal Husbandry, University of Illinois, Urbana, Illinois)
1. An improved method of determining the collagen and elastinin uncooked animal tissues is described, and its accuracy ismeasured and discussed. The results of its application to beefmuscle from carcasses of definite antecedents and descriptionare given.
2. No constant and significant differences in connectivetissuecontent were found between heifer and steer beef.
3.Among different retail cuts of beef examined, the eye-muscleof the rib possessed for practically all calves examined thelowest content of collagen, expressed as collagen nitrogen inper cent of total nitrogen. The tenderloin was only slightlyhigher. The round, porterhouse and sirloin were next in orderand were indistinguishable from each other in this respect.The chuck ribs and the navel contained consistently larger percentagesof collagen nitrogen than the more expensive cuts, but the foreshanks of all calves contained the highest, the collagen nitrogenof this cut averaging 23 per cent of the total nitrogen of thelean. The outer round generally contained more collagen thanthe inner round.
4. The percentage of elastin in muscle isonly a small, in mostcases an insignificant, fraction of thepercentage of collagen.The distribution of elastin among thedifferent retail cutsof meat differs from the distributionof collagen, but appearsto be as consistent and as significant.
5. Age does not seem to have a great effect upon the connectivetisse content of muscle meat, nor a consistent effect amongthe different muscles of the carcass. However, much of the dataobtained on this point were so irregular as to preculde anydefinite conclusions.
6. No relation at all was noted betweenthe ordinary marketgrading of beef carcasses and the connectivetissue contentof the lean of the rib (eye) or of the round.Insofar as thetenderness of meat is related to its contentof connective tissue,the results obtained in this investigationlend no support tothe belief that the appearance, texture andfirmness of itslean gives reliable information concerning itstenderness.
7. No obvious relation was found between the gradingof beefcarcasses and the fat content of the lean of selectedsamples.